Votes vs Melbourne

[jezzatigerbrent]

5.Judd
4.Warnock
3.Murphy
2.Gibbs
1.Scotland

 

[Blue_Fury]

5. Scotland
4. Judd
3. Warnock
2. Ellard
1. Murphy

BYP: Ellard

Honourable mention to Bret "Double Tackle" Thornton

 

[Blue and Silver]

5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. Warnock
2. Ellard
1. Murphy

BYP Ellard

Too many honourable mentions to go through

 

[blue gunslinger]

Same votes for me...add Laids as the BYP

If you have Ellard in your top 5 surely he is BYP

5 Scotland: lynch pin
4 Juddy: my brother started booing him at the Odin every poss. He was exhausted by the end of the game
3 Warnock: give the lad time
2 Ellard:could have been higher if not for a few faults
1 Murph

 

[Massive Attack]

5. Judd. Broke it open.
4. Scotland. Worked all day.
3. Thornton. Knows the ropes.
2. Warnock. The big giraffe.
1. Ellard. Tackles and goals.
0. Gibbs. Very polished display.

 

[iRemember87]

5. Judd
4. Warnock
3. Gibbs
2. Murphy
1. Thorton

 

[Stig O'Hara]

5. Chris Judd - too good
4. Heath Scotland - solid all day
3. Bryce Gibbs - Oozing class
2. Robert Warnock - Up against a witches hat, but killed them anyway
1. Marc Murphy - Gets his own footy and uses it.

BYP: David Ellard - goal machine.

 

[no. 4]

5. Chris Judd: Blind Freddy could see that he was BOG.
4. Bryce Gibbs: Was good to see him play inside some more to prove he is not simply an outside player.
3. Heath Scotland: Was almost faultless.
2. Robert Warnock: His tap work to Judd was first class and dominated the inexperienced Melbourne ruckmen.
1. David Ellard: I don't think there was a clear 5th best but his 3 goals gives him the vote.

 

[HBF]

5. Judd
4. Scotland
3. Warnock
2. Gibbs
1. Ellard

 

[reg_lower91]

5. Judd
4. Scotland
3. Warnock
2. Gibbs
1. Ellard


BYP: Ellard

Can't disagree with this, spot on

 

[juzz88]

5. Judd
4. Scotland
3. Gibbs
2. Ellard
1. Warnock

ROTY - Ellard

Unlucky: Thornton, Laidler and Smurph.

 

[The old campaigner]

5. Judd
4. Warnock
3. Gibbs
2. Scotland
1. Thornton

Rookie - Ellard

 

[Big Sim]

1. Judd. His second quarter was mind boggling.
2. Scotland. Hot form continues.
3. Warnock. Wow, really starting to put it together. Dominated.
4. Gibbs. A rich vein of good footy.
5. Thornton. Seemed to be everywhere and hardly put a foot wrong.

 

[TerryWallet]

5 C Judd (Peerless)
4 R Warnock (Still a very, very young ruckman)
3 H Scotland (Real on-field leader)
2 B Gibbs (Always plays - nearly always plays well)
1 D Ellard (Finals teams need players who bust out from the mediocre pack to join the regular game pack. Well done this year Ellard)

 

[Polo]

5. Judd
4. Warnock
3. Scotland
2. Murphy
1. Thornton

Ellard very, very unlucky.

 

[Blues_FC]

5. Judd
4. Scotland
3. Ellard
2. Warnock
1. Gibbs

 

[OldBlueFan]

Haven't seen the links for the game vids posted (Zee would seem to have earnt some mod's wrath).

Here they are for anyone interested.

Carlton v Melbourne RD20 1st Qtr

Carlton v Melbourne RD20 2nd Qtr

Carlton v Melbourne RD20 3rd Qtr

Carlton v Melbourne RD20 4th Qtr

 

[GordonBlue]

5. Judd
4. Scotland
3. Warnock
2. Gibbs
1. Ellard

BYP: Ellard

Unlucky: Thornton, Laidler, Joseph, Davies

Terrible game by Duigan...

 

[PooMonkey]

5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. Scotland
2. Warnock
1. Thornton

BYP - Ellard

 

[Malifice]

5: Judd
4: Gibbs
3: Scotland
2: Thornton
1: Warnock

Im sorry Ellard.

You know I love you.

 

[Claypigeon]

5. Judd - Broke it open, that play between he and Murphy then the handpass to Betts was gold
4. Gibbs - Played inside, outside, back, forward becoming the complete player
3. Murphy - Did the hard stuff for not as much reward
2. Scotland - His consistent and composed self as per usual. .. The most relaxed hard man in the side
1. Thornton - Set it up early and some of his unselfish play was fantastic to see. ..

BYP - Ellard - Unlucky not to get into the votes, seemed to play outside a bit more and up forward which is great. .. Showing why he is a workman like Murphy. ..

Betts/Warnock supremely unlucky too. ..

 

[Team Mo']

5. Judd
4. Gibbs
3. Scotland
2. Murphy
1. Warnock

 

[Stamos]

Coaches' Votes
Carlton vs Melbourne

10 Judd (Carl)
6 Scotland (Carl)
5 Gibbs (Carl)
4 Murphy (Carl)
3 Davies (Carl)
2 Warnock (Carl)


Interesting that nobody on the board gave Davies a single vote, and yet he got 3 from the coaches.

 

[Blues_Man]

Coaches' Votes
Carlton vs Melbourne

10 Judd (Carl)
6 Scotland (Carl)
5 Gibbs (Carl)
4 Murphy (Carl)
3 Davies (Carl)
2 Warnock (Carl)


Interesting that nobody on the board gave Davies a single vote, and yet he got 3 from the coaches.

Oh look the coaches had Scotland second best player on the ground ..and you couldn't fit him in the votes .

 

[Wickzki]

5. Judd
4. Scotland
3. Murphy
2. Ellard
1. Warnock

BYP: Ellard

Unlucky: Brad Green