Analysis What will happen at tonight's board meeting?

[Frank Gallagher]

This is just a smoke screen so Ed can say "the independent review recommended Buckley be retained", and we all know that's what the review will say, nothing surer, because that's what Ed wanted it to say, independent my ass.

 

[Dubaimagpie]

Good as is the acknowledgement of need of ruck kicking and goal coaches. Get rid of Bucks

Silly question but who ultimately had a say not to hire specialist coaches for skills, kicking etc.

We all knew that they needed this 3 years ago.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[barrackers]

What an absolute joke that the media can film parts of the presentation!

Pretty amateur from the club to place themselves in such a position.

That Seven footage had some interesting info. One of the slides identified gaps in development including coaches for kicking, ruck coach and goal kicking. Given some or the conversation on here regarding that it's interesting to know the club recognises it.

Tackling was another gap identified. Pausing through that video the graphics are from the blueprint for the future (Peter Murphy), not Walsh's review of the football department and the slides shown look to be pretty generalised and generic in respect to survey response recommendations. That said other points amongst them are:

Player survey (30 responses): GM football to be more visible ---- decision making, leadership to more engaged in list management decisions

Health check (32 responses): the board to receive feedback on their performance, greater transparency in staff appointments, introductions between the board and staff (skill sets), mentor development for coach/captain, education for player leadership

 

[Matt_352]

Silly question but who ultimately had a say not to hire specialist coaches for skills, kicking etc.

We all knew that they needed this 3 years ago.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Ultimately. My guess emporor ed

 

[TW Sherrin]

What an absolute joke that the media can film parts of the presentation!

Maybe its deliberate. Part of softening the big decisions release.

 

[Black_White]

Just need to keep that in context. That was a dot point from the player survey. So that's what the players think? I wonder how much weight that holds or in fact if it's all that relevant.

Would think the players views are more than relevant.
And remember that the players these days have friends that they grew up playing with spread throughout the league.
And they talk between themselves all the time. And they know how each club coaches them.
We are clearly lacking.

 

[Matt_352]

Would think the players views are more than relevant.
And remember that the players these days have friends that they grew up playing with spread throughout the league.
And they talk between themselves all the time. And they know how each club coaches them.
We are clearly lacking.

dont need a survey for that

 

[Saintly Viewed]

No grange?

That's only at Eds house with Nathan, Carla and Tanya.

 

[Black_White]

Pretty amateur from the club to place themselves in such a position.



Tackling was another gap identified. Pausing through that video the graphics are from the blueprint for the future (Peter Murphy), not Walsh's review of the football department and the slides shown look to be pretty generalised and generic in respect to survey response recommendations. That said other points amongst them are:

Player survey (30 responses): GM football to be more visible ---- decision making, leadership to more engaged in list management decisions

Health check (32 responses): the board to receive feedback on their performance, greater transparency in staff appointments, introductions between the board and staff (skill sets), mentor development for coach/captain, education for player leadership

Did they break down the players responses to "Should we keep Bux as coach"?
I'm guessing it would read something like....." J Blair votes - YES!"

 

[magpies2013]

The 1st subject should be the recruitment of mayne and wells.whoever ticked off on the deal should be shown the door immediately.

 

[Pedro]

Maybe its deliberate. Part of softening the big decisions release.

Of course its deliberate. If they wanted privacy, they would have ensured it. Strategically leaked buzz words designed to appease the masses and plant seeds that all the suspect areas in our game, recruiting etc are being looked at.

 

[Quicky]

Pretty amateur from the club to place themselves in such a position.



Tackling was another gap identified. Pausing through that video the graphics are from the blueprint for the future (Peter Murphy), not Walsh's review of the football department and the slides shown look to be pretty generalised and generic in respect to survey response recommendations. That said other points amongst them are:

Player survey (30 responses): GM football to be more visible ---- decision making, leadership to more engaged in list management decisions

Health check (32 responses): the board to receive feedback on their performance, greater transparency in staff appointments, introductions between the board and staff (skill sets), mentor development for coach/captain, education for player leadership

Thanks for the context barrackers. Tackling is a good point. Roos made a good point about keeping your feet while tackling also (made about Stewart from Geelong). I think that's an area we can improve.

I know it's not a great look that the media got that footage, but given one of the other points was to have this blueprint for the future accessible for transparency, maybe it doesn't really matter.

 

[Black_White]

*******BREAKING NEWS*******
Buckley to be sacked!
And Eds arranged his termination package already.
https://au.news.yahoo.com/video/wat...es-record-for-melbournes-most-expensive-home/
Nice and close to the Ed mansion.....

 

[MyManLynch]

I hope they sent the player survey to ex players like Heath Shaw, Daisy Thomas, Hertier Lumumba, Dayne Beams, Darren Jolly, Chris Dawes, Alan Didak...would be a great read...

 

[VAFA Spectator]

Nothing will happen, gutless board which cow tows to Eddies rule


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Quicky]

Of course its deliberate. If they wanted privacy, they would have ensured it. Strategically leaked buzz words designed to appease the masses and plant seeds that all the suspect areas in our game, recruiting etc are being looked at.

That's too much conspiracy for me. Given the slides were from the blueprint for the future presentation, and one of the stated aims is to publish the blueprint for transparency, maybe they didn't need to take precautions about it.

 

[Pedro]

That's too much conspiracy for me. Given the slides were from the blueprint for the future presentation, and one of the stated aims is to publish the blueprint for transparency, maybe they didn't need to take precautions about it.

Dunno about conspiracy, cynicism maybe. Ed doesn't do much by accident.

 

[MyManLynch]

They should have put up the 'Future Coach' slide....then just as they click for the next slide...Ed appears at the window & draws the curtains. The media would be foaming...

 

[barrackers]

Thanks for the context barrackers. Tackling is a good point. Roos made a good point about keeping your feet while tackling also (made about Stewart from Geelong). I think that's an area we can improve.

I know it's not a great look that the media got that footage, but given one of the other points was to have this blueprint for the future accessible for transparency, maybe it doesn't really matter.

I like that the players (or two thirds of them) want to take greater ownership in the direction the club takes, they seemed big on having a say in list management. In terms of the slides shown from those that were readable there's nothing ground breaking nor anything that would come as a surprise to other clubs and I'm sure if a similar survey was done here the bigfooty community would raise much the same issues.

 

[Collingwood 4 eternity]

First thing to get tomorrow morning down at dimmeys

Some Collingwood black and white drapes for the boardroom

 

[orion21]

So we're having a board meeting tonight and Walsh is tabling the outcome of at least one of our reviews. Do you think any big decisions are going to be made? If so what?

If you have or hear any news post it in here.

1. 
   

1. Pies want formal education for player leadership

• 1. Tom Browne‏Verified account @TomBrowne7 1m1 minute ago
  1. 
     

1. They've identified gaps in skills. Kicking skills, goal kicking, tackling and ruck skills #pies

• 1. Tom Browne‏Verified account @TomBrowne7 16m16 minutes ago
  1. 
     

1. Pies also want to invest in mentorship for senior coach

• 1. Tom Browne‏Verified account @TomBrowne7 17m17 minutes ago

1. The pies are aiming to review and repair TPP model over 12 months

 

[Matt_352]

1. Pies want formal education for player leadership

• 1. Tom Browne‏Verified account @TomBrowne7 1m1 minute ago

1. They've identified gaps in skills. Kicking skills, goal kicking, tackling and ruck skills #pies

• 1. Tom Browne‏Verified account @TomBrowne7 16m16 minutes ago

1. Pies also want to invest in mentorship for senior coach

• 1. Tom Browne‏Verified account @TomBrowne7 17m17 minutes ago

1. The pies are aiming to review and repair TPP model over 12 months

Mentorship for Dew or Caracella I hope

 

[Obese Arachnid]

No grange?

Please we're a working class club, it'll be beers then maybe followed by le grange.

 

[orion21]

Mentorship for Dew or Caracella I hope

Well the way I think its going to go Matt in mentor for Bucks.........

 

[Matt_352]

Well the way I think its going to go Matt in mentor for Bucks.........

Better flipping not be