Vintage Bay Worst 200 game player

[Coondogs]

I've discussed this with numerous people before and in my opinion it would have to be Jarred Crouch (Tivendale can't make the grade with 188 or Nick Davis with 164). Anthony Rock would rank pretty closely behind. Who else do people think of in recent years?

 

[SpecialComments]

There is no such thing as "the worst 200 game player".

If you stick around long enough to play 200 games, its a great effort. Those people you mentioned have done things for their clubs at times, that you don't know what their coach has asked of them. Crouch might not have been the most talented, but him and Aker had some great battles, which I'd give the honours to him. Davis got Sydney into a GF and has excited crowds with his freakishness at times. I find it a bit stupid that you would call anyone who has played 200 games, to try and find the worst player out of it.

 

[amer]

Obviously Parker and McManus.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

 

[Big Delut]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

Where does anyone mention Anthony Rocca?

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

Wow, pre-emptive defense.

Never seen that before on BF.

 

[Bomberlicious]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

Vinnie - Anthony Rock - 222 games for North & Hawthorn ('88 - '01)
Anthony Rocca - 238 games for Sydney & Collingwood ('95 - present)

It's called Google, mate...

 

[gandaal]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

*cough*

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthony_Rock

 

[boomer37]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

Don't see Rocca being mentioned, maybe its your sub-conscious telling you rocca is the worst 200 game player....

 

[Altum Volantes]

I agree with vinnie, Anthony Rocca is clearly the worst.

 

[kidstyler]

Obviously Parker and McManus.

ohhh snap who didn't see this coming.

 

[chappy1979]

McManus 4 sure!

 

[amer]

ohhh snap who didn't see this coming.

lol. maybe because its obvious??

 

[Rabbit of Caerbannog]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

Ouch.

 

[dont bowl there]

Has anyone nominated Anthony Rocca? He would be my choice.

 

[Burzum]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

lulz

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

This thread should be renamed '2nd worst 200 game player' as Anthony Rocca is the presumed worst.

 

[Mr Mojo Risin]

Shane Woewodin, Norm Ware, Stuart Trott, Allan Stoneham, Michael Sexton, Michael Roach, Ted Pool, Scott McIvor, John Longmire, Neville Fields and George Bennett are the only players in VFL/AFL history to play 200 games only.

If I had to pick a team including all of them bar one then Stuart Trott would miss out.

 

[Bomberlicious]

I think Vinnie killed this thread...

 

[Jimthegreat]

Where does anyone mention Anthony Rocca?

It's Vinnie. No respect there at all. Don't be upsetting the Colliwobbles you might get a ban. Doesn't surprise me he doesn't know the difference between Rock and Rocca....hilarious...LOL !!! They give moderators jobs out easily. Then again it's Collingwood.

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

I think Vinnie is stuck between a Rocca and a hard about face.

 

[Scallop Industry Thug]

I think Vinnie is stuck between a Rocca and a hard about face.

I have reported your post.

 

[Weiterbot23]

You are a buffoon, Coondogs.

Anthony Rocca has clearly earned his 200 games. He has been the focal point up forward a Collingwood team that has gone close to a premiership on more than one occasion, and he's kicked 411 goals for his career, despite playing a large portion of it at CHF.

When he's in the side, he ALWAYS draws the best defender, which would indicate that the coaches know a lot more about his ability than you do.

But you're a Dogs fan - It wouldn't surprise me if you've forgotten what value a KP forward has.

You should be banned from BF

 

[ToO]

1. A Rocca
2. A Rocca
3. A Rocca

 

[dont bowl there]

Surprised no mention of A.Rocca.