Which Tassie side will be 0-2 come Saturday morning???

[cammo78]

How are Shane Edwards, Matt White, Brad Miller, Daniel Jackson, Angus Graham and Luke McGuane on an AFL list let alone a teams best 22?? Would those spuds get a game for GWS?

You can add Houli, Grigg, Nahas and King to that list.

**** me this club is a joke.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

That is quite possibly the biggest bunch of spuds ever to lace on a boot (Martin, Cotchin and Riewoldt excepted).

Therein lies the reason you've played finals twice in thirty years.

1-11 by Rd 12.

Bookmark it.

There might be 4 blokes there that should have numbers lower than 40. Port Melbourne would flog that lot.

 

[Jade's]

There might be 4 blokes there that should have numbers lower than 40. Port Melbourne would flog that lot.

Yet we still beat you!

 

[DimmasCubs]

You can add Houli, Grigg, Nahas and King to that list.

**** me this club is a joke.

I see your too pussy to accept my offer. Put your money where your mouth is flog?

 

[Jade's]

You can add Houli, Grigg, Nahas and King to that list.

**** me this club is a joke.

Those 4 would walk into the dogs team

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Yet we still beat you!

Yay!!!

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Apart from a couple of players, Richmond's lists is chock-a-block full of spuds. No wonder they haven't made the finals for over a decade

 

[Jade's]

Apart from a couple of players, Richmond's lists is chock-a-block full of spuds. No wonder they haven't made the finals for over a decade

See the composite team i posted and debate the selections on merit

 

[Old Skool]

Richmond players who would get a game at North or Hawthorn:

2. Dylan Grimes - No
4. Dustin Martin - Yes
6. Shaun Grigg - No
7. Matt Dea - No
8. Jack Riewoldt - Yes
9. Trent Cotchin - Yes
10. Shane Edwards - No
11. Jake Batchelor - No
13 Brad Miller - LOL
14 Bachar Houli - No
16. Luke McGuane - No
17. Chris Newman - No
18. Alex Rance - No
20. Ivan Maric - LOL
21. Shane Tuck - No
23. Daniel Jackson - No
25. Angus Graham - LOL
26. Robin Nahas - No
28. Jake King - No
29. Tyrone Vickery - No
30. Reece Conca - No
32. Brad Helbig - Who?
35. Matthew White - Who?
37. Jayden Post - No
38. Steven Morris - Who?
39. Tom Derickx - Who?
41. Nathan Foley - No
42. Brandon Ellis - Who?
43. Todd Elton - Who?
44. Matt Arnot - Who?
45. Brett O'Hanlon - Who?
46. Jeromey Webberley - Who?
47. Addam Maric - No
49. Steven Verrier - Who?

Draw your conclusions from that.

 

[cammo78]

Those 4 would walk into the dogs team

That'd be why you haven't beaten us in seven years.

They are hacks. Plain and simple.

 

[cammo78]

Richmond players who would get a game at North or Hawthorn:

2. Dylan Grimes - No
4. Dustin Martin - Yes
6. Shaun Grigg - No
7. Matt Dea - No
8. Jack Riewoldt - Yes
9. Trent Cotchin - Yes
10. Shane Edwards - No
11. Jake Batchelor - No
13 Brad Miller - LOL
14 Bachar Houli - No
16. Luke McGuane - No
17. Chris Newman - No
18. Alex Rance - No
20. Ivan Maric - LOL
21. Shane Tuck - No
23. Daniel Jackson - No
25. Angus Graham - LOL
26. Robin Nahas - No
28. Jake King - No
29. Tyrone Vickery - No
30. Reece Conca - No
32. Brad Helbig - Who?
35. Matthew White - Who?
37. Jayden Post - No
38. Steven Morris - Who?
39. Tom Derickx - Who?
41. Nathan Foley - No
42. Brandon Ellis - Who?
43. Todd Elton - Who?
44. Matt Arnot - Who?
45. Brett O'Hanlon - Who?
46. Jeromey Webberley - Who?
47. Addam Maric - No
49. Steven Verrier - Who?

Draw your conclusions from that.

First sensible post I've seen you make.

Shockingly ordinary list.

 

[Jade's]

Richmond players who would get a game at North or Hawthorn:

2. Dylan Grimes - No
4. Dustin Martin - Yes
6. Shaun Grigg - No
7. Matt Dea - No
8. Jack Riewoldt - Yes
9. Trent Cotchin - Yes
10. Shane Edwards - No
11. Jake Batchelor - No
13 Brad Miller - LOL
14 Bachar Houli - No
16. Luke McGuane - No
17. Chris Newman - No
18. Alex Rance - No
20. Ivan Maric - LOL
21. Shane Tuck - No
23. Daniel Jackson - No
25. Angus Graham - LOL
26. Robin Nahas - No
28. Jake King - No
29. Tyrone Vickery - No
30. Reece Conca - No
32. Brad Helbig - Who?
35. Matthew White - Who?
37. Jayden Post - No
38. Steven Morris - Who?
39. Tom Derickx - Who?
41. Nathan Foley - No
42. Brandon Ellis - Who?
43. Todd Elton - Who?
44. Matt Arnot - Who?
45. Brett O'Hanlon - Who?
46. Jeromey Webberley - Who?
47. Addam Maric - No
49. Steven Verrier - Who?

Draw your conclusions from that.

Na has cut you to pieces twice last year

Vickery would have finished 2nd in your leading goal kicker

King kicked more goals than any small forward for Norf

Grigg Houli Newman Rance Tuck Foley all would be walk up starts

Grimes would be your best key defender

Conca and bachelor have shown more than cunnington wright Adams

Even miller is a better player than Hansen

 

[cammo78]

Care to wager? How does $100 sound...that's if you can afford it?

Thanks for the offer. I can afford it, thanks for asking.

I'd rather whack my hundee on the Blues @ $1.30 in Rd 1 and roll it onto whoever the Tiges are facing (bar Port) until Rd 12.

Much smarter investment strategy.

I can do the same for you if you're not old enough to get a bet on.

 

[Bombers 2003]

why wouldn't robin nahas get a game at north or hawthorn?

 

[Jade's]

Thanks for the offer. I can afford it, thanks for asking.

I'd rather whack my hundee on the Blues @ $1.30 in Rd 1 and roll it onto whoever the Tiges are facing (bar Port) until Rd 12.

Much smarter investment strategy.

I can do the same for you if you're not old enough to get a bet on.

Lol. Dimma calls him and camo backs away at a rate of knots much like the bulldogs list...all bark no bite

 

[Old Skool]

why wouldn't robin nahas get a game at north or hawthorn?

Harvey, Thomas, Adams, Campbell, Harper, Wright and Speight are all better.

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Similar to Old Skool I was going rate Richmonds list and whether they would get game at Hawthorn but I almost completely agree with him.
Cotchin, Martin, Riewoldt would get a game. Most of the remaining are shockers

 

[cammo78]

Lol. Dimma calls him and camo backs away at a rate of knots much like the bulldogs list...all bark no bite

Explain to me why I'd lay $100 with a 16-year old on the Internet?!

You'll be 1-11 mate. Check the draw -you're ****ed.

Having a bet with me ain't going to mitigate that situation.

I can understand your enthusiasm though - it's all you have when your season's ****ed after round 4 every year.

Cheerio.

 

[Jade's]

Harvey, Thomas, Adams, Campbell, Harper, Wright and Speight are all better.

You say that yet nahas kicked more goals and averaged more disposals than any of them other than boomer

 

[Old Skool]

Richmond have got 4 x A graders, a couple of B graders and the rest is just generic filler.

They need at least 2 more top drafts to be a contender. They're honestly better off tanking.

 

[Jade's]

Similar to Old Skool I was going rate Richmonds list and whether they would get game at Hawthorn but I almost completely agree with him.
Cotchin, Martin, Riewoldt would get a game. Most of the remaining are shockers

Have a look at my composite team and make arguements based around statistical performance As to why the tigers players shouldn't be included

 

[Stratton_Gun]

why wouldn't robin nahas get a game at north or hawthorn?

A stupid question (but I don't expect any less from a Bummers supporter)

A more relevant question would be "Why wouldn't Nahas get game in the Broadmeadows U/10's"

 

[Theseventhhamster]

Vickery is AFL standard. He's getting underrated in this thread.

 

[Old Skool]

Vickery is AFL standard. He's getting underrated in this thread.

Currently a B grader, but you would definitely grab him if you could get a 5th Richmond player.

The cupboard is pretty bare after that.

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Have a look at my composite team and make arguements based around statistical performance As to why the tigers players shouldn't be included

Ceebs looking for it but feel free to post it again