When will the Carlton FC Arrive? Part 2

[Rich01]

Their window is open with this group for at least two, perhaps three years.

They rose quicker than expected last year and have been disappointing this year. They should be up their contending next year with their talented core.

 

[Taper]

I thought Hansen was ready for a senior coaching role?

Who else apart from Hansen is a highly rated assistant at Carlton?

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Who else apart from Hansen is a highly rated assistant at Carlton?

Power and Clarke

 

[Nugett]

They are probably due for another rebuild, along with another coach.

Rebuilds are hard work though.

 

[doppleganger]

Their window is open with this group for at least two, perhaps three years.

They rose quicker than expected last year and have been disappointing this year. They should be up their contending next year with their talented core.

They won 12 games in 2022 for 9th
They won 13 games in 2023 for 5th
They will win 12-14 games in 2024

Not sure where this unexpected rise was?Looks pretty consistent to me, a solid team but nothing special.

They have had the same talented senior core for years now.

Mckay, Weiters and Curnow are 26-27 - Cripps, Saad, Doc, McGovern, Newman, Martin, Williams, Acres, Pittonet, Hewett are all older.

No signs of contending with that talented core, a consistent 5-10 team unless things change.

 

[bourbons]

They should be up their contending next year with their talented core.

Yep if there's one thing we do well its deliver on expectation

 

[Rich01]

Yep if there's one thing we do well its deliver on expectation

Their supporters had to go through a bottom up rebuild with several years of absolute putridness.
They tanked to ensure they would get the draft picks to build this core group. If they don’t deliver on at least one flag in the next three years their rebuild has been a complete failure.

Time for them to go all in, trade in any additional experienced talent required and back the coaching staff hired to deliver them their next flag.

 

[Robertio]

They won 12 games in 2022 for 9th
They won 13 games in 2023 for 5th
They will win 12-14 games in 2024

Not sure where this unexpected rise was?Looks pretty consistent to me, a solid team but nothing special.

They have had the same talented senior core for years now.

Mckay, Weiters and Curnow are 26-27 - Cripps, Saad, Doc, McGovern, Newman, Martin, Williams, Acres, Pittonet, Hewett are all older.

No signs of contending with that talented core, a consistent 5-10 team unless things change.

You've obviously forgotten the age profile of last seasons premiers.

 

[doppleganger]

You've obviously forgotten the age profile of last seasons premiers.

Pies won 15+ games and finished top4 in 2018, 2019, 2022 and 2023.

So yes, closer to the end of our premiership contending run then at the beginning.

Tigers had a couple of 15 wins seasons as a younger squad in 2013 and 2015, before their launch in 2017.

Will this Carlton group make the jump from a 12-13 win team to an actual top4 contending team who wins 15+ games?

Or have they already "arrived" and they just aren't at that level.

 

[Robertio]

Pies won 15+ games and finished top4 in 2018, 2019, 2022 and 2023.

So yes, closer to the end of our premiership contending run then at the beginning.

Tigers had a couple of 15 wins seasons as a younger squad in 2013 and 2015, before their launch in 2017.

Will this Carlton group make the jump from a 12-13 win team to an actual top4 contending team who wins 15+ games?

Or have they already "arrived" and they just aren't at that level.

Our window has three seasons to go, maybe four, what will the Pies do? Linked with a few high profile players with no first round draft pick.

 

[doppleganger]

Our window has three seasons to go, maybe four

Your window of 12-13 win seasons?

Will Carlton ever arrive as a 15+ win premiership contender?

 

[Robertio]

Your window of 12-13 win seasons?

Will Carlton ever arrive as a 15+ win premiership contender?

Next season mate.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Our window has three seasons to go, maybe four