-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
MVP Waite??
- Thread starter carlton09
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- May 29, 2009
- 29,823
- 14,883
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- LA Lakers
The replays showed there wasn't a real lot in it.
If he gets a week for that it will be proof that the MRP is rigged. He will be able to use the David Hille defence in that he set himself to take a mark & then realised he wasn't going to be able to take the mark & therefore turned his body mid-air to minimise the contact. Ultimately his hip hit Bate, not his arm, elbow or fist.
Clearly going for the mark and was in the air when he turned and made contact. Pretty hard to pull out of a marking contest mid air. Made incidental contact to the head and the free kick +50m was the right decision.
Listened to the call on 693 and the expert Graeme Bond, who apparently understands all things tribunal, said there was nothing in it and Waite should be fine.
Listened to the call on 693 and the expert Graeme Bond, who apparently understands all things tribunal, said there was nothing in it and Waite should be fine.
AlecDuncan
Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2016
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2015
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2014
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2013
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2012 Player Sponsor
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2011 Player Sponsor
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2010 Player Sponsor
He was already in the air for the marking contest, saw Bate and then turned mid-air. Not even half as bad as bad as Hille's.
Nothing in it. He was already airborne and tried to turn out of it.
Except that Hille plays for Essendon, and Waite plays for Carlton. Will probably get 2 weeks.
- Moderator
- #12
Except that Hille plays for Essendon, and Waite plays for Carlton. Will probably get 2 weeks.
Even the HUN reckons nothing.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/blues-stun-dees-in-first-half/story-e6frf9jf-1225875859160
Seriously. Will be fine.
Also don't forget that he was pushed into the contact...Shouldn't even reach the MRP....but...with the state our game is in, who knows these days.
Nothing in it what so ever. Launched himself for the chest mark, Bate backed in from the side and Waite had nowhere to go.
wavefall21
All Australian
put it this way, if Waite gets done for that and Hille didn't for an act which was much more dangerous, you couldn't help but laugh, Waite was already airborne and turned his body to protect himself from doing any damage, he did all he could not to clean Bate up, unlike Hille, who swung his elbow in his motion
Waitey will be fine, we can't afford to lose him cos he's arguably our second most important player behind Juddy with the flexibility he adds to our side
Waitey will be fine, we can't afford to lose him cos he's arguably our second most important player behind Juddy with the flexibility he adds to our side
There was nothing in it, and if Hille gets off for chest marking Bartel's head, Waite will be compensated for having his time being wasted
Shaker_Maker
Senior List
No coincidence that Vozzo was the umpire either. All game, the most disgraceful bias from an individual umpire I can recall.
chaser1
Team Captain
\no way will he get suspended for that. \if he does it will be the worst decision in history. \full stop
Jarrad will be fine.. I think the Melbourne players all around him were totally shocked when they saw the report.
However, what I worry about now is that Waite must clearly be a target of the umpires. The slightest infraction and he's going into the book. Not good.
However, what I worry about now is that Waite must clearly be a target of the umpires. The slightest infraction and he's going into the book. Not good.
- Banned
- #24
Enright and Podsiadly were weak pricks against WC.
Enright smashed Adam Selwood after he had taken the ball and was in the air.
Miles worse than Waite's bump on Davenport.
Podsiadly bitch slapped another Eagle with an open hand.
The WC player did a 180 due to the force of the blow.
LOL.
Enright smashed Adam Selwood after he had taken the ball and was in the air.
Miles worse than Waite's bump on Davenport.
Podsiadly bitch slapped another Eagle with an open hand.
The WC player did a 180 due to the force of the blow.
LOL.
The David Hille defence would go well here. Eyes on the ball, in the air heading for a chest mark until Bate very courageously backed back into him. Waite had no other option but o pull himself up. If that charge is not thrown out the club really needs to kick up a stink.
The umpire has no idea.
The umpire has no idea.
