- Oct 19, 2012
- 1,550
- 1,073
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Suns
Joel Tippett making his debut for NM this weekend
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
The one that got away...Ken Hinkley's a pretty good coach
Disagree. Don't think he's disciplined enough for the role.Happy for Mav. Could be a good tagger I think.
It's the position he has been playing at VFL level, if he can do it in the AFL is another question. Few weeks ago got 39 disposals, 3 goals while he shutdown his opponent, 18 disposals, 11 tackles, 2 goals last week and was the one who got the tag.Disagree. Don't think he's disciplined enough for the role.
Disagree. Don't think he's disciplined enough for the role.
It's the position he has been playing at VFL level, if he can do it in the AFL is another question. Few weeks ago got 39 disposals, 3 goals while he shutdown his opponent, 18 disposals, 11 tackles, 2 goals last week and was the one who got the tag.
We'll see i guess.
He's a ball hunter first and foremost, leading him to get sucked into the contest rather than look after his man. When we played him as a defensive mid in the 1s he kept giving away frees for tackling his man without the ball and getting frustrated.Discipline can be taught. He has the right attributes to be a tagger. His discipline isn't exactly poor however, not sure what makes you say that.
He's a ball hunter first and foremost, leading him to get sucked into the contest rather than look after his man. When we played him as a defensive mid in the 1s he kept giving away frees for tackling his man without the ball and getting frustrated.
Racking up stats in the 2s level was never his problem. If he can turn it around in the seniors, then good on him. Happy to stand corrected, but I just don't think he will be effective as this sort of player.
Some can't. He couldn't do it during his 4 years with us. He can certainly turn it around, but I'm just saying that we should wait until he has shown the ability to do it all the time at AFL level.No player has it in their genetics to hunt the man and not the ball. He will learn. Seems an odd thing to say that because he did not follow instructions well in the few games he did the role for us he can never do it?
Some can't. He couldn't do it during his 4 years with us. He can certainly turn it around, but I'm just saying that we should wait until he has shown the ability to do it all the time at AFL level.
Never was ability. Was more to do with learning the tagging role. Lets be honest he never got a good run at it.
Disagree. Don't think he's disciplined enough for the role.
Killing it? That's a bit much. And a bit of an insult to David, Dion and Jaeger. They're great defensive minded mids.Mav is killing it at the Saints. What we wouldn't give for a midfielder with his defensive mindset atm
He's always been a good tackler, and he's worked hard on being accountable so that's good for him.
It's just his kicking. If he can clean that up he'll be a genuine mid option.
how the hell are we going to beat st kilda now!? hahaFreo midfield just totally dominated, I think! Not sure what's happened there.