Look into ours if you like, it's the worst I've ever seen. There's plenty of information around about it. It has completely destroyed our season. The other two clubs have been able to stay afloat through injury crises, good on them.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
When will the melbourne FC be Dissolved?
- Thread starter Seethus
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Thread starter
- #27
What a load of horse droppings. St Kilda has had a massive run of Injuries. HUGE. their supporters are as passionate as they have ever been. and look, they still have massive injuries but they are in finals contention. You can keep bringin up on field issues all you like, but it only puts things more into perspective.Look into ours if you like, it's the worst I've ever seen. There's plenty of information around about it. It has completely destroyed our season. The other two clubs have been able to stay afloat through injury crises, good on them.
I'm not having a go at Melbourne but yesterdays game was the least ammount of opposition fans i have ever seen at a freo home game even the Roos were pulling in more supporters.
Tas
Premium Platinum
Veteran
10k Posts
30k Posts
North Melbourne - 2022 Kaitlyn Ashmore and Aileen Gilroy Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2022 Aaron Hall and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne AFLW - 2021 Aileen Gilroy and Kaitlyn Ashmore Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2021 Taylor Garner and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
TheBrownDog
- Dec 23, 2002
- 62,676
- 62,322
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- There can be only one...
When I went to the North vs Demons game there weren't a lot of Demons supporters there but the ones that rocked up had to take some bitter medicine. It is fine to talk about this team should go or that team should go but behind the mindless internet trolling there are a lot of people that really love their club and 80% of the football public is fickle, no matter which team or which state.
A few years back even Collingwood had poor figures after a couple of lean years, still reasonable numbers but exceptionally poor for Collingwood, poor enough that stations were playing Adelaide vs Port Adelaide on tv in Melbourne instead of Collingwood vs Carlton.
Next time someone has a bright idea of moving or killing a club, be original and nominate your own club to move or die when you are at a low ebb. Every club will go through low points. If we kill off every club that goes through a bad period we wont have any clubs left.
A few years back even Collingwood had poor figures after a couple of lean years, still reasonable numbers but exceptionally poor for Collingwood, poor enough that stations were playing Adelaide vs Port Adelaide on tv in Melbourne instead of Collingwood vs Carlton.
Next time someone has a bright idea of moving or killing a club, be original and nominate your own club to move or die when you are at a low ebb. Every club will go through low points. If we kill off every club that goes through a bad period we wont have any clubs left.
They are winning. We are losing. Our crowds are big when we are winning, and small when we are losing. Comprendé?
Why don't you start a Sociology Reseach Journal on MFC Supporters so you can how these strange creatures behave. You clearly aren't registering what I'm trying to explain. It sucks but it doesn't mean we should fold.
Your geographical zoning points would have alot more merit if we didn't have a
bigger membership then 2 or 3 other clubs. Another point is that with so many MCC members being Melbourne supporters, there must be some social demographic even if there is no geographical one.
- Thread starter
- #31
What? nothing you said is relevant. we are talking about crowd attendances, and there are several clubs going through hard times but their supporters still show up. If you can magically change facts, your argument has merit. Otherwise accept that Melbourne is a special case and Ive already clearly pointed out why I believe this to be so.
OH! sorry, I didnt get it...wait a second, arent Richmond on the bottom of the ladder? oh yes thats right. they are.
Ok the AUSTRALIAN FOOTBALL LEAGUE is represented by 15 towns cities or suburbs, representing anyone who lives there ,or identifies with that area.
Melbourne is represented by a Cricket club, which costs extensive amounts of money to join, and is a fairly small demographic in the context of a Truly national competition.
Listen to some cold hard facts. There are several reasons why people support, turn up to games and become members of AFL clubs. For me it wasnt location admittedly, it was on field performance of a particular player, G Ablett surprisingly. There is also family, if your father/brother/mother goes for a certain club, you can identify with them and that particular team.
The main overarching reason that people support a particular team however, is representation of a certain place, or area. That is a fact, that is why Fremantle and port adelaide automatically grew supporters, and how sydney and Brisbane helped grow the game in their respective states.
how can a supporter base grow of a team that doesnt even represent a particular suburb or town, the major reason for football support? Simply it cant.
Id like all the "trolls" in this thread to prove this solid reasoning wrong and come up with another alternative to football supporter growth or health.
Geddy how about you lay off? Just because someone doesn't agree with you it does not make them a troll. The post is not necessarily directed at you. If you're club had more people like you (passionate, paid up people who attend) there would not be an issue. I don't want Melbourne to be going poorly off field or on. I want all Victorian teams to survive and prosper. When Melbourne are selling home games to Brisbane and playing other ones in Canberra against Sydney they are obviously in more trouble off field than on. It is just crap they should have to do that. They have enough support obviously (certainly all turning up in 2000) but that they drop away so quickly and badly makes it very tough on the club.
Check out the thread's subject matter champ.
- Thread starter
- #34
Yet again stating the obvious, but missing the point
IMHO i agree with you melbourne need to go elsewhere,merge whatever!haha, keyboard heros. Im actually a paying member of an AFL club, are you? My opinion matters mate. accept it
Your attempt to derail a legitemate, non personal topic has failed.
But IMHO your opinion doesnt matter at all!because at the end of the day we are all keyboard heroes!
Some of us just take abit longer than others to realise this!Anyway you would be preparing yourself for the choker hold no doubt!!with finals and all just round the corner!Hoping the hawks once again give the cats a good dose of furball!
The supporter base is represented by a team that is clearly identified as one for their demographic, not by the players, but what it stands for.
I dont know what Melbourne stands for. Do you? its kind of hard when there are 6 other teams that represent a part of it as well.
What a team stands for can be a whole range of different things its very open to interpretation what does st.kilda stand for, what do the dogs stand for, what do the tigers stand for? And talking about parts of things, are we talking geographically like suburbs or what?
- Thread starter
- #37
Read above to my previous big post
Haha, oh my hawthorn friend, nice to see you derailing threads, and personally attacking me unnecesarily
rizzo
Brownlow Medallist
- Sep 11, 2003
- 14,342
- 1,037
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Everton, Melbourne Heart, Raptors
Can't see melb being dissolved as such. However the head honcho's down there need to figure out what they are going to do. Lets hope sheeds gives some light to these fickle supporters (Not all of you are fickle).
Cheshire Cat
Cancelled
- May 31, 2007
- 4,569
- 942
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Red Sox, Celtics
IMHO i agree with you melbourne need to go elsewhere,merge whatever!
But IMHO your opinion doesnt matter at all!because at the end of the day we are all keyboard heroes!
Hoping the hawks once again give the cats a good dose of furball!
We are all keyboard heroes but not all of us have mastered the art of how to structure a sentence
Oh well im sure youll pick it up in time!!Never to late to learn,you can always turn to a fellow keyboard hero who will gladly show you the keys!
You maintain that because the MFC does not have an identifiable area, that they should relocate or "dissolve" because there is no/little growth prospects because people will never feel drawn into the club because of their conjunctive locality.You are right, we don't have an identifiable area, and clubs like yours and Freo have a wonderful advantage having that. Yet our membership continues to grow, and there are definitely tangible improvements to our clubs infrastructure that nearly collapsed in the 1990s. If we have a star player that can draw people in to support the club (like GA did for you and Jakovich did for me) it will help truckloads.
I think you are overstating the importance of a club having it's own suburb as a key attribute of long-term sustainability, and that when we finally do come out of the wilderness locality will be put further in perspective. Our clubs have been starved of success for the same period of time (40+ years), yet ours has the disadvantage of not having our own suburb or town, which in turn speaks volumes about the underlying passion that lies underneath the clubs stereotype as fickle, snow-bound yuppies.
Cheshire Cat
Cancelled
- May 31, 2007
- 4,569
- 942
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Red Sox, Celtics
Oh well im sure youll pick it up in time!!Never to late to learn,you can always turn to a fellow keyboard hero who will gladly show you the keys!
I won't be be asking you for help.
I hate to be the one to break it to you, but there actually is a "particular suburb or town" called the City of Melbourne.
- Thread starter
- #45
You dont read my post, then make a fool of yourself stating the obvious. Dont worry, I dont judge Sydney supporters by you, so dont feel accountable.
Gone Critical
Moderator
- Moderator
- #46
There is only one club that is necessary, Collingwood. The rest are merely window dressing around our greatness. You all rely on us and are able to be replaced.
Don't worry Demon supporters, we will let you finish the year with a win
I don't see why not. Never really understood this argument. If their name is truly the best thing the Dees have got going for them, they're in a power of trouble.
I just don’t get this theory at all. Of course you can. There is no Perth and things seem to go ok in the West. The AFL, in Melbourne at least, is a club based competition not a geography based competition. Melbourne geography ceased to be relevant to any meaningful extent decades back. While I don’t particularly want to see any club fold the name is the very least relevant consideration for a clubs survival and support.
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll
