Would you still trade for Judd?

[opng]

First i must say im not on here trying to troll or anything like that id love a serious answer.

If carlton had not secured a priority pick would most of you have been happy trading pick 2 for judd? and i will add im not against carlton getting a priority pick, they played by the rules, any other supporter would have wanted the same thing for their club and if they say any different their lying.

 

[melo_15]

If carlton had not secured a priority pick would most of you have been happy trading pick 2 for judd?

HELL YES!!!

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

If we missed the priority pick but finished 15th therefore getting Pick 2, we would have missed Kreuzer so would have traded Pick 2 for Judd, no problem. I wonder if Pick 2 would have got the job done for the Eagles without needing Kennedy as 2 guarantees Cotchin. #2 and #19, no picks but get Judd and keep Kennedy. I could have lived with that.

 

[Waite_30]

We would of had more competition from Richmond, but we would have given up pick 2, i rekon.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Yes I would still have traded for Judd.



Thanks for showing some respect on our board mate and not trolling.

I'm amazed at how many opposition supporters have been coming on here and acting like d#cks lately.

People are carrying on like teams have never tanked before. Teams tank every year FFS. Anyone remember Kepler on Richo in round 22 06? We only would have tanked the last couple anyway and that was sipmly by resting players for the new year which is common sense.

 

[mediumsizered]

If we missed the priority pick but finished 15th therefore getting Pick 2, we would have missed Kreuzer so would have traded Pick 2 for Judd, no problem. I wonder if Pick 2 would have got the job done for the Eagles without needing Kennedy as 2 guarantees Cotchin. #2 and #19, no picks but get Judd and keep Kennedy. I could have lived with that.

I knew we should have won that last game against Melbourne. Then no way could anyone have called us 'tanks'.

 

[opng]

Should have added that i ment 2, 19 and kennedy. Same deal as traded but without carlton still having the PP.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Should have added that i ment 2, 19 and kennedy. Same deal as traded but without carlton still having the PP.

Yes, I would have done that.

 

[RPCB]

Hell yes i still would've traded for Judd.

Lets face it Cotchin is nothing like and never will be anything like Judd.

Judd is a one in a billion player and he's all ours guaranteed for 5 years and most likely for the next 10 years.

 

[Bomba Sheldon]

Should have added that i ment 2, 19 and kennedy. Same deal as traded but without carlton still having the PP.

Yes like all other clubs in our position would have. the ones that say they wouldnt are either lying or kidding themselves.

 

[HBF]

Hell yeah.
You don't fu^k around and miss the opportunity to recruit the best player in the country.

 

[Blue Dimension]

He's the best player in the competition. Why the hell wouldn't we?

 

[blues4flag]

Definitely. The fear alone at the reemergence of the giant after the Judd announcement has been worth it.

 

[GPW1]

I knew we should have won that last game against Melbourne. Then no way could anyone have called us 'tanks'.

yeah then it wouldve been endless "omg stoopid blues won a pointless game a gave up pick 1 lololol!!!!111!!" threads.