Venn Diagram Challenge - Coaches

[subaru]

He does most things by himself I'd reckon.
Owner / operator that one!

 

[SydCrow]

it got off the front page and you decided to bump it
ps. I have a life D_One, either cut it down to current coaches, and supply me with sources, otherwise you'll be doing it all to yourself

sorry Riggy

(ps I'll help you - the answer to the latest one also intersects the record GF losses, insulting major sponsors and man boobs circles)

 

[Stumpy Pete]

I think this is an excellent thread.

Regards

S. Pete

 

[Brick Tamland]

He does most things by himself I'd reckon.
Owner / operator that one!

WIN

 

[D_One]

it got off the front page and you decided to bump it
ps. I have a life D_One, either cut it down to current coaches, and supply me with sources, otherwise you'll be doing it all to yourself

Ok I'll help you out Riggy.

Here's the coaches.

Alistair Clarkson
Brad Scott
Brett Ratten
Damian Hardwick
Dean Bailey
John Worsfold
Mark Harvey
Mark Thompson
Mark Williams
Matthew Knights
Michael Voss
Mick Malthouse
Mumbles Craig
Paul Roos
Rodney Eade
Ross Lyons

Use this site to work out the non0-6 coaches. (12 all up, ie there are four 0-6 coaches)

http://afl.allthestats.com/statistics/alltime.php

Use this site to work out coaches that have played in a winning VFL/AFL final. (13 all up)

http://www.stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/playersA_idx.html

And use this site to work out the Premiership coaches that have coached three minor premierships (1 only)

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/Default.aspx

Good Luck

 

[Riggy1]

Ok I'll help you out Riggy.

Here's the coaches.

Alistair Clarkson
Brad Scott
Brett Ratten
Damian Hardwick
Dean Bailey
John Worsfold
Mark Harvey
Mark Thompson
Mark Williams
Matthew Knights
Michael Voss
Mick Malthouse
Mumbles Craig
Paul Roos
Rodney Eade
Ross Lyons

Use this site to work out the non0-6 coaches. (12 all up, ie there are four 0-6 coaches)

http://afl.allthestats.com/statistics/alltime.php

Use this site to work out coaches that have played in a winning VFL/AFL final. (13 all up)

http://www.stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/playersA_idx.html

And use this site to work out the Premiership coaches that have coached three minor premierships (1 only)

http://www.portadelaidefc.com.au/Default.aspx

Good Luck

I'll just guess out of mid air
I'd guess Craig, Hardwick and Bailey are 3 of the 0-6 starters, and ill just throw in Ratten (he did lose every game in his 1st year right, just not starting from week 1 right?)

the 3 that havnt won a vfl/afl premiership
Craig
and i'll guess Knights (I saw on chooseday noght football he was playing for Richmond) and Roos (Fitzroy/Swans IIRC)

and the 1 with 3 minor premierships is Williams?

they were all guesses

 

[D_One]

So you think it's OK that he bet on a game ...but not ok that Goodwin did, because the amounts were different?

Fine ....whatever....

I'll just guess out of mid air
I'd guess Craig, Hardwick and Bailey are 3 of the 0-6 starters, and ill just throw in Ratten (he did lose every game in his 1st year right, just not starting from week 1 right?)

the 3 that havnt won a vfl/afl premiership
Craig
and i'll guess Knights (I saw on chooseday noght football he was playing for Richmond) and Roos (Fitzroy/Swans IIRC)

and the 1 with 3 minor premierships is Williams?

they were all guesses

Not even close.

Malthouse in 99 was the other 0-6 coach.

The three coaches that have never played in a winning VFL/AFL final are Alistair Clarkson (he played in one Elim Final for a loss), Ross Lyons (zero finals) and Mumbles Craig (0 VFL/AFL games for 0 VFL/AFL finals and0 VFL/AFL finals victories)

But you are correct only Choco fits in all three sets.

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

Why not change the 'played in winning finals' to 'winning premiership'?

Or would that eliminate Boobs?

 

[Rough As Guts]

Why not change the 'played in winning finals' to 'winning premiership'?

Or would that eliminate Boobs?

Yeah. Funny how he's very selective in his choice of words.

 

[D_One]

Why not change the 'played in winning finals' to 'winning premiership'?

Or would that eliminate Boobs?

I could have used "Coaches threatened with being sacked at the end of 2006" too and that would have put Thompson in the middle. But I didn't.

BTW There's no-one stopping you from coming up with you own Venn Diagram Challenge.

 

[Sekaj]

Sekaj spam multiquote

Before even reading the thread, I'm more than happy to put my neck out and say that Choco is in the best category possible and Craig is in the worst category possible, right?

Wrong.

I checked and it's Neil Craig courtesy of losing by 141 points to Brisbane a few years back, not winning a flag and multiple finals chokes.

Here's Choco's Venn Diagram:

Here's another version for you Port Power nuffy's.

Coaches who have coached a team to a 119 point Grand final defeat.

Here, let me make it easier for you:

 

[Lunchlady Doris]

I could have used "Coaches threatened with being sacked at the end of 2006" too and that would have put Thompson in the middle. But I didn't.

Ooh, that hurt.

BTW There's no-one stopping you from coming up with you own Venn Diagram Challenge.

Nothing but my dignity and sense of self-worth.

 

[D_One]

Ooh, that hurt.

Nothing but my dignity and sense of self-worth.

So we agree, there's nothing stopping you.

 

[ziad]

Read D One a port supported and - well Craig is the answer, then I read the question.
Dull

 

[Lensen]

Not even close.

Malthouse in 99 was the other 0-6 coach.

Only if for some reason you've decided to read it as L-W rather than W-L.

Going just beautifully this thread.

 

[WAG]

Read D One a port supported and - well Craig is the answer, then I read the question.
Dull

Channeling a drunk Yoda again !

 

[D_One]

Only if for some reason you've decided to read it as L-W rather than W-L.

Going just beautifully this thread.

Nope I read the 1999 round 6 prem table correctly.

Club		P	W	D	L	For	Agst	%	PP
West Coast	6	6	0	0	611	389	157.07	24
Essendon	6	5	0	1	644	520	123.85	20
Geelong		6	5	0	1	721	599	120.37	20
Brisbane Lions	6	4	0	2	621	426	145.77	16
Camry Crows	6	4	0	2	558	504	110.71	16
Hawthorn	6	3	0	3	494	474	104.22	12
Kangaroos	6	3	0	3	640	643	99.53	12
St Kilda	6	3	0	3	570	581	98.11	12
Port Adelaide	6	3	0	3	559	587	95.23	12
Melbourne	6	3	0	3	524	557	94.08	12
Carlton		6	3	0	3	532	602	88.37	12
Wstn Bulldogs	6	2	0	4	622	650	95.69	8
Richmond	6	2	0	4	590	652	90.49	8
Sydney		6	2	0	4	496	672	73.81	8
Collingwood	6	0	0	6	522	688	75.87	0
Fremantle	6	0	0	6	497	657	75.65	0

 

[Lensen]

Nope I read the 1999 round 6 prem table correctly.

Club		P	W	D	L	For	Agst	%	PP
West Coast	6	6	0	0	611	389	157.07	24
Essendon	6	5	0	1	644	520	123.85	20
Geelong		6	5	0	1	721	599	120.37	20
Brisbane Lions	6	4	0	2	621	426	145.77	16
Camry Crows	6	4	0	2	558	504	110.71	16
Hawthorn	6	3	0	3	494	474	104.22	12
Kangaroos	6	3	0	3	640	643	99.53	12
St Kilda	6	3	0	3	570	581	98.11	12
Port Adelaide	6	3	0	3	559	587	95.23	12
Melbourne	6	3	0	3	524	557	94.08	12
Carlton		6	3	0	3	532	602	88.37	12
Wstn Bulldogs	6	2	0	4	622	650	95.69	8
Richmond	6	2	0	4	590	652	90.49	8
Sydney		6	2	0	4	496	672	73.81	8
Collingwood	6	0	0	6	522	688	75.87	0
Fremantle	6	0	0	6	497	657	75.65	0

Good, maybe now you can find a table of who was coaching who in 1999.

 

[subaru]

BTW There's no-one stopping you from coming up with you own Venn Diagram Challenge.

No ...I guess there's not ...

Why hasn't anyone else done it?

Cause it's STUPID ...that's why!

 

[D_One]

Good, maybe now you can find a table of who was coaching who in 1999.

You are correct and I humbly apologise. I read that he was appointed 1999. Next time I'll get you to vet my Collingwood related material. I hope you don’t mind a few PMs.

 

[WAG]

No ...I guess there's not ...

Why hasn't anyone else done it?

Cause it's STUPID ...that's why!

C'mon subaru. Douche_One has done it before. It was so great the last time, but this time he has tweaked it a little and now............I mean wow. Potential thread of the year stuff .

I can't believe this hasn't been stickied yet ! Mods? Whats going on???

 

[Sekaj]

Coach Circle Diagram

There are 320 known coaches in VFL/AFL history. Only one has humiliated his side in a Grand Final by a world-record breaking 119 points. Which one? Pick the correct coach and place him in the circle.

Adams Bill
Adamson Jim
Albiston Alec
Alexander Ron
Allan Ben
Alves Stan
Angus George
Arklay Tom
Arthur Graham
Austin Rod
Ayres Gary
Baggott Jack
Bailey Dean
Baldock Darrel
Balme Neil
Barassi Ron D.
Barker Syd (snr)
Bartlett Kevin
Beames Percy
Beckwith John
Belcher Alan
Belcher Vic
Bentley Percy
Birt John
Bisset Jack
Blakey John
Blight Malcolm
Bourke Francis W.
Brew Ray
Brittain Wayne
Brosnan Gerald
Buckenara Gary
Bunton Haydn
Cable Barry
Cahill John
Caldwell Jim
Cameron Charlie
Campbell Garnet
Campbell Graham
Carter F. Wally
Cashman Jack
Cassidy Jim
Cazaly Roy
Chadwick Bert
Clark Norman
Clark Wally
Clarke Ansell
Clarke Jack E.
Clarkson Alastair
Clegg Ron
Clover Horrie
Clymo Charlie
Coghlan Arthur
Coleman John
Condon Dick
Connolly Chris
Cornes Graham
Coventry Syd (snr)
Craig Neil
Crocker Darren
Crowe Jim
Cubbins Bill
Curcio Frank
Daniher Neale
Dare Norm
Davis Allan
Davis Barry
Davis Bob
Deane Col
Devine John
Dibbs Charlie
Diggins Brighton
Ditterich Carl
Dixon Brian
Donald Wally
Donaldson Graham
Donnelly Gerry
Drohan Eddie
Drum Damian
Dugdale John
Dyer Jack (snr)
Eade Rodney
Eason Alec
Eason Bill
Edwards A. Arthur
Eicke Wels
Elliott Fred
Elms Henry
Erwin Mick
Everett Allan
Farmer Graham
Faul Bill
Feltham Paul
Findlay Bill
Fitzmaurice Tom
Fleiter Fred
Foote Les
Forbes Keith
Francis Jim
Franklin Tony
Frawley Danny
Freake Jimmy
Froude Fred
Garvin Reg
Gaudion Charlie
Gellie Graeme
Gieschen Jeff
Goggin Bill
Goode Frank
Grace Mick
Gravenall Sam
Green Fred
Griggs Les
Guy Eric
Hafey Tom
Hagger Lloyd
Hale Jack
Hall Alec
Hammond Bob
Hampshire Ian
Hands Ken
Hardy Charlie
Harris Dick D.
Harris Jacky
Hart Royce
Harvey Mark
Heinz George
Hickey Reg
Hickinbotham Dave
Hillard Norm
Hird Allan (snr)
Hiskins Arthur
Holden George
Hopkins Allan
Howell Verdun
Hughes Frank (snr)
Hughson Fred
Hunter Harry
Hutchison Greg
Incigneri Len
Jackson Jim
Jeans Allan
Jenkins Ern
Jesaulenko Alex
Jewell Tony
John Graeme
Jones Dennis
Jones Peter
Jordan Ray
Joyce Alan
Judge Ken
Kelly Harvey
Kelly Joe
Kennedy John J.
Killigrew Alan
King Stuart
Kinnear Col
Knight Jack
Knights Matthew
Knights Peter
Kyne Phonse
La Fontaine Allan
Lahiff Tommy
Laidley Dean
Lane Gordon
Laver Les
Leonard Johnny
Lethbridge Chris
Lewis Johnny Francis
Lyon Ross
Maher Frank
Malthouse Mick
Mann Neil
Matthews E. Herb
Matthews Leigh
May Charlie
Maybury Percy
McAlpine Ivan
McCarthy Con
McCaskill Bob
McConnell Alan
McCorkell Jock
McDonald Alan
McDonald Donald
McHale Jock
McKenzie Don
McKenzie Jack Joseph
McKenzie Keith
McLaren George
McMahen Noel
McMaster C. Bill
McNamara Dave
Melling Ted
Merrett Roger
Metherell Len
Miller Alan
Mills Bert
Minogue Dan
Moriarty Geoff
Morris Mel
Morrison Alby
Murray Kevin
Nash Laurie
Neesham Gerard
Nicholls John
Niven Colin
Nolan Bernie
Noonan Paddy
Northey John
Nunan Michael
O'Brien Paddy
O'Donohue Peter
Ogden Percy
Olliver Arthur
Olsson Rodney
Oppy Max
Orchard Billy
Pagan Denis
Pannam Albert F.
Pannam Charlie E.
Pannam Charlie H.
Parkin David
Parratt Percy
Patterson Bill G.
Patterson Michael
Pemberton John
Pianto Peter
Plummer Elton
Quade Ricky
Quinlan Bernie
Quinn Tommy
Rademacher Arthur
Rankin Cliff
Ratten Brett
Rattray Gordon
Rawlings Jade
Reynolds Dick
Richards Ron
Richardson Barry
Ricketts Charlie
Ridley Ian
Riley Mark
Ringose Doug
Rohde Peter
Roos Paul
Rose Bob
Rose Kevin
Rowe Des
Rowe Percy H.
Rowell Ted
Ruddell Cec
Rush Bob
Ruthven Allan
Ryan Joe
Saunders Harry
Scanlan Paddy
Schimmelbusch Wayne
Schmidt Billy
Schwab Peter
Scott Brett
Sewell Greg
Shaw Robert
Shaw Tony
Shea Keith
Sheedy Kevin
Sheldon Ken
Silvagni Sergio
Simmonds Roy
Skilton Bob
Slocum Ray
Smith Dave
Smith Jimmy M.
Smith Len V.
Smith Norm W.
Smith Ross G.
Sparrow George
Sproule Paul
Stephen Bill
Stewart Ian
Strickland Bill
Sutton Bert
Sutton Charlie
Taylor Bert R.
Taylor Dick J.
Thaw Alan
Thomas Bill D.
Thomas Grant
Thomas Hugh
Thomas Len
Thomas Stan
Thompson Mark
Thorogood Ian
Titus Jack
Todd John
Trezise Neil
Tuddenham Des
Twomey Bill P.
Tyson Charlie
Upton-Brown Victor
Valentine Viv
Voss Michael
Wallace Terry
Walls Robert
Ware Norm
Warne-Smith Ivor
Watson Colin
Watson Tim
Weideman Murray
Wells Jack
Wheeler Terry
Whitten Ted (snr)
Wigraft Len
Williams Jack A.
Williams Mark M.
Williams Tom
Williamson Col
Wilson Percy
Wood Artie
Worrall John
Worsfold John

 

[wapower]

Re: Coach Circle Diagram

Struggling for original content of your own Sekaj?

 

[Godzke]

Re: Coach Circle Diagram

It won't let me click and drag

 

[BWST]

Re: Coach Circle Diagram

Massive yawns [: yawn smiley :]