Severe concussion. Sick after last weeks game from knocks in first and second quarter. Not tested until AFTER game when symptoms showed. Sick all week. Still did not pass a concussion test today.
Give it a rest. What sort of supporter are you? He played his role very well. Like to see your AFL football stats over your obviously prestigious career...
I don't blame the young ones - too many senior players had a down day and our disposal was poor by everyone. Lots of turnovers. However, I haven't given up on the Cats yet
How can you compare them - Polec went pick 5 in 2010 and Murdoch was pick 48 in 2011. He's had one less year in the system and has had the same amount of time at Geelong as McCarthy, Kersten, Bews and Hamling. If you compare him against those guys, he's tracking very well. Give the kid a break!
Murdoch, McCarthy and Mackie
Followed by Murdoch and McCarthy at Glenelg SA and have met them- great down to earth, humble guys who are country boys at heart! Both play for the "team" - never for themselves. Nice guys so I will defend them if I have to.
Mackie, because he also is a SA boy
Also a...
Some people are never happy. Murdoch plays well - you whinge, He's quiet - you whinge. None of his efforts have been "pathetic failures" - He's a young kid in his 2nd season (same as Kerston, Hamling, McCarthy, Eardley and Bews - all of which haven't been tried (and criticised) as yet. He is...
Jordan actually drafted a full year after Guthrie, Caddy and Smedts so has only been in the system for 18 months. He was drafted in 2011 with Kersten, Hamling (no AFL) as yet, and before Lincoln McCarthy (1 game). He will continue to improve, I'm sure
A win is a win. Rather than criticising every player, focus on the positives. Murdoch was better, Thurlow is playing well for a first year player and Selwood came through when needed. JPod showed he still has plenty to offer. Senior player came through in the end. We won. Please don't tear apart...
Excuse me for butting in on your board but I'm pretty sure he got a 14.2 beep test at the National combine in 32 degree heat (top ten) and backed it up with a 10.24 2km (top 15) so his fitness is pretty good, I think mainly his stats were affected due to playing in an unfamiliar role. I think...
Just want to add my opinion on the SA kids.. Watched these kids all year- not just highlights (and it makes a difference) but in order of which kid we need (and what roles we need filling) these are my picks for the 16 spot. 1st Troy Menzel; very very smart footballer, uses body very well for...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.