Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[South of the Yarra]

Yeah mate you sound like you’re in his corner massively.

Dropping hints spreading negativity about a ****ing 16yo? Huge support you must be.

Keep crying victim though.

Keep it up.

I know Carlton supporters won’t have the balls to pick you up on your embarrassing comment but several Collingwood supporters already have. I made it very clear I will be proud of the kid no matter where he plays yet you doubt my Aboriginal pride in these kids by responding

Except for this kid.

‘What a shame you let footy club tribalism effect your judgement.’

Shameful and just as shameful not one Carlton supporter had the balls to pull you up. Crying victim hey, I have been the Aboriginal victim and I fought hard to no longer be a victim but be a survivor. It’s people like you that makes me appreciate how far I have come.

 

[Fadge]

We weren't the reigning premiers though

No. That's right, you weren't.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

I know Carlton supporters won’t have the balls to pick you up on your embarrassing comment but several Collingwood supporters already have. I made it very clear I will be proud of the kid no matter where he plays yet you doubt my Aboriginal pride in these kids by responding

Except for this kid.

‘What a shame you let footy club tribalism effect your judgement.’

Shameful and just as shameful not one Carlton supporter had the balls to pull you up. Crying victim hey, I have been the Aboriginal victim and I fought hard to no longer be a victim but be a survivor. It’s people like you that makes me appreciate how far I have come.

Bullshit. Look at your first comment about him - telling Carlton supporters they’re in for a rude shock & to temper their excitement. The KID is clearly the best u/16 player getting around and you’re talking him down due to him being a Carlton F/S prospect.

When I suggest you’re letting your Collingwood tribalism cloud your judgement you go on a tangent about race.

So I’ll ask again, if he were a Collingwood F/S prospect, would you be saying the same comments about him?

I actually know the kid and his old man, they’d brush off your comments no problems but they’d be wondering why you’re doubting him.

 

[carlton_99]

Shameful and just as shameful not one Carlton supporter had the balls to pull you up.

It's a commonly used term in all sports which refers to the one-eyed nature of a team's supporters. You have made it clear now that it is offensive to you so it shouldn't be used again on here but you can't expect us to know that when it is such a widely used term in world sport.

 

[Fadge]

Bang on the money see you're getting smarter

Getting smarter?

Or completely misunderstanding your response?

 

[carlton_99]

Getting smarter?

Or completely misunderstanding your response?

Still nothing on my "inability to understand basic trading"?

Will you ever admit to being wrong? Or when you are proven wrong do you just pretend it never happened?

 

[South of the Yarra]

It's a commonly used term in all sports which refers to the one-eyed nature of a team's supporters. You have made it clear now that it is offensive to you so it shouldn't be used again on here but you can't expect us to know that when it is such a widely used term in world sport.

Happy to chat to you but want nothing to do with that other poster. It’s not the words tribalism that it is insulting it is the fact i clearly told him that I would be proud to see any Aboriginal kid play for any club. When you hsve have been one of the stolen ones you get pretty damn proud to see any Aboriginal kid has a pathway that may help him / her achieve. His immediate comment was inferring I was lying that I would not be proud of Walker due to the club he may play for. For him to suggest I would turn my back on my Aboriginal culture when I clear noted my pride is a disgrace and really shameful comment.

 

[carlton_99]

Happy to chat to you but want nothing to do with that other poster. It’s not the words tribalism that it is insulting it is the fact i clearly told him that I would be proud to see any Aboriginal kid play for any club. When you hsve have been one of the stolen ones you get pretty damn proud to see any Aboriginal kid has a pathway that may help him / her achieve. His immediate comment was inferring I was lying that I would not be proud of Walker due to the club he may play for. For him to suggest I would turn my back on my Aboriginal culture when I clear noted my pride is a disgrace and really shameful comment.

I'm not going to speak for the other poster but I just didn't like your comment about us "being shocked" about Walker. It did sound like you were making an insinuation about him that was in a negative light. Especially as you repeated it multiple times. My comment on that had nothing to do with race in any way so if that's how it came across and why you called me "twisted" I do apologise.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I'm not going to speak for the other poster but I just didn't like your comment about us "being shocked" about Walker. It did sound like you were making an insinuation about him that was in a negative light. Especially as you repeated it multiple times. My comment on that had nothing to do with race in any way so if that's how it came across and why you called me "twisted" I do apologise.

This. I don't get how race or heritage has been brought into the discussion but I just want to know why we're in for a "shock" with Cody? He's quite obviously in the best handful of 16 year olds in the country if not a clear standout.

 

[South of the Yarra]

I'm not going to speak for the other poster but I just didn't like your comment about us "being shocked" about Walker. It did sound like you were making an insinuation about him that was in a negative light. Especially as you repeated it multiple times. My comment on that had nothing to do with race in any way so if that's how it came across I do apologise.

No need to apologise as I said my beef is not with you it is with that other poster.
It is interesting that Carlton are shocked at any perceived negative light to a great young kid like Walker but have been happy to slam Nick Daicos for years even as a kid. Was pretty funny then. Number 1 I was not slamming him, I made it very clear in several posts the kid is a great kid and a great footballer. A rare talent. I was referring to the fact there is lots of decision making still to be made. That posters comment is unforgivable

 

[carlton_99]

No need to apologise as I said my beef is not with you it is with that other poster.
It is interesting that Carlton are shocked at any perceived negative light to a great young kid like Walker but have been happy to slam Nick Daicos for years even as a kid. Was pretty funny then. Number 1 I was not slamming him, I made it very clear in several posts the kid is a great kid and a great footballer. A rare talent. I was referring to the fact there is lots of decision making still to be made. That posters comment is unforgivable

Well you called me "twisted" so I clearly did something wrong.

And I wouldn't be lumping all Carlton supporters into one box - I haven't said a negative thing about Daicos. But you are going to get that in a thread equally filled with some Pies fans going after the likes of Curnow, Walsh etc

 

[PCORF]

If healthy I think the Pies will be better than the Blues.

 

[South of the Yarra]

Well you called me "twisted" so I clearly did something wrong.

And I wouldn't be lumping all Carlton supporters into one box - I haven't said a negative thing about Daicos. But you are going to get that in a thread equally filled with some Pies fans going after the likes of Curnow, Walsh etc

I apologise for the twisted comment. I thought you referring to me and the comments about a 16 year old in a different light.

 

[Bale Dup]

Getting smarter?

Or completely misunderstanding your response?

Understood the response, just not worth replying

On SM-G980F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Worm4]

If healthy I think the Pies will be better than the Blues.

That's a big if with a side full of geriatrics . Having them all in the best 23 together just won't happen due to their age demographic

 

[Worm4]

Bit like Carlton and Crippa hey. Leads the team in Handballs, Disposals, Inside 50s, Clearances, Frees For, Frees Against, Contested Possessions.

Difference is, Cripps turns 30 next year

So pendles turning 38 or whatever next year isn't a problem , but Cripps turning 30 is a big deal. Blow me down with a feather

 

[Worm4]

Happy to chat to you but want nothing to do with that other poster. It’s not the words tribalism that it is insulting it is the fact i clearly told him that I would be proud to see any Aboriginal kid play for any club. When you hsve have been one of the stolen ones you get pretty damn proud to see any Aboriginal kid has a pathway that may help him / her achieve. His immediate comment was inferring I was lying that I would not be proud of Walker due to the club he may play for. For him to suggest I would turn my back on my Aboriginal culture when I clear noted my pride is a disgrace and really shameful comment.

What I got out of the original comment was that you thought that Cody Walker might end up at Richmond ? Am I wrong ?
I doubt that will be the case as Carlton have been courting him since he was born...

 

[Captivating]

So pendles turning 38 or whatever next year isn't a problem , but Cripps turning 30 is a big deal. Blow me down with a feather

Carlton's top 10 for disposals in 2023 (removing Kennedy):

3 x over 30
7 x under 30


compared to Collingwood's top 10 (removing Noble)

3 x over 30
7 x under 30

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Oldiewood is just old, old, old.

I mean glacier-old.

Older than the moon & with much more gravity!

They have zero youth coming through to refresh their team, oldies just getting freaking older!

9 players over 30 - olllllllllld!

They will break the world record for the number of strained calf muscles in a season!

Not to mention broken hips!

After which, they’ll all sit around the fire & regale each other of their WW2 stories - when they fought together at the Battle Of The Bulge.

(Of course this will trigger “brackets” Schultzy, making him feel a little uncomfortable)

 

[Worm4]

Carlton's top 10 for disposals in 2023 (removing Kennedy):

3 x over 30
7 x under 30


compared to Collingwood's top 10 (removing Noble)

3 x over 30
7 x under 30

I'm not concerned about Cripps turning 30. I don't understand why pie supporters bring up Cripps age ? It seems they think its an issue for some reason

 

[Worm4]

You hope a pick turns into a quality senior player.

We won't be picking a freeman or a scharenberg, so we will be ok

 

[Worm4]

the kid is a great kid and a great footballer. A rare talent. I was referring to the fact there is lots of decision making still to be made.

Can you clarify what exactly you mean by this sentence ?

 

[Robertio]

Carlton are so close to the holy grail.

Keep persisting, you'll get there!

Closer than the Pies.

 

[T2B_]

this is a disgusting post

Not sure why people are jumping on that comment. Tribalism used in this context is very common, I.e one eyed footy supporters, but hell I've seen it used in reference to people on the internet and how they act in regards to politics etc.

Let's not make it about something its not in order to point score.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Closer than the Pies.

You underestimate the impact to Oldiewood, from recruiting Dylan Shiel.

I mean - Dan Houston!!!

Sorry peeps.