Trade: Andrew Lovett

[Ben the Gooner]

Put any Lovett related stuff in here.

Sydney seem to be the front runners, and pick 12 or O'Keefe seem to be the targets.

I'd be happy with Lovett + 23/39 for 12.

 

[Colin D'Cops]

I'd be happy with Lovett + 23/39 for 12.

I'd be happy with that but if a PP was offered for Lovett, I'd take that first.

If either of them deals don't go through and we don't get an early second round pick or late first rounder that we're after, I'm quite happy for us to hang onto him for another year.

 

[ant555]

Would be nice if they did give us pick 12

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

Lovett + 23 for 12 seems fair for both teams.

 

[Essendonfc_4_lyfe]

A first rounder would be a nice result.

Clubs interested: Sydney, Fremante, Eagles. The only problem i see, is that Freo and the Eagles can offer a late first round pick, but would be interesting to see what they throw up.

 

[carmi99]

Is there a way we could trade Lovett for pick 12 without giving up pick 23?

Lovett and another player for 12?

It would be great to have pick 5,12,23.

 

[The Dustbin]

A first rounder can't be ruled out completely, particularly when your dealing with Sydney.

How good would it be if we can their pick 12?

Having said that, I'd be just as happy if Lovett stayed a Bomber.

 

[Charliebrow16]

Lovett + 23 for 12 seems fair for both teams.

This is what was suggested in the merged threads. It's probably my favourite trade involving Lovett at this stage. Pick twelve looks very good.

 

[Charliebrow16]

Is there a way we could trade Lovett for pick 12 without giving up pick 23?

Lovett and another player for 12?

It would be great to have pick 5,12,23.

I heard that Sydney were interested in Stanton but trading both Lovett and Stanton for pick twelve would be very foolish.

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

Is there a way we could trade Lovett for pick 12 without giving up pick 23?

Lovett and another player for 12?

It would be great to have pick 5,12,23.

Lovett + Dyson for 12.

Or on a more serious note, Lovett + Hislop for 12 and maybe Sydney's 4th round pick.

 

[The Dustbin]

Lovett + Dyson for 12.

Or on a more serious note, Lovett + Hislop for 12 and maybe Sydney's 4th round pick.

Sounds good to me, the Lovett + Dyson for 12 that is. I'd like to see Tom for another season, see what he's got.

 

[carmi99]

Lovett + Dyson for 12.

Or on a more serious note, Lovett + Hislop for 12 and maybe Sydney's 4th round pick.

Hislpp hasnt had much of a chance to show what he is got but i wouldnt be against that trade.

We have quite a few hard at it MIDS coming along so it wouldn't leave a big hole.

 

[Hirdman]

I have heard Hislop re-signed, anyone??

I hate to say it but I dont think we are going to get a first rounder for Lovett, the Lovett + 23 for 12 would be a real result for us. If not expect a 2nd rounder, I think he will be traded though!!

 

[Charliebrow16]

on a more serious note, Lovett + Hislop for 12 and maybe Sydney's 4th round pick.

I couldn't see Sydney accepting it. They have more than enough players similar to Hislop. They'd want a player that they are generally interested in.

 

[Ben the Gooner]

I couldn't see Sydney accepting it. They have more than enough players similar to Hislop. They'd want a player that they are generally interested in.

They were apparantly interested in him, though.

 

[Tambu]

Lovett + pick 23 to Sydney for pick 12 + 30

Pick 5 - Hurley
Pick 12 - Swift

 

[Charliebrow16]

Lovett + pick 23 to Sydney for pick 12 + 30

Pick 5 - Hurley
Pick 12 - Swift

Post of the year?

This has been my thinking ever since I started believing that we could possibly get pick twelve.

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

Lovett + pick 23 to Sydney for pick 12 + 30

Pick 5 - Hurley
Pick 12 - Swift

That would give us picks 5, 12, 30 and 39 inside the top 40 and considering the depth of this years draft that would be a great result.

 

[bomba4eva]

Put any Lovett related stuff in here.

Sydney seem to be the front runners, and pick 12 or O'Keefe seem to be the targets.

I'd be happy with Lovett + 23/39 for 12.

23 + Lovett should be able to snare pick 12. Initially I wanted an extra pick thrown in my Sydney but Im not sure if that is plausible. Their 3rd rounder was my line of thinking. So in essence:
Lovett + 23 for Pick 12 + 46.

That way we don't have to utilise a later pick because we are trading 2 for 2 instead of getting the quality Pick 12 but then having to use 55 and perhaps another pick after that.

 

[Phat Toni]

Put any Lovett related stuff in here.

Sydney seem to be the front runners, and pick 12 or O'Keefe seem to be the targets.

I'd be happy with Lovett + 23/39 for 12.

I just wrote something similar in another thread. Couldn’t agree more with using Lovett and picks to upgrade to pick 12. We would then be able to target the two areas that need the most attention like maybe draft Hurley for the defense then Swift with pick 12 as a inside/outside midfielder. The more I see and read of Swift the more I like the thought of him in a Bombers jumper, seems like that balanced midfielder we need to off set the one dimensional midfielders we have.

 

[Yoda_]

I am thinking that Swift will be picked up before 12, with him testing so well, I would prefer Swift at 5, and one of Trengove or Lisle at 12,

 

[Tippaz]

forget pick12, i want Ryan O'Keefe.

Lovett + pick39 for O'Keefe

the history of picks 10-20 are pretty much hit-and-miss -> and mainly "handy" players rather than stars. i don't want pick 12.
O'Keefe will be 28 next year. i think he's worth a mid 1st round draft pick (8-10). i rate Lovett late 1st round (14-16), so an extra 3rd rounder should sweeten the deal.

 

[DonMania#5]

I would accept that, would be a good deal

 

[Dick johnson]

forget pick12, i want Ryan O'Keefe.

Lovett + pick39 for O'Keefe

the history of picks 10-20 are pretty much hit-and-miss -> and mainly "handy" players rather than stars. i don't want pick 12.
O'Keefe will be 28 next year. i think he's worth a mid 1st round draft pick (8-10). i rate Lovett late 1st round (14-16), so an extra 3rd rounder should sweeten the deal.

but in the strength of this draft, that 10-20 range will hold some gems

 

[sikmoe]

I honestly don't know why some people want O'Keefe, he will be 28 in January, so he will only have about 2-3 good years in him. We will possibly be a flag contender by 2011-2012. Do we really need him in our team?