Coach Top 20 coaches by career win percentage

Remove this Banner Ad

What was Malcolm Blight's win %. Obviously it would have taken a hit at the end there with the Saints but still would have thought it would be reasonably high based on Geelong's GF appearances and Adelaide's flags.

Was he ever actually coaching the saints though? I know he got paid, so I guess you take the stats too.
But as for coaching the saints: he was succeeding tim Watson, so the bar was basically on the floor.
 
Was he ever actually coaching the saints though? I know he got paid, so I guess you take the stats too.
But as for coaching the saints: he was succeeding tim Watson, so the bar was basically on the floor.
Some of Blightys coaching techniques Ive heard from past players are legendary. Took the entire team into a room after a loss and turned all the lights off and went berserk, would pause for a few seconds, then go apeshit in another part of the room without warning. :tearsofjoy:
 
King Dick quietly reminding everyone he's in the running for greatest player and best coach. I understand the love for Hird and Sheedy but Reynolds was blindingly good, by all accounts. Took three Brownlows playing against guys like Chicken Smallhorn, Haydn Bunton and Harry Collier, so probably one of the few cases the medal means something.

Not so sure about his flags, my old man called the flags in the 1940's "firemen and policemen's premierships" as those jobs were exempt from the draft, and Melbourne and Essendon seemed to have a lot of exempt players: that may be sour grapes. Still made the GF a lot and won 3 after the war as well as 1 during it.

Norm Smith the Melbourne hero because he's two thirds as good as McHale. Parleyed home ground advantage into a finals dynasty so good luck to him, but he gets a statue and a medal named after him for being maybe the third best ever coach. Pure politics.

Chris Scott is Geelongs best ever coach. Imagine if they had a decent administration, the Hawks turn advantage like that into 4-5 flag runs.

Good coaches two-peat. Great coaches three-peat.

Winning flags from time to time is a bit meh.
And what sort of coach 4peats?
Tongue Goat GIF
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Some of Blightys coaching techniques Ive heard from past players are legendary. Took the entire team into a room after a loss and turned all the lights off and went berserk, would pause for a few seconds, then go apeshit in another part of the room without warning. :tearsofjoy:

I've heard about that one. Haha could you imagine feeling his saliva hit your face in the dark 🤣
 
I've heard about that one. Haha could you imagine feeling his saliva hit your face in the dark 🤣
Ejecting the video tape out of the VCR and ditching it full pelt at Billy Brownless because he watching a plane out of the window instead of the game footage they were reviewing is still one of the funniest things Ive heard
 
King Dick quietly reminding everyone he's in the running for greatest player and best coach. I understand the love for Hird and Sheedy but Reynolds was blindingly good, by all accounts. Took three Brownlows playing against guys like Chicken Smallhorn, Haydn Bunton and Harry Collier, so probably one of the few cases the medal means something.

Not so sure about his flags, my old man called the flags in the 1940's "firemen and policemen's premierships" as those jobs were exempt from the draft, and Melbourne and Essendon seemed to have a lot of exempt players: that may be sour grapes. Still made the GF a lot and won 3 after the war as well as 1 during it.

Norm Smith the Melbourne hero because he's two thirds as good as McHale. Parleyed home ground advantage into a finals dynasty so good luck to him, but he gets a statue and a medal named after him for being maybe the third best ever coach. Pure politics.

Chris Scott is Geelongs best ever coach. Imagine if they had a decent administration, the Hawks turn advantage like that into 4-5 flag runs.


And what sort of coach 4peats?
Tongue Goat GIF

Cheats who ran the game is a way which guaranteed them grand final appearances and rematches when they lost the grand final.

How crap have the Pies been since they ended that crap in the early 1930s?
 
Interesting while we are on win percentages, Chris Scott has the 13th highest finals win % of all current coaches.

Even more interesting is Chris Scott does not even possess the highest finals win percentage coached in his own family. 🙂
Chris Scott did well to get us as far as he did from 2012-2021 given the limited cattle he had at his disposal in the forward 50.
It's no coincidence Scott's finals record has improved greatly since he's had an A grade forward line at his disposal.
Yeah but he has four flags to his name, so at that point, the empty statistic known as 'winning percentage!' becomes utterly irrelevant....
How many AFLCA Coach of the Year awards has Clarkson won?
Clarkson's head to head record against Chris Scott isn't great either.
 
Chris Scott did well to get us as far as he did from 2012-2021 given the limited cattle he had at his disposal in the forward 50.
It's no coincidence Scott's finals record has improved greatly since he's had an A grade forward line at his disposal.
It's a good point, and one not really mentioned as much as just stating that they changed the game plan etc.

The starting forward line for the 2020 Grand Final had Mark O'Connor and a highly cooked Luke Dalhaus trying to win us a flag. Really makes you think that we did pretty well to get there.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Cheats who ran the game is a way which guaranteed them grand final appearances and rematches when they lost the grand final.

How crap have the Pies been since they ended that crap in the early 1930s?
Play by the rules=cheats? Lol cope and seethe.

I don't blame Hawthorn for taking the zone rort recruits, they've done ok even since that was stopped, but your club was literally nothing until the league started spoon feeding minnows.

When the playing field was truly level, Collingwood ruled. You're an assisted success story, paid for by Collingwood. You're welcome.
 
It's a good point, and one not really mentioned as much as just stating that they changed the game plan etc.

The starting forward line for the 2020 Grand Final had Mark O'Connor and a highly cooked Luke Dalhaus trying to win us a flag. Really makes you think that we did pretty well to get there.

But hang on, wasn't Hawkins the best finals in the game according to AA selectors, Dangerfield played forward, 8 x AA. Ablett Jnr supposed to be the GOAT. Miers supposed to be all that. All these other great adaptable players like Henry, Duncan, thought they were supposed to be guns?

And Tigers less AA selections forward that night and the likes of Castagna.

If Scott had a shit forward line it is because he spent all his money in other areas of the ground. That's on him.
 
But hang on, wasn't Hawkins the best finals in the game according to AA selectors, Dangerfield played forward, 8 x AA. Ablett Jnr supposed to be the GOAT. Miers supposed to be all that. All these other great adaptable players like Henry, Duncan, thought they were supposed to be guns?

And Tigers less AA selections forward that night and the likes of Castagna.

If Scott had a shit forward line it is because he spent all his money in other areas of the ground. That's on him.
Hawkins yes, one of his best years in 2020 of course but Ablett was on his last legs, Miers just starting out, J Henry was almost always a backman, Duncan & Danger not true forwards at all even if they spent some time there.

Whatever the exact mix was in 2020, it was not a very good forward line and much weaker when compared with our 2022 group when we had Jez, Stengle & Close (all firing), as well as a vastly improved Miers. Even Rohan was in the form of his life just about and Hawkins was still doing his thing.
 
Last edited:
Why are Port so desperate to get rid of Ken when he’s top 10 all time? One of the icons of the game based on these stats
Maybe because despite being there 12 years and being top 10 all-time, he's only had one finals series where Port has won more than 1 final?

I don't mean that as an insult to Ken, I'm trying to understand Port fans' frustrations.

I'm a Carlton supporter, none of our coaches last long enough to make these lists...
 
I think you have to remove their first 3-year win/loss record, then analyse.

Chris Scott started his coaching career with a team containing about a dozen AA players that had gone flag/RU/flag/PF in the preceding 4-years.

Hardwick took over a team containing no AA players that was a rabble and had limited access to top end talent due to GWS and GC.

And Fagan js not even in that list … because he went to a team who’d just lost 5 x quality players to other teams and was in a developing state needing to start from scratch.

So remove the first 3-years of Hardwick, Fagan and Scott and what are their respective win/loss records?


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com


Yeah Scott’s percentage plummets all the way down to 66 per cent. He’s really struggled in the years that have followed.


Hardwick’s - also with the generosity of removing his season with the Gold Coast just so you didn’t cry about the tough task of having to go to another new team - ‘skyrockets’ past Scott.

61 is a higher number than 66, isn’t it?
 
Last edited:
These guys who coach for a lot of games with a high win % don't overly impress me. Must be an awesome gig when things are going right.

Bill Stephen coached 258 games with a 32.9% win rate.

Now there's a hero.

He had a reputation as a very good coach. As did another Fitzroy coach Len Smith(Norm's brother) to an even greater extent. L Smith had a win % of 57% over 5 seasons at Fitzroy but was 0-3 from 3 finals there.
 
Maybe because despite being there 12 years and being top 10 all-time, he's only had one finals series where Port has won more than 1 final?

I don't mean that as an insult to Ken, I'm trying to understand Port fans' frustrations.

I'm a Carlton supporter, none of our coaches last long enough to make these lists...
If Vossy doesn't take you to the promised land would you consider welcoming Ken down to Ikon Park?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Coach Top 20 coaches by career win percentage

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top