Search results for query: *

He possibly gave up one flag by going to Gold Coast. He may yet win another one if he hangs around for the next 3-5 years. Whats worth more?? Staying at an already successful club or helping build a club from scratch and captaining it to its first flag??

Did Nigel Lappin even have a knee reco??? I can remember a broken leg, a severe ankle inury and knee tendinitis. No reco's come to mind. Care to elaborate a bit more about the Hodge incident. If he stuck his leg out and tripped Lappin in the same fashion as Fletcher has done in the past then he...

Pretty sure that is what everyone who doesn't barrack for the Swans is saying too

Every panel member on league teams, all ex-players believed what Goodes did was dangerous. They all agreed he isn't a thug as do most people on here but they all thought he had history of going in to a contest feet first and needs to change his approach. I personally don't think it wa reportable...

Basically says it all happened at the same time buddy. I also used the word "about" in there implying it not to be an exact timeframe! Took his legs out with a erratic attempt at kicking the ball off the ground. Was dangerous. That is all. I'm assuming you have no argument hence the resort to...

There was still contact below the knees mate. About one millisencond after that thigh contact you continue to bang on about. As I have said before I don't think that particular incident was reportable so whether it constitutes a trip or not is irrelevent. I just think it potentially could have...

Why does it matter where the intial contact was when his foot clearly takes out Gibsons lower leg (there we go, that should cover both shin and ankle!). His intent was the ball in any case but his action took Gibson legs out from under him. Like I said reckless act but not intentional. Needs to...

Agree with everything you just said. Finally!!!! I dont think Goodsey lacks courage, I think he has an issue he needs to sort before he does break someones leg or worse for you Swans fans gets rubbed out for a month!

He always tread a fine line. But no-one here is denying that. Unlike you Swans fans who have your heads so far up Adam Goodes bum you can't even acknowledge he may have a technical issue with the way he attacks the ball at times.

You are right, still got him below the knee on the right leg though.

Yeah thats right, you're the bloke who thinks he hit Gibson on the thigh despite Gibson clutching his shin. Sorry, my bad.

That flog raised a valid point. I can still hear the crying from Swans fans when Rohan had his leg broken. Goodes is treading a fine line.

Funny how not one Sydney fan can actually discuss the incident that took place but rather attack the man. It was a silly thing to do by Goodes, probably not quite reportable but is approaching that line and he has a history of doing this regularly throughout his career. Dangerous act and it...

Yep thats why Gibbo is seen clutching his ankle after the incident. Stop living in denial. Its a tiny little flaw Goodes has in his game and you Sydney twats cant even acknowledge it!

He was trying to kick the ball, only problem was he kicked Gibbo instead. I don't think anyone has said the guy went in there trying to maim Gibbo, it was just a careless act that potentially could have done a lot more harm. Gibbo was in quite a bit of discomfort after it and had to leave the...

Reckless act. No intent to hurt but just stupid. Simple as that. He should stop doing it and it was worse than Nat Fyfes kick that he got rubbed out for.

Just as long as you're not thanking me for saying ÿou sound like a bloody Collingwood supporter" ;)

Put it this way, if you were Kevin Sheedy (god forbid) next week. Would you see it as a sign of disrespect if the Hawks fronted up without Hodge, Gibson, Mitchell, Sewell, Franklin and Roughead?? I would! I would be thinking these blokes reckon they can knock us off with their B Side, which...

What he said!

What is to gain in resting players now when we have a bye in 3 weeks? If they are sore or have niggles sure, give them a rest, but not just for the sake of resting people. Me personally, I would get the wins on the board first, if we have secured a top 4 spot then you can start giving some guys...

I've seen top sides lose to bottom sides plenty of times before and I think its a terrible attitude to have towards any opposition you are playing against. Im just glad you are not part opf the coaching panel mate! Its digusting and we should show some grace while things are going well, because...

Worst thread title on big footy. Totally disrespectful. You sound like a bloody Collingwood supporter.

See I have a problem with this. I think it is far too early in the season to gain anything out of resting players. After our bye we have 11 or 12 more games to play in a row leading into the finals. Why rest someone now, when they are going to get a rest anyway in 2 weeks time?? I can only see...

I don't think his best is behind him at all. Keeps this vein of form going all year and it will be as good as any year he has played IMO. As Chewy said, all things being fair he should have 10 brownlow votes at round 7.

Terrible post. Thread was started by and Adelaide supporter. Just as much jizz being thrown around by Hawks fans, Cats fans and neutrals alike.

I remember that bloody dog act as well Lord Mud. It was absolutely disgraceful. It was such a shame too because I too remember Lance being in great form that year, he was my favourite of all the yloung blokes coming through at the time. Was never the same player after that.

No worries mate. We all want the same thing don't we. Up the HAWKS!

Haha! Pretty good reply. Not much you can say to that! While I respectfully disagree on some of your obsevations on Buddy regarding his selfishness, I do agree with what you say about his maturity and discipline at times. I think he can get a bit hot headed at times and definitely gives away...

I havent thrown anything at you, except maybe when you suggested Hodgey was a raging alcoholic. I just think sometimes you claim things to be fact or very close to when in fact there could be a plethora of other possibilities around certain subjects. I respect that you think Buddy will leave as...

Really looking forward to what you have to say when Buddy signs up again in the lead up to the finals......should be interesting ;)