Who should go at the end of the year?

[MagpiesMan]

Don't worry about contracts, list numbers salary caps, just who does everyone think shouldn't be playing for us next year?
My thoughts-
These should be certainties to leave: O'Bree, Walker, Lonie, J.Cloke, Cole, Davis,Swan, Lokan, Williams.
Trade bait: Tarrant, Woewodin, Didak, C.Cloke.

Hopefully we'll be a bit ruthless this year and get rid of the ordinary players and go after some big names.

 

[Lensen]

Lonie? Davis? Swan?

These guys aren't victims of a lack of ability, they're victims of a lack of chances in spots where they can actually play well. When Lonie and Davis start playing more in the guts, and Swan starts playing the roving forward he has done so well when he's given the chance, we'll see them come along.

No one will trade anything for Woey, given his salary.

 

[MaggieNo20]

I reckon the only certainity to go at the end of the year is Williams. Hopefully we can pick up a good freebie in the PSD with our No1 pick

 

[Coin_Toss]

These should be certainties to leave: Lokan, Williams, Bill Morrison, Chad Morrison, King, Swan, Holland (although Holland is ok).
More chances: Lonie, Jas Cloke, O'Bree, Davis.
Give them time: Cam Cloke, Davidson, Hall.
Trade Bait: Woey, Walker (could go into the "give them time" list), Caracella.

Why did we get Chad Morrison?

 

[Jabso]

Delisting Certainties: Lokan, Williams, King,
Last Chance: B.Morrison, O'Bree, Lonie, Woewodin, Davis, J.Cloke, Swan
Trade Bait: Lonie, O'Bree, Lockyer, Holland, J.Cloke?
Time: C.Cloke, Davidson, Hall,
Retiring (unlikely to be any): Burns, Buckley

Could be anywhere from 5-7 spots left for draft. Too early to make definate calls on some players.

Big fan of Swan. Could become a very handy back pocket player we have missed since Coles poor form and Johnsons move to the midfield. No real 'guns' but is a smart player, not many weaknesses, won't be exposed on oponent. I'd say his major strength is he knows what to do.

 

[diehard pie]

Bout time Buzz

You can't take half the list and just ******** them away
Only certainty should be Williams with a few others as traid bait and if not traided some delisted

 

[Braddock]

Exactly right. It's all well and good to say 7 players are certainties to be delisted, but who do you replace them with? For mine the only ones you could just about consider certain are Williams and Lokan, and even with those it's still too hard to predict. After all, who picked McGough to get delisted last year?

 

[Murray]

Don't worry about contracts, list numbers salary caps, just who does everyone think shouldn't be playing for us next year?
My thoughts-
These should be certainties to leave: O'Bree, Walker, Lonie, J.Cloke, Cole, Davis,Swan, Lokan, Williams.
Trade bait: Tarrant, Woewodin, Didak, C.Cloke.

Hopefully we'll be a bit ruthless this year and get rid of the ordinary players and go after some big names.

You just removed 33% of the playing list.

Do you really think that will happen?

 

[Murray]

Why did we get Chad Morrison?

Have a look at the voting by members of this board.

 

[hawkeye23]

Why did we get Chad Morrison?

Because your recruiting department love relying on their ability/necessity to recycle non-performing Eagles!

 

[Murray]

Because your recruiting department love relying on their ability/necessity to recycle non-performing Eagles!

Hello spunk

 

[hawkeye23]

Hello spunk

Good Morning. Quite cold this morning isn't it! You just can't wait to play "Where's Wally" (of a fashion) on Saturday can you?

 

[Murray]

Good Morning. Quite cold this morning isn't it! You just can't wait to play "Where's Wally" (of a fashion) on Saturday can you?

Ohhhh yeah

 

[hotpie]

King O'Bree Williams B Morrison Leonard and Lokan to go. Burns to have a good hard look at his future, hope he plays on but would not be surprised if he hangs up the boots. Hall to be seriously considered for delisting. Lonie to be retained only if he pulls his finger out for the rest of this year. Woey to be retained on a significantly reduced contract.

Trade bait almost everybody else.

 

[Ice goddess]

delist Lokan, Williams, Lockyer, Morrison, good trade bait would be Leon, Lonie, Fraser,

 

[bobneil130]

some people have no idea, you want to delist Cam Cloke when he has played 12 games of footy.
Yep no chance for him to improve hes only going to get worse from here, he will be 20 soon so he has no chance to get better. You fools.

Delist/Trade if we can: Woewoddin, Obree, Williams, Lokan, Lonie.
Trade if we can get something decent: J Cloke, T Walker
On the fringe: Lockyer, Cole, Morrison

I think J Cloke and Tex are very solid players that if we have a full strength side wont be playing but you need these types of players to adda bit of depth to the list as they can come in at any time.

 

[MagpiesMan]

You just removed 33% of the playing list.

Do you really think that will happen?

Clearly this can't happen I'm just dreaming.

 

[MagpiesMan]

some people have no idea, you want to delist Cam Cloke when he has played 12 games of footy.
Yep no chance for him to improve hes only going to get worse from here, he will be 20 soon so he has no chance to get better. You fools.

Delist/Trade if we can: Woewoddin, Obree, Williams, Lokan, Lonie.
Trade if we can get something decent: J Cloke, T Walker
On the fringe: Lockyer, Cole, Morrison

I think J Cloke and Tex are very solid players that if we have a full strength side wont be playing but you need these types of players to adda bit of depth to the list as they can come in at any time.

If these guys create such depth, then why are we sitting on the bottom of the ladder? From what I hear C.Cloke has caused a bit of trouble down there so I think it would be a good thing to see the back of his fat ****.

 

[diehard pie]

What a positive dream that must have been PieMan
I am sensing you are not a very patient person. Keep your chin up

 

[diehard pie]

From what I hear C.Cloke has caused a bit of trouble down there so I think it would be a good thing to see the back of his fat ****.

OUCH

 

[bobneil130]

If these guys create such depth, then why are we sitting on the bottom of the ladder? From what I hear C.Cloke has caused a bit of trouble down there so I think it would be a good thing to see the back of his fat ****.

Why would you comment on something you obvisouly no nothing about.

Idiot.

 

[grayza]

it was probably said earlier, i just didnt pick it up,...but Billy Morrison was drafted as a project player, is very much still a project player, and will get a couple more seasons, at leats until end of 2007 to try prove something

 

[Dr AlfAndrews]

I think the Club itself should go.

We are just not up to AFL standard.

Maybe we should relocate to Adelaide and join the SANFL. We might have to put a bit of teal on our jumper so we don't clash with the real magpies

 

[Dr AlfAndrews]

some people have no idea, you want to delist Cam Cloke when he has played 12 games of footy.
Yep no chance for him to improve hes only going to get worse from here, he will be 20 soon so he has no chance to get better. You fools.

I'm quite sure he could improve if he wasn't so far up his own arse.

The problem is he already thinks he's a champion. You can tell by the way he prances around the field. Sort of like a young Carl Ditterich ... but without the ability.

People like that will never take the Club anywhere.

 

[celtic_pride]

some people have no idea, you want to delist Cam Cloke when he has played 12 games of footy.
Yep no chance for him to improve hes only going to get worse from here, he will be 20 soon so he has no chance to get better. You fools.

Delist/Trade if we can: Woewoddin, Obree, Williams, Lokan, Lonie.
Trade if we can get something decent: J Cloke, T Walker

Do you honestly think any club would be dumb enough to trade for any of the players you have mentioned (well maybe apart from Lonie ?)
Obree and Williams should have been delisted last year.
Still it's good that you have identified the dead wood that need to be culled from the list.