Opinion Our best three players

[Mr Lloyd Christmas]

The thread title is very simple and that is exactly what I am asking.

The Jy thread had me thinking that there is quite clearly different views on how we see our players, some rate higher others some rate lower. (which is fine)

As of right now who are your best three players in order, and i'll tally them up on Friday.

1. LDU
2. Simpkin
3. McKay

It's actually pretty difficult to list the three, well I could shuffle various different three's around and feel ok about it.

*Cunnington is not in the discussion as clearly our best so it's available players only.

 

[King Corey]

1. Eddie Ford
2. Eddie Ford
3. Eddie Ford

Apologies I couldn't fit more Eddie Ford into the list.

 

[MinistryOfMajak]

LDU
Jy
McKay

Zurhaar comes closest to knocking one of these off. He must be re-signed.

Sent from my SM-S906E using Tapatalk

 

[AnEmptyChair]

Obviously Cunners, but without him:

1. Jy
2. McKay
3. LDU

I want to see LDU do it for longer than 6-8 weeks, but i expect that he'll be our best player this time next year.

 

[Twangler]

Agreed - LDU, Simpkin McKay. And on current form Zurhaar isn’t far off at all

 

[Frank Thring]

No Goldy?

3. LDU
2. Goldy
1. Jy

 

[The Filth Wizard]

If the winner of this poll gets a $50 Roo Shop voucher I am shutting this down.

LDU
Simpkin
McKay

With Goldstein and Zurhaar just missing.

 

[Mr Lloyd Christmas]

1. Eddie Ford
2. Eddie Ford
3. Eddie Ford

Apologies I couldn't fit more Eddie Ford into the list.

Ha! I'm looking forward to him getting some more game time.

 

[buttox]

No Goldy?

3. LDU
2. Goldy
1. Jy

Spot on IMO.

 

[Mr Lloyd Christmas]

No Goldy?

3. LDU
2. Goldy
1. Jy

Of course Goldy can be voted for! He is still quality.

As I said, it isn't that easy imo

 

[Passmore]

Cunnington*
Goldstein
Simpkin

I can’t leave him out despite OP’s rules.

 

[Mr Lloyd Christmas]

Cunnington*
Goldstein
Simpkin

I can’t leave him out despite OP’s rules.

Just pick your best 3 mate as it not rules more that we already know Cunners is our best when fit and firing.

If not, no worries, i'll tally your other two.

 

[buttox]

Top 10 via ranking points. (Cunners would be first on last years results.)

I would be interested to see how the coaches votes compare but I cant seem to find club totals.

 

[The acurate one]

I don't think we have three that stand out.

LDU, Simpkin, McKay, Cunners, Goldy & Zurhaar and there's a bit of a gap to the next lot of Larkey, TT and Stevo then those too inexperienced as yet and then come the shitmen. We have oodles fyi

 

[gerry101101]

LDU
Mckay
Goldstein

Very honourable mention: Zurhaar

Honourable mention: Jy, Curtis

How I want this to look in 2 years time:

LDU
JHF
Comben

 

[Bren]

LDU
Mckay
Goldstein

Very honourable mention: Zurhaar

Honourable mention: Jy, Curtis

How I want this to look in 2 years time:

LDU
JHF
Comben

same

 

[Mr Lloyd Christmas]

I don't think we have three that stand out.

LDU, Simpkin, McKay, Cunners, Goldy & Zurhaar and there's a bit of a gap to the next lot of Larkey, TT and Stevo then those too inexperienced as yet and then come the shitmen. We have oodles fyi

That is exactly why I made the thread is because we don't have three clear standouts.

So list your 3 please TAO as of this moment!

 

[The acurate one]

That is exactly why I made the thread is because we don't have three clear standouts.

So list your 3 please TAO as of this moment!

Honestly MLC. Zurhaar, LDU and Simpkin.

 

[Ball Dont Lie]

No clear 3 and excluding Ben 10

Top 5 in no real order

McKay
LDU
Simpkin
Goldie
Zurharr

How I want it to be by end of 24

Thomas
JHF
WAP

 

[Engimal v3]

This changes, but right now:

3. LDU
2. McKay
1. Zurhaar

 

[ferball]

Right now...

I'm going with Buckets, LDU and JY but not sure the order so I'll go with the votes for the MVP.

LDU,
JY
McKay

Goldy and Jy are equal second and LMac is one point behind them but I'd still count those three, in that order right now.

 

[Tiberius]

Someone has to do it...
3. Mahoney
2. Turner
1. Polec

 

[franjon]

Ha! I'm looking forward to him getting some more game time.

Any game time at all would do me. Can't understand it.

 

[The acurate one]

Currently the only king of his position we have now is Zurhaar. As good as it gets in a side which measures fwd fifty entries by time not numbers.

Oh well

 

[Massive Unit]

1. Cunners

Daylight

2. LDU
3. Goldy

Honourable mentions to Jy and Cam Z.