AFLW West Coast Womens Discussion

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Rather keep McCarthy to be honest.

We have enough players who look fantastic, and excite with their potential, but who get 4 possessions a game, and have zero impact.

On moto g(6) plus using BigFooty.com mobile app


Oh I agree and I am just trying to salvage something from the situation is McCarthy decides to defect.

Besides I think she would prefer Adelaide to us and its most probably draft picks that we get from the unwashed.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

In all seriousness, what is a fair trade? McCarthy better performed but Roux still very young and has shown plenty.
 
In all seriousness, what is a fair trade? McCarthy better performed but Roux still very young and has shown plenty.
Straight swap.
 
Do we do that deal?

Roux was struggling to get a game, while McArthey was one of our main starting midfielders.

Roux is younger, but several years in, hasn't cemented a spot.

On SM-X200 using BigFooty.com mobile app

She is also on the outer at Cockburn, something is amiss there and thats a bit suss.
 
Just for comparison, Barrass and Ginbey are the only two players on the men’s list signed to 2027

So Ella is in good company

Makes me wonder whether we are close to announcing our next Coach. I can't imagine Ella falling over herself to sign on for another four seasons without even knowing who will be steering the ship.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Straight swap.
Yep. McCarthy's been good, but she's slow compared to where the AFLW is heading. Roxy hasn't done much, but huge upside, plenty of players who struggle at their first club, then have breakouts at the next. If the forward line isn't working for her, why not try her down back? Massively strong, huge vertical, worth a shot.
Makes me wonder whether we are close to announcing our next Coach. I can't imagine Ella falling over herself to sign on for another four seasons without even knowing who will be steering the ship.
If by some miracle we got Daisy for coach, then Ella and Charlie locked in long term, that's a nucleus a lot of other players would like to be a part of.
 
Yep. McCarthy's been good, but she's slow compared to where the AFLW is heading. Roxy hasn't done much, but huge upside, plenty of players who struggle at their first club, then have breakouts at the next. If the forward line isn't working for her, why not try her down back? Massively strong, huge vertical, worth a shot.

If by some miracle we got Daisy for coach, then Ella and Charlie locked in long term, that's a nucleus a lot of other players would like to be a part of.
Might actually make our 2025 crop consider nominating WA instead of national. Roxy vane firing out of the blocks at Freo but hasn't shown much since? I think i remember murmurs on the gossip a while back that there were some attitude problems?

Personally i think trying to lure Jess Hosking over as a developed player with a bit of mongrel to help the younger cohort could be worth considering.
 
1701933095575.png

Wonder what skill set Verity brings.

At my WAFLW club we are training with a Fever player. Absolute athlete and very fit

Cannot kick.

I’m not sure I want to be seeing this at AFLW level
 
Having never played football before, Simmons said it was the right time for something new.

🤦🏽‍♂️

Aren’t we past this? The comp is a ****ing joke
 
🤦🏽‍♂️

Aren’t we past this? The comp is a ******* joke
Yeah, I think we are well and truly past this experiment, if she takes the spot of one of our developing youngsters only to be useless, ill mad. Happy to eat my words but this seems pointless.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top