Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. CarnMags

    Unofficial Preview Changes V GWS Rd 2, '18 - Scharenberg and Callum Brown in, Cox and Smith out

    Exactly right. We're in a political game now, where Ed won't admit failure to his succession plan and implicate himself in bringing the Club to it's knees. It's crazy to think he's standing there watching this, and not thinking the same as we are. It's sad because I almost want to go 0-6, so...
  2. CarnMags

    Unofficial Preview Changes V GWS Rd 2, '18 - Scharenberg and Callum Brown in, Cox and Smith out

    I can't remain level headed anymore. I've supported Bucks through thick and thin, but I'm done. We have no clear game plan or structure I can't remember the last time I saw us kick to a lead in F50 Our forward line run into each others space and clog up our F50 Our skills are simply deplorable...
  3. CarnMags

    2017 Member Forum

    That was just misreported. Buddy was always going to Sydney from a long way out - they just kept it under the radar beautifully.
  4. CarnMags

    Player Watch Nathan Murphy (Retired 2024)

    I actually think in hindsight this draft year will be very highly rated. Potentially the evenness of the draft can be blinding - but I think there's a lot of stars in the making here.
  5. CarnMags

    Player Watch Nathan Murphy (Retired 2024)

    Great pick up - we are very very lucky with this one. He's going to be an out and out gun - and far from a project player. Anyone who disagrees with this selection needs a loooong looooooooong look at themselves in the mirror.
  6. CarnMags

    2018 - Best 22

    I'm not going to argue the point with you. We simply have a different view on this. My view In modern day football, many top end draft picks come in and play straight away - that's my point. I then supplied 10 players in a 2 year period that validates that. Your view First year players...
  7. CarnMags

    2018 - Best 22

    Not in this day and age - especially not the top end kids... 2015 Draft Player / 1st season games Weitering / 20 Schache / 17 Mills / 22 Oliver / 13 (due to injury) Parish / 20 2016 Draft Player / 1st season games McGrath / 21 Tarranto / 14 (due to injury) McCluggage / 18 Powell-Pepper / 22...
  8. CarnMags

    2018 - Best 22

    Top 6 draft picks are commonly best 22 players at AFL level. I see Stephenson definitely in our best 22
  9. CarnMags

    2018 - Best 22

    B: Langdon Dunn Shaz HB: Howe Moore Crisp C: Maynard Adams WHE HF: Sidebottom Reid DeGoey F: Fasolo...
  10. CarnMags

    Oppo Camp Jaidyn Stephenson (Traded to Nth Melb. 2020)

    Hine already said he's ready to play straight away - and I agree. Lachlan Whitfield played 19 games in his first year, McCluggage 18 - both similar build.
  11. CarnMags

    Oppo Camp Jaidyn Stephenson (Traded to Nth Melb. 2020)

    With the utmost respect, I don't have time to go back and match quotes to prove my point. My point remains - Darcy Fogarty battled with a minor injury throughout the year, missed games and struggled with form. That would worry me as a recruiter - with the rigours of AFL you need to manage that.
  12. CarnMags

    Oppo Camp Jaidyn Stephenson (Traded to Nth Melb. 2020)

    It’s ironic how people are up in arms about us selecting Stephenson – citing risk associated with his heart condition – which is relatively unknown. Funnily enough, the same people wanted us to select Darcy Fogarty. Quick reality check… Stephenson played 20 games this year across TAC Cup (15...
  13. CarnMags

    Oppo Camp Jaidyn Stephenson (Traded to Nth Melb. 2020)

    Will play in R1 - 100%
  14. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    I haven't gone back and read all the commentary on the selection of Stephenson, but I'm absolutely stoked. This kid is a genuine star.
  15. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    Update from a mate of mine who's a journo in the know. (he asked me not to reveal his publication online) Stephenson is our man unless Cerra available. Pies looking past Fogarty now.
  16. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    Yeah really good call.
  17. CarnMags

    2017 Draft rumours

    I see it playing out like this: Rayner LDU / Cerra Dow LDU / Cerra / Fogarty Cerra/ Brayshaw Brayshaw / Stephenson / Fogarty Few key summary points: Freo tossing up who to take at 2 - with the thought Cerra may be there at 5, while LDU won"t be. North will definitely take LDU if he's...
  18. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    It's an exciting first 6... With Freo and NM's selections to shape it. I get the feeling Fogarty and Stephenson will be the two we need to flip the coin on (assuming it goes Rayner, LDU, Dow, Cerra, Brayshaw in no particular order) If NM take Fogarty at 4, we may have Brayshaw and Stephenson...
  19. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    Late mail - Kangas seriously considering taking Fogarty at 4
  20. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    Have we got the 'Welcome to Collingwood Darcy Fogarty' thread ready to go? My predicted top 6 1. Rayner 2. LDU (Cerra) 3. Dow 4. Brayshaw 5. Cerra (LDU) 6. Fogarty Freo want Cerra and LDU - and I think they will get both. Whoever they select at 2, I think the other one will be there at 5...
  21. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    No neither have I, but I was just listing it as an option - as it is an option, ha!
  22. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    I'm hearing Brander is touted as the clear best talent in the pool - but just had a stinker of a year with injury and form issues. Naughton is definitely the best KPP on form - not sure about natural talent though.
  23. CarnMags

    Prediction Pick 6

    It's going to be an intriguing draft night... I don't think Freo will take Naughton - they'll take LDU at 2 (if Lions take Rayner), and may jump at Brayshaw if he's there at 5. That means our options are: 1. Take Fogarty (if he slips past NM) or Naughton at 6 to help with our KPP stocks. 2...
  24. CarnMags

    Game Day 2017 National Draft

    I'd be happy with any of these players at 6: Cerra/Coffield/Balta/Stephenson (assuming LDU, Dow, Rayner are all gone) Clavarino at 38 would be nice too. Then grab Brown as FS
  25. CarnMags

    Pies handed a 'dream' draw

    Looking at our first 10 games, I think we could likely be 3-7 and under pressure from the get go.
  26. CarnMags

    Anthony Rocca or Travis Cloke?

    Cloke by a miiiiile.
  27. CarnMags

    One word that describes Buckley.. One word that describes Mcguire

    Buckley: Stoic Mcguire: Passionate
  28. CarnMags

    All things horse racing

    I'm liking the way Johannes Vermeer got to the line in his last two runs. With a long open straight at Flemington, I expect him to be very prominent in the closing stages.
  29. CarnMags

    News Cloke announces his retirement

    Agree to disagree His legacy is as a premiership player that played 246 games and kicked 441 goals for the black and white verticals! On top of that, he was a genuinely lovely guy that gave everything he had to us.
  30. CarnMags

    Game Day 2017 National Draft

    I actually think Stephenson is going to end up as good as any of the those 4. He has huge upside, Bontempelli like.
Back
Top