Erwin Fletcher
Debutant
Who would be the worst player to represent us? My vote would be for Richard Lounder he was a shocker! But I reckon anyone from the late 80's and early 90's might qualify!
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 4 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Bumped Worst Tiger Player Ever?
- Thread starter Erwin Fletcher
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Sausage roll said:
tigerdan
Norm Smith Medallist
Laffy was absolutely useless, especially considering how many games he had...
Lionel Proctor
prefer to erase them from the dark recesses of my mind and fill that vast space with the litany of champions that have worn the Yellow & Black
However if I was to be put under duress for an answer, clearly it would be Justin Blumfield, played and acted like a bum, completely disrespected the priveldge of being a Tiger, made me sick in the guts
However if I was to be put under duress for an answer, clearly it would be Justin Blumfield, played and acted like a bum, completely disrespected the priveldge of being a Tiger, made me sick in the guts
Yeah, not something I like to dwell on, but there was a guy back in the early 80s called Wayne Shand.
Absolute shocking player.
I was reduced to tears one day in 1982 or 83 when I went to Princes Park to watch the lad play the Blues and out should run the aforementioned Wayne Shand in the #30 guernsey of my all-time favourite Tiger and idol Francis Bourke.
I was ropable - even as a 13 year old kid and went home and penned a letter to the club!
Goes to show, our club was disrespectful even back then!!
Absolute shocking player.
I was reduced to tears one day in 1982 or 83 when I went to Princes Park to watch the lad play the Blues and out should run the aforementioned Wayne Shand in the #30 guernsey of my all-time favourite Tiger and idol Francis Bourke.
I was ropable - even as a 13 year old kid and went home and penned a letter to the club!
Goes to show, our club was disrespectful even back then!!
peejay
Brownlow Medallist
Kicked four goals in a game which is a lot more than other 4 game wonders.
Mind you 9 of his career 12 possesions came in that game.
I reckon Wayne Hernamen as just about the worst i have seen.
Out of those who played a little longer i reckon John Manton was pretty bad.
However they all were 100 X better than me
peejay
Brownlow Medallist
He had a nice raking long kick on him,he was just a rotten defender.
peejay
Brownlow Medallist
peter Williams - number 28, late 70's was a shocker.
As was ex saint Darryl Cowie, late 80's
As was ex saint Darryl Cowie, late 80's
Oh yes - how could i forget him. Thanks for putting that memory back into my brain.
I still have nightmares, Peejay!
But what also continues to bug me is that the club never learned from its mistakes.
KB retired and what happens... a few years later they handed his jumper to another contender for worst player...Brett Mahoney...and then Todd Menegola!!!
God help us what they do with the sacred #12 when Richo goes?
It better be put on ice for a year or two...or handed directly to one J. Riewoldt!
Brian Winton.
Heisenberg_
17🏆19🏆20🏆
so many choices
Ben Hollands he was horrible.
Ben Hollands he was horrible.
Rolfe another dud.
so many choices
Ben Hollands he was horrible.
Not against freo in 1999 he won us that game.
Ahhhh we churned out some junk down there in defence. Cowie, Stephen Pirie (though career ruined by knee injuries), Goodwin, the late Richard Nixon, Michael Thomson, Paul Barlow.
Michael Rolfe...debuted v Footscray I think...played a good game...alas, that was it!
Same day as Winton debuted!
Heisenberg_
17🏆19🏆20🏆
A recent one, the Shane Morrison and Luke Weller combo.
Spud thought they deserved a shot because they just couldn't get a game being behind Jon Brown.
Turns out they were ****ing shit
Spud thought they deserved a shot because they just couldn't get a game being behind Jon Brown.
Turns out they were ****ing shit
- Banned
- #22
saw him at the races what a complete d***head!
- Banned
- #23
was at that game , no 41 wasnt he?
- Mar 30, 2007
- 597
- 4
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Second that.
