Opinion Top 50 2013

Remove this Banner Ad

From Round 6 - Coll v St K:
9. Pendlebury
8. Riewoldt, Thomas
7. Cloke, Montagna, Roberton, Shaw, Jolly
6. Swan, O'Brien, Reid, McEvoy, Armitage, Macaffer, Geary
5. Clarke, Seedsman, Steven, Siposs
4. Jones, Fisher, Dempster
3. Dal Santo, Lynch, Elliot, Brown, Stanley, Blair
2. Sidebottom, Milne, Gilbert, Dwyer
 
From Round 6 - Ess v GWS:
8. Cameron
7. Zaharakis, Hooker, Dempsey
6. Hibberd, Crameri, Davey, Townsend
5. Baguley, Myers, Goddard, Howlett, Hardingham, Giles
4. Coniglio, Mohr, Adams, Treloar, Scully, Hocking, Gumbleton
3. Watson, Greene, Palmer, Melksham, Ward, Shiel, Smith, Hille, Bellchambers
2. Pears, Stanton, Bugg
 
From Round 6 - NM v PA:
8. Cunnington, Bastinac, Boak
7. Thompson, Swallow, Cornes, Petrie, Goldstein
6. Gray, Ziebell, Jonas, Schulz, Wells, Firrito, Wingard, Ebert
5. Monfries, Cassisi,
4. Black, Mullett, Wines
3. Thomas, Atley, Gibson, Carlile
2. Hartlett, Westhoff, MacMillan, McMahon, Heath
1. Stewart
 

Log in to remove this ad.

From Round 6 - Adel v Haw:
9. Dangerfield
8. Stratton, Gibson
7. Hodge, Talia, Breust, Roughead
6. Mitchell, Thompson, Rutten, I. Smith, Hill, Puopolo, Reilly
5. Gunston, Vince, Lake, Sloane, Mackay, B. Smith
4. Hale, Douglas, Otten, Jacobs
3. Birchall, Sewell, Burgoyne, Jenkins, Porplyzia
2. Franklin, Osborne, Wright
 
From Round 6 - Rich v Geel:
9. Christensen
8. Stokes, Johnson, Enright
7. Kelly, Duncan, Bartel, Edwards
6. Guthrie, West, Martin, King
5. Taylor, Blicavs, Selwood, Knights, Chaplin, Hunt, Ellis, Morris
4. Maric, Riewoldt, Corey, Ellis, Houli, Jackson, Petterd, Grigg
3. Deledio, Cotchin, Hawkins, McGaune, Mackie, Newman, Rance
2. Podsiadly, Motlop
1. Vickery, Horlin-Smith
 
From Round 6 - Carl v Melb:
8. Garlett, Henderson, Murphy
7. Betts, Lucas, Jamison, Waite, Walker
6. Scotland, Robinson, Warnock, White, M. Jones
5. Curnow, Simpson, Garland, Dunn, Slyvia, N. Jones
4. Armfield, McLean, Hampson, Ellard, Evans, Terlich, Frawley, Tapscott
3. Tuohy, Judd
2. Yarran, Viney, Gawn
1. Trengove, Howe, Byrnes
0. Grimes
 
From Round 6 - Syd v Bris:
8. Jack, Hannebery, Maceski
7. Pyke, Jetta, O'Keefe, Hanley
6. Reid, McVeigh, Smith, Parker, Lester
5. Rockliff, Moloney, Kennedy, Adcock, Redden, Richards
4. Leuenberger, Goodes, Grundy, Polkinghorne, Golby
3. Bolton, Mumford, Mattner, Mayes, Zorko, Merrett, Patfull
2. McGlynn, Green, Paparone
 
From Round 8 - GCS v Frem:
8. Griffin, Harbrow
7. Walters, McPharlin
6. Ablett, O'Meara, Mundy, Suban, Ibbotson, Crozier, Crowley
5. Duffield, Spurr, Broughton, Swallow, Mzungu, C. Pearce, Stanley, Johnson
4. Prestia, Barlow, Day, Shaw, Mayne, Dawson
3. Bennell, Smith, Brennan, Rischitelli, D. Pearce
2. Dixon, Ballantyne
1. Matera, Hall
 
eaglespremiers said:
From Round 6 - Ess v GWS:
8. Cameron
7. Zaharakis, Hooker, Dempsey
6. Hibberd, Crameri, Davey, Townsend
5. Baguley, Myers, Goddard, Howlett, Hardingham, Giles
4. Coniglio, Mohr, Adams, Treloar, Scully, Hocking, Gumbleton
3. Watson, Greene, Palmer, Melksham, Ward, Shiel, Smith, Hille, Bellchambers
2. Pears, Stanton, Bugg
Click to expand...

Think Watson was a 4. Gumby a 5-6. Hibberd a 7. Scully a 5. Hille a 4. Hooker a 6. Mohr a 5. Melksham a 4. Bellchambers a 2.
 
Here's round 6:

top50-round-6.jpg
 
Kennedy should probably be in the 50 but other than that i cant really say any other West Coast players should be in there. I'm assuming Selwood,Masten,Shuey are in the 50-70 range at the moment.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

WCEbrody said:
Kennedy should probably be in the 50 but other than that i cant really say any other West Coast players should be in there. I'm assuming Selwood,Masten,Shuey are in the 50-70 range at the moment.
Click to expand...

Missed the 50 by one point so in the 51-55 range.
To get in to the 50 you needed to have 35pts this week.
Masten is on 33pts, Shuey is on 32pts and Scooter is on 28pts.
So both Masten and Shuey are close.
I'm not sure what Roobs321 is complaining about?
 
Your rankings are a bit more elaborate than mine. I've only been ranking the top 10 players in every game but for the hell of it here's my top 20. Hope you don't mind me posting it in your thread. Your rankings in brackets.

1. Boak (2)
2. Jack (5)
3. Watson (4)
4. Cornes (6)
5. Harbrow (13)
6. N Riewoldt (8)
7. Ablett (7)
8. Swallow (11)
9. Hannebery (1)
10. Westhoff (44)
11. Cloke (25)
12. Stokes (14)
13. A Walker (31)
14. Birchall (22)
15. Garlett (NA)
16. Dixon (NA)
17. McVeigh (9)
18. Hibberd (20)
19. Sloane (35)
20. J Selwood (29)
 
Think the list is outstanding personally.

Way to much bias in other lists around the place, some much deserved unheralded players in there.

Can't argue with any of it, although, I'm not sure how Hartlett got 2 votes last round.
 
Pykie said:
Think the list is outstanding personally.

Way to much bias in other lists around the place, some much deserved unheralded players in there.

Can't argue with any of it, although, I'm not sure how Hartlett got 2 votes last round.
Click to expand...

Thanks mate, appreciate the comments.
TBH I'm not sure why I gave Hartlett 2 either. Should've been 1.
 
From Round 7 - Haw v Syd:
9. Hodge
8. Roughead
7. Kennedy, Breust, Gibson
6. Goodes, Pyke, Lake, Hale, Stratton, Gunston
5. McGlynn, Mitchell, Jack, Richards, Lewis, Bird, Puopolo
4. Franklin, Birchall, Sewell, Jetta, Parker, McVeigh, O'Keefe
3. Hannebery, Burgoyne, Bailey, I. Smith, Bolton, Grundy, N. Smith, Shiels
2. Hill, Malceski, Reid
 
From Round 7 - Frem v Coll:
8. Walters, Ibbotson
7. Duffield, Barlow
6. Swan, Sidebottom, Dwyer, Mayne, J. Thomas, McPharlin, Crowley
5. Reid, Dawson, Blair, C. Pearce, Seedsman, Shaw, Mundy
4. Pendlebury, Jolly, Mzungu, Silvagni, D. Thomas, Hannath, Sutcliffe, Macaffer
3. Krakouer, D. Pearce, Johnson, O'Brien, N. Brown
2. Cloke, Ballantyne, Crozier, Lynch, Maxwell
1. Elliott
0. Griffin, Clarke

Would love feedback on this as I haven't watched the game.
 
From Round 7 - Melb v GCS:
8. Smith, Ablett
7. Prestia, Bennell
6. Thompson, Swallow, Brennan
5. Shaw, Day, O'Meara, C. Brown, Lynch, Viney, T. McKenzie
4. Howe, Broughton, Hall, Stanley, Gawn, Terlich
3. Harbrow, Sylvia, N. Jones, M. Jones, Nicholson
2. Frawley, Matera, Sellar, Evans, Garland, Spencer, May
1. Hutchins, Bail, Davey, Byrnes, Tapscott, Dawes, J. McKenzie
 
From Round 7 - Bris v WCE:
8. Glass, Hurn
7. Mackenzie, Rockliff
6. Kennedy, Leuenberger, S. Selwood, Naitanui, Hanley, Priddis
5. Rosa, Moloney, J. Clarke, M. Brown, Golby, Patfull, Raines
4. Dalziell, Sheppard, Redden, Cox, Schofield, J. Hill, Adcock
3. Wellingham, LeCras, Bewick, Merrett, Black, Lester, Mayes, Shuey
2. Gaff, J. Brown, Darling, A. Smith, Zorko, Green
 
From Round 7 - Geel v Ess:
8. Stokes, Johnson
7. Carlisle, Motlop, Zaharakis
6. Lonergan, Enright, Bartel, Podsiadly, Hocking, Kelly, Watson
5. Bellchambers, Hooker, Goddard, Myers, Christensen, Hibberd, Blicavs
4. Howlett, Thurlow, Selwood, Guthrie, Melksham, Kommer, Mackie
3. Heppell, Horlin-Smith, Hardingham, Fletcher, Taylor, Duncan
2. Hawkins, Crameri, Hurley, Gumbleton, Winderlich, Davey, West
1. Lovett-Murray
0. T. Hunt
 
From Round 7 - WB v NM:
9. Griffin
8. Ziebell, Daw, Goldstein
7. Black, Petrie
6. Atley, Gibson, Thompson, Cunnington, Minson
5. Hansen, Lower, Dahlhaus, Murphy, Harvey, Morris, Markovic
4. Swallow, Thomas, Young, Boyd, Giansiracusa
3. Liberatore, Wallis, MacMillan, Picken, McMahon, Firrito, Mullett, Wright, Adams, Cooney
2. Roughead, Jones, Cross, C. Smith, Wells
 
From Round 7 - GWS v Adel:
9. T. Lynch
8. Dangerfield
7. Wright, Kerridge, Thompson
6. Reilly, Ward, Douglas, Sloane, Vince
5. Talia, Jenkins, Mackay
4. van Berlo, Treloar, Scully, Rutten, Brown
3. Cameron, Tomlinson, Jacobs, Otten, B. Smith, Gilham, Whitfield
2. Adams, Greene, Giles
1. Mohr, Coniglio, Townsend, Shiel, Brogan
 
From Round 7 - PA v Rich:
9. Deledio
8. Martin
7. Riewoldt, Newman
6. Ellis, Calile, Vlastuin, Stephenson, O'Shea
5. Edwards, Wingard, Schulz, King, Rance, Tuck
4. Mitchell, Boak, Cornes, Ebert, Grigg, Redden, Monfries, Maric, Cornes
3. McGuane, Gray, Westhoff, Jackson, Wines, Stevenson, Batchelor, Chaplin
2. Knights, Jonas, Foley
1. Hartlett, Neade, Stewart
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Top 50 2013

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top