- May 5, 2006
- 63,036
- 70,444
- AFL Club
- West Coast
West Coast list management is diabolical.
How do you trade out good players and worsen your draft hand at the same time?
I cannot imagine them being competitive until at least 2030.
We'll be more competitive in 2025 than 2024.
The real question is whether that is a good move long term. Are we trying to become St Kilda or Essendon? I've seen every WC season since 1992. We were bottom 4 fodder in the late Ken Judge years 2000/01, then again 2008-10 under Worsfold after the premiership midfield split up, then again the last 3 years under Simpson. I've never been less enthusiastic about our off field moves.
Sometimes you get lucky with the draft. Melbourne had a down year and got Luke Jackson. Freo traded Lachie Schultz to the reigning premier and ended up with pick 10. Somehow we've managed to turn 3 top 3 picks into one top 3 pick on the list. You can't afford to be so bad you get 3 top 3 picks in a row and then only use picks 9, 14 and whatever 12 turns into to go with Harley Reid. FWIW I liked the 2022 trade. 2024 not so much.