I was there in 99, 03, 05 and 09.without even really doing a deep dive, Melbourne has had some absolute crackers in dry and wet conditions. Had a few dull years at the start of the hybrid era but both the first decade of Melbourne and recent times have been fantastic.
Dare I say it more than Adelaide. Adelaide had the championship showdown factor and had plenty of 'moments' but if Adelaide was the first race of the season would we be going on about how crazy Schumacher taking out Hill was or Mansell's tyre failure?
That being said, 2014 takes so many points off as I remember standing at Turn 2 for the hybrid's first laps thinking "what the hell is this sound?". And those phallic noses
1999 - Eddie Irvine's first win
2002 - Barrichello up their Cazaly, Webber's first points
2003 - wet/dry epic
2005 - Fisi's first win, entertaining mixed up grid race
2006 - so many things happened, Alonso vs Kimi, Button's fiery engine on the start/finish straight on the last lap
2009 - the whole Brawn first race story
2012 - very good race, top 4 finished within 5 sec of each other
23-24-25 were all cracking races
They were not exciting races. 09 was right up there with 98 as the Brawns were sooooo much better than everyone else, the only interest was whether MW would podium, and that was answered on the first lap.
Im sorry, its just not an exciting track and nothing will convince me otherwise. Even the event itself was dull prior to COVID.