- Nov 5, 2010
- 9,014
- 4,485
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Banned
- #151
I reckon a lot of the players on your list aren't rated at all such as Bruce, Kosi and Davey who you are right about he is as soft as. I think you are wrong about Goddard and Thomas they are both Guns IMO. As for Didak not my favourite player but he was hampered by an interupted pre-season last year and better players than Didak have struggled with inadequete preparation. Wells had a good season last year and if he can back up again this year he'll be starting to earn the wraps he had put on him earlier in his career.
Good post apart from Goddard IMO, not saying he isn't a gun but most were speaking of him as the second coming after the 2010 season, Sheahan had him at 2 post season iirc lol, that's severly overrated, the bloke's a HB and has never shown form in any postion except HB on a consistant basis, some 'experts' were saying he could be the best player in any postion he chose, 70 goals from a fwd pkt etc etc lol, IMO he's the most over-rated player in the history of the game, that isn't his fault though, as i said, he's a gun, probably the best HB in the comp, but gee, he would struggle to make my top 30.
Didak's hated lke Milne, mostly only Collingwood people rate dids, at his best there isn't many better as a Fwd-Mid combo player, he isn't the most physical player going around but anyone who can average 25 disposals with his kicking skills and kick 40 goals has to be rated very highly.