Trades: Round 9

[trueblue_91]

Symes to either S Fisher or Birchall.....trying to do as much research as i can but they are pretty even.

Birchall- super consistent but rarely gets a 100+
Fisher- depends what his role is. Inconsistent but can get a big score

both averaging around 80 with Fisher 15k less than Birchall.

A point i am considering is that with guerra out for a few weeks Birchall might take on the role as the free man in defense.....Still got a lot of thinking to do

 

[Ole Gill]

well if u havent done these trades, then keep Stanton give him one more week at least

Already done.

To be honest, getting rids of Stanton is due to my frustration with players who go up and down all the time. Even he racks them up this weekend, fact is that he's going to cop the tag every week and hasn't done anything this year to convince me that he can break it on a regular basis.

 

[Juddy88]

Got a bit of a problem, have got Riewoldt on the field with Tippet as EMG.
Also have Rioli starting.

Really want to trade out Rioli for maybe Valenti and then upgrade Tippet to Pav, but if I do so and Roo doesn't play I'll be copping Valenti's score.

11 trades left, could wait a week as Rioli and Tippet are playing Melbourne and Eagles, which could mean a score in the 70's, which isn't to bad.

Thoughts?

 

[BartBart]

Well, did the Chapman in for Medhurst trade. Hopefully it won't end up too sideways.

 

[Chrisrocks53]

Is there any worth in trading in Nathan Brown for David Myers?

So my trade combination is:

Brown > Myers
Bird > Cotchin

I have 14 trades left

 

[Big Kitty]

Got a dilema. Trading out Symes, not sure who to get for him can get anyone thinking Bock, Mackie or Goddard. My backline is currently like this
C.Cornes
P.Burgoyne
H.Shaw
R.Ladson
D.Milburn
B.Symes-->One of the above
A.Wonamerri

 

[Chrisrocks53]

^ Sam Fisher or Bock

is what I would suggest

 

[Daz]

Is there any worth in trading in Nathan Brown for David Myers?

So my trade combination is:

Brown > Myers
Bird > Cotchin

I have 14 trades left

no. certainly not. brown is more valuable than you think. barring injury he will play every game and how many backs reserves can we say that about? and what have you got to gain in trading him. a couple of $ so what? a trade is too valuable anyway.

 

[samwise]

have kruzer, browne only playing emergencies at the moment.
10 trades left and rioli, b jones & hill the ones i needa get rid of.
is it worth trading proud to myers?
or i could trade pfeiffer starting to myers and hill to franklin

 

[Chrisrocks53]

no. certainly not. brown is more valuable than you think. barring injury he will play every game and how many backs reserves can we say that about? and what have you got to gain in trading him. a couple of $ so what? a trade is too valuable anyway.

point taken, thanks dazza

I was just considering doing the trade cause i read that myers is a lock for the whole year in the dons team

But my love NJB is still here, so Ill keep the man that has bigger arms than JBrown

Then should we ask the inevitably and hard question to answer

Cotchin or Myers just joking, no one can possibly no the answer to that, maybe except for Terry Wallace and Matty Knights

 

[Hawkmad]

Is there any worth in trading in Nathan Brown for David Myers?

So my trade combination is:

Brown > Myers
Bird > Cotchin

I have 14 trades left

Myers would be a more solid emerg.

 

[Hawkmad]

If I traded Hill down it would give me $423,700 to do an upgrade for Houli Could get Corey just.
This is my mids atm - Bartel , Salopek , Sewell , Stevens , Palmer & Houli (emerg. Jack & Lonergan)

I am open to opinions on who I should get for Houli

 

[Big Kitty]

If I traded Hill down it would give me $423,700 to do an upgrade for Houli Could get Corey just.
This is my mids atm - Bartel , Salopek , Sewell , Stevens , Palmer & Houli (emerg. Jack & Lonergan)

I am open to opinions on who I should get for Houli

Cross 416.9K

 

[Daz]

If I traded Hill down it would give me $423,700 to do an upgrade for Houli Could get Corey just.
This is my mids atm - Bartel , Salopek , Sewell , Stevens , Palmer & Houli (emerg. Jack & Lonergan)

I am open to opinions on who I should get for Houli

corey. no doubt

 

[Chrisrocks53]

Cross 416.9K

seconded

arghh, this is seriously doing my head in

Browny is a reliable EMG in the same ilk as presti

but Myers could add an extra 20 - 40 more points.

Then theres the situation of trading Bird, is Myers worth the 20k less than Cotchin?

 

[lynchy23]

bradshaw/waters for p burgoyne/milburn?


who would u do?

waters will score more than bradshaw over the year i would think

 

[Big Red is back]

Bradshaw out Fisher in
Houli out Swan/Kornes/Corey in

Guarantee Bradshaw outscores Fisher over the next 3 home games at the Gabba

 

[Big Kitty]

seconded

arghh, this is seriously doing my head in

Browny is a reliable EMG in the same ilk as presti

but Myers could add an extra 20 - 40 more points.

Then theres the situation of trading Bird, is Myers worth the 20k less than Cotchin?

Go with one of
Brown-->Myers
or
Bird-->Cotchin
Personally I would get Myers, you have plenty of trades left and Myers will score more and make more cash the Brown. With the other trade Bird will hold his spot so only go with that if you desperatly need cash to upgrade someone.

 

[gdogga]

i have 449,700 in the bank. (taking out houli)


Dane Swan - 396,600
Jimmy Bartel - 439,100
Simon Goodwin - 393,800
Joel Corey - 423,200

Thanks

 

[Chrisrocks53]

thanks Big Kitty

I went for you suggestion, it just sures up my backline a bit and it will enable me to downgrade Wonnaman later on and upgrade Myers instead of struggling with NJ

Next week will be then

Bird>Cotchin
Tippett>Valenti

 

[Daz]

i have 449,700 in the bank. (taking out houli)


Dane Swan - 396,600
Jimmy Bartel - 439,100
Simon Goodwin - 393,800
Joel Corey - 423,200

Thanks

bartel or corey. bartel IMO but many people disagree

 

[Dunn - Well Done]

bartel or corey. bartel IMO but many people disagree

i totally agree but is Ablett tebetter choice will average the most this season IMO. shows he can go real big 150 and 135 and a 121

 

[Moose1]

Anyone think Roughead ($302k) to J. Brown ($287k) is a worthwhile trade. Roughead has been inconsistant and brown appears to be hitting some DT form. Thoughts anyone??

 

[Daz]

i totally agree but is Ablett tebetter choice will average the most this season IMO. shows he can go real big 150 and 135 and a 121

you could be right but he can't afford him anyway

 

[bones25]

All 3 are nice


Ok I will not brag anymore