Votes vs Melbourne

[bluesforlife]

Coaches' Votes
Carlton vs Melbourne

10 Judd (Carl)
6 Scotland (Carl)
5 Gibbs (Carl)
4 Murphy (Carl)
3 Davies (Carl)
2 Warnock (Carl)


Interesting that nobody on the board gave Davies a single vote, and yet he got 3 from the coaches.

if my maths is correct both coaches gave davies votes but i find it more interesting that one coach gives murphy 2nd best on and the other does not have him in the votes.

Judd 5-5
Scotalnd 3-3
Gibbs 4-1
Murphy 4
Davies 2-1
Warnock 2

 

[HARKER]

if my maths is correct both coaches gave davies votes but i find it more interesting that one coach gives murphy 2nd best on and the other does not have him in the votes.

Judd 5-5
Scotalnd 3-3
Gibbs 4-1
Murphy 4
Davies 2-1
Warnock 2

I'd say it would be like this:

Judd: 5-5
Scotland: 4-2
Gibbs: 4-1
Murphy: 3-1
Davies: 3
Warnock: 2

Surely two coaches couldn't have given Davies votes.

 

[GordonBlue]

Coaches' Votes
Carlton vs Melbourne

10 Judd (Carl)
6 Scotland (Carl)
5 Gibbs (Carl)
4 Murphy (Carl)
3 Davies (Carl)
2 Warnock (Carl)


Interesting that nobody on the board gave Davies a single vote, and yet he got 3 from the coaches.

I gave him an "unlucky"

 

[Stamos]

Oh look the coaches had Scotland second best player on the ground ..and you couldn't fit him in the votes .

I didn't have Murphy or Davies in the votes either. What's your point?

 

[Blues_Man]

I didn't have Murphy or Davies in the votes either. What's your point?

that you were wrong ..or that everyone else on the planet were wrong ....tough one to work out

Scotland was in the best 3 on the ground ..absolutely indisputable fact..to totally leave him out of the votes defies logic.

 

[Claypigeon]

that you were wrong ..or that everyone else on the planet were wrong ....tough one to work out

Scotland was in the best 3 on the ground ..absolutely indisputable fact..to totally leave him out of the votes defies logic.

Something based on personal opinion can rarely be suggest as a fact let alone an indisputable one. .. Its why the votes are tallied up for the final 5to1 votes to get a broad idea of the opinions of the board. .. So I think we can just agree to disagree and continue with the voting

 

[Silvagnis]

if my maths is correct both coaches gave davies votes but i find it more interesting that one coach gives murphy 2nd best on and the other does not have him in the votes.

Ratts wasn't happy with the lairising after half time.

Murphy and a few others did try to do too much at the expense of playing a team game.

Both coaches probably acknowledged Davies's selfless one per centers and game on Green.

Loved that shepherd that may have been illegal.

"And you call yourself a Tasmanian..."

A few fan girls would like to be in Green's position.

 

[Zolli8]

5. Judd
4. Scotland
3. Warnock
2. Thornton
1. Laidler