Simple question, difficult answer..
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
What we would need to give up to get Judd?
- Thread starter Matty Knights
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Banned
- #3
Matty Knights said:
naaa, more like stupid question, no answer.
PHX
Quarterback Style
I'm happy with what we have coming through already in the midfield. Judd would be nice but for what it would take to get him, we dont need him.
Forget it
The club would have to finish dead last and then Judd would have to walk out on the eagles
To actually do any kind of deal this club would have to give up too much and would actually go backwards.
The club would have to finish dead last and then Judd would have to walk out on the eagles
To actually do any kind of deal this club would have to give up too much and would actually go backwards.
No chance. None.
Even if we offered them our 10 best players they wouldn't be able to accept because they couldn't afford them under the salary cap.
Even if we offered them our 10 best players they wouldn't be able to accept because they couldn't afford them under the salary cap.
I am looking forward to seeing this thread on another board in 3 years time but with the name Delidio in it. You see he already is a Tiger and actually wants to play for us and with half a chance might be just as good. Forget worrying about what we dont have...there is more joy in what we do have.
tigerdan
Norm Smith Medallist
Like PRR said - we'd have to finish on the bottom.
Guess that means he may end up a Bomber!
Guess that means he may end up a Bomber!
Don't want him
Great player but would cost too much
Sometimes getting a player like him can rip out the soul of a club when you have to give up one of the players that have been with the side for such a long time.
Great player but would cost too much
Sometimes getting a player like him can rip out the soul of a club when you have to give up one of the players that have been with the side for such a long time.
sante
Emu
We would have to give up too much and therefore we would 'lose' the trade
Heisenberg_
17🏆19🏆20🏆
would have to give up way to much, unless Judd told WC that the only team he wanted to go to was Richmond and nobody else, and we could give as little as possible and **** WC over because they dont want to lose him for nothing. Would never happen but can only hope
tugga
Hall of Famer
- May 9, 2006
- 35,859
- 71,716
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Tottenham,NY Rangers,Red Sox, SA Spurs
Obviously would love to have him, but it's a pipedream.I think we've spent too much time and energy developing our list geared towards youth and we should keep going that way. Obviously you need experienced players to compliment the kids, but it would mean giving up too much for just one player...and let's face it as good as Judd is, he's still only only one out of 22.
West Coast have plenty of midfielders but were one tall forward off winning a premiership last year. Stafford for Judd - straight swap. West Coast get their tall forward, we get a gun midfielder, Judd gets to come home, Stafford gets a career extension. Everyone's a winner in this deal. 
Hell, we could even pay over the odds and throw in a tall West Australian defender to bolster their backline.
Hell, we could even pay over the odds and throw in a tall West Australian defender to bolster their backline.
nudgep
Debutant
Crumden said:West Coast have plenty of midfielders but were one tall forward off winning a premiership last year. Stafford for Judd - straight swap. West Coast get their tall forward, we get a gun midfielder, Judd gets to come home, Stafford gets a career extension. Everyone's a winner in this deal.
mate i know your probably kidding, but regardless of what they need, stafford dont cut the mustard when your talking about one of the most gifted youngsters (yes he is still young) to play the game! to get judd at punt rd i suspect youd need to hand over the one and only Nathan G Brown and Matthew Richardson. even that might not do as Brown is still recovering from injury and richo is at the tail end of his career...but they sure could do with a tall forward
judd-->Richmond = not happening
sorry!
We got our "Judd" two year ago when Browny came to Tigerland. You don't get to import two players of that absolute elite ilk twice in the same decade.
- Thread starter
- #17
It was supposed to be pretty hypothetical this thread..
- Banned
- #18
Can't see Judd joinign richmond EVER< he wants to play finals so that cancels richmond out
If he ever comes back to Victoria he'll obviously play for the likes of St. Kilda to replace Harvey when he retires at the end of 2007 season
If he ever comes back to Victoria he'll obviously play for the likes of St. Kilda
to replace Harvey when he retires at the end of 2007 season
- Thread starter
- #19
Hopefully Thomas i still there then...
Aaron said:Can't see Judd joinign richmond EVER< he wants to play finals so that cancels richmond out
If he ever comes back to Victoria he'll obviously play for the likes of St. Kilda
I assume you ain't been following AFL for very long. Haven't you yet worked out that it has become very cyclic and that teams don't tend to stay on the top or the bottom for very long.
When once upon a time a club could bottom out for a decade or more, I'd say peak-to-pits-to-peak is only about seven or eight years nowadays, if a team plays their cards right.
Even if Judd joined Essendon (for arguments sake) at the start of 2008, he would probably play in as many finals as he would if he joined St Kilda in that year.
If a team like St Kilda doesn't keep it's eye on maintaining something resembling a youth policy, they could (once again) be the 'Essendon' of 2010, and Juddy would still have four or five years left of his career to endure.
- Banned
- #21
Aaron said:Can't see Judd joinign richmond EVER< he wants to play finals so that cancels richmond out
If he ever comes back to Victoria he'll obviously play for the likes of St. Kilda
if he goes anywhere it will be melbourne, the team he has barracked 4 all his life
the bombers are out of the equasion as they wont make finals for at least anotyher 5-10 yrs
- Jun 11, 2006
- 12
- 0
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Banned
- #23
Give them redundant Gaspar and dwarf Rodan,hell i'll even throw in Spud's integrity that Wallace found amongst the possum shiite!
Judd will not leave the Eagles, could not blame him either. Would expect them to be playing finals for the next 5-6 years with there current list & if they manage their team right could be even longer.
I am happy with the directions of the Tige's at the moment, building our own team from the ground up. All these kids learning together is better than throwing in some overrated has beens from other clubs, such as Essendon & the Kangaroos have done over the last couple of years. Thankfully we have stopped this at the RFC, the older players we have picked up have plenty of football left in them & they also have a role to play while the kids are learning their trade. The best thing about the likes of Simmonds & P.Bowden is they have'nt cost the club much & are putting in some pretty good displays at the moment.
I am happy with the directions of the Tige's at the moment, building our own team from the ground up. All these kids learning together is better than throwing in some overrated has beens from other clubs, such as Essendon & the Kangaroos have done over the last couple of years. Thankfully we have stopped this at the RFC, the older players we have picked up have plenty of football left in them & they also have a role to play while the kids are learning their trade. The best thing about the likes of Simmonds & P.Bowden is they have'nt cost the club much & are putting in some pretty good displays at the moment.
24 year old Richo.
