I thought that Pasmans from the Ranges was an emergency, not Simcoe.Reading between the lines and your past threads, you are obviously closely associated with the Northern Knights.
The main fault I noticed with Walsh at the carnival was that he runs flat footed and lacks pace. He has height but is carrying a bit of weight - this can easily be lost with a good pre-season. He was brought in as an emergency (and it was noted that all 3 emergencies Walsh, Wallace & Simcoe were all NK players ????). IMO Walsh didn't have much of an impact on the backline at all.
I don't agree with you at all on Cachia. Cachia is a great player and will get AIS, along with Scully and Blease.