Worst players in Good teams?

[DarkPhoenix]

Its pretty much a fact that a side is never 100% decent. Theres always one guy you look at and say "How the hell does he get a game in that side?".

By good sides lets just say Top 8 for this year. But if you have any historical duds in good sides feel free to nominate them.

 

[The Big League]

I'd rattle off a few Carlton names, however they are not a good team so I'll just say L.Brown

 

[DarkPhoenix]

Ill throw in Cloke (maggies), because i dont rate him at all.

 

[Bayer_]

Collingwood - Cloke, Rocca, Fraser (alright skills, but soft as a pillow).
Geelong - M. Stokes, T. Hawkins, H. Taylor, J. Kelly.
Hawthorn - we have em, but there'll be plenty of comment on that one.
St. Kilda - Both Clarkes.

 

[Renegade]

Collingwood - Cloke, Rocca, Fraser (alright skills, but soft as a pillow).
Geelong - M. Stokes, T. Hawkins, H. Taylor, J. Kelly.
Hawthorn - we have em, but there'll be plenty of comment on that one.
St. Kilda - Both Clarkes.

He said good teams.
Why are you putting Hawthorn up there with top 4 sides?

 

[Bayer_]

He said good teams.
Why are you putting Hawthorn up there with top 4 sides?

I'll bump this thread at the start of next year to remind you, Handbagger. BTW enjoy the last dregs of your premiership window, would be very sad to go back to the wilderness with only one flag.

 

[Renegade]

I'll bump this thread at the start of next year to remind you, Handbagger. BTW enjoy the last dregs of your premiership window, would be very sad to go back to the wilderness with only one flag.

Wow scathing!
Nice join date bandwagoner.

 

[Tyler Durden007]

Collingwood - Cloke, Rocca, Fraser (alright skills, but soft as a pillow).
Geelong - M. Stokes, T. Hawkins, H. Taylor, J. Kelly.
Hawthorn - we have em, but there'll be plenty of comment on that one.
St. Kilda - Both Clarkes.

Just go on ****ing holidays will you...

 

[Team Chemistry]

I'll bump this thread at the start of next year to remind you, Handbagger. BTW enjoy the last dregs of your premiership window, would be very sad to go back to the wilderness with only one flag.

Yeah, Hawthorn's premiership window on the other hand is going along swimmingly. Clear it up for me would you, it was last year you were a year ahead of schedule, yeah? Making this year your...on schedule ...year...?

How's that going for you?

 

[Bayer_]

Just go on ****ing holidays will you...

Those three were all witches hats in the GF, all contributed to Hawthorn's premiership. If you can't recognise that, you're living in denial.

 

[Team Chemistry]

Those three were all witches hats in the GF, all contributed to Hawthorn's premiership. If you can't recognise that, you're living in denial.

One bad game does not prompt asking the question "How the hell do they get a game in that team?"

Read the OP you ****ing twat.

 

[owenkraveki]

The night-time specialist - TOOVEY!!!

Although to his credit, he has improved immensley.

 

[Bayer_]

Yeah, Hawthorn's premiership window on the other hand is going along swimmingly. Clear it up for me would you, it was last year you were a year ahead of schedule, yeah? Making this year your...on schedule ...year...?

How's that going for you?

Two years ahead of schedule, actually, to quote Clarko. This year was our depth building year. A good pre-season and there won't be much stopping the Hawks.

 

[Team Chemistry]

Two years ahead of schedule, actually, to quote Clarko. This year was our depth building year. A good pre-season and there won't be much stopping the Hawks.

Anything coming out of that well-rounded human being must be gospel.
Fluked a premiership outside of your window, and now it's closed.
At least we have one flag (minimum) and years of dominance to our credit. You just have one flag with an asterisk next to it.

 

[Bayer_]

Anything coming out of that well-rounded human being must be gospel.
Fluked a premiership outside of your window, and now it's closed.
At least we have one flag (minimum) and years of dominance to our credit. You just have one flag with an asterisk next to it.

Can you tell me how many examples are in the history books of premierships marked by an asterisk, or mentions of successful but, ultimately, unfruitful periods of dominance? Didn't think so. People only ever remember the last 10 or 15 years, thereafter it's all about the flags next to your name.

 

[The Donners]

Essendon: Henry Slattery, Michael Quinn.

 

[DarkPhoenix]

Good to see people targetting their own clubs as well

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Stokes and Varcoe at Geelong are disgraceful footballers.

In a side like Melbourne or Richmond, they wouldn't get a touch.

At Hawthorn, I think Tom Murphy's year has been appropriately analysed on our boards.

 

[SwampCreature]

Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake Mark Blake

 

[Ashboy]

Cats forwards apart from Steve J and Chapman, and Mark Blake

 

[lions_den]

Jack Watts.

 

[Bert1]

Jack Watts.

C'mon mate. Worst call of the thread....
Title says GOOD teams.

 

[Silvagnis]

Zac Dawson - imagine Dawson playing one out at Melbourne or Richmond with the ball coming in lace out every minute.

Andrew McQualter - delisted and re-drafted for being a keg on legs.

Clinton Jones - Jones' disposal makes Carrazzo look like Akermanis.

 

[IluvHarvey]

Zac Dawson - imagine Dawson playing one out at Melbourne or Richmond with the ball coming in lace out every minute.

Andrew McQualter - delisted and re-drafted for being a keg on legs.

Clinton Jones - Jones' disposal makes Carrazzo look like Akermanis.

And yet all 3 would walk straight into your team!!

 

[Bert1]

And yet all 3 would walk straight into your team!!

And walk out gay!