Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
1. Natanui
2. Dangerfield
3. Gibbs
4. Ryder
5. Rioli
6. Scully
7. O'Brien
8. Zaharakis
9. Maxwell
10. Dawes
I don't know why everyone is claiming Gibbs as overrated. I rarely see anyone rating him as anything other than a soft mistake of a No.1 pick, despite him being a top 3 player at his club and doing some unheralded but downright terrific jobs on the game's stars. Perhaps next year's anticipated shift to the forward/mid will make his contributions more obvious to the casual observer.
Natanui,the laughs still keep rolling in.Natanui is the best player i've ever seen and will,barring injury,retire in the best few players of all time.This thread is becoming laughable and although people are entitled to their opinion,Too see players like Judd,Betts,Natanui,Martin,on the overated list,almost makes one wonder if some actualy are entitled to an opinion with such laughable views,i mean,someone could say,it's my opinion that Gary Ablett is overated,would we even listen to a so called opinion like that.Natanui overated,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL.I Still can't get over the idiot/fool/something that said a certain "dual brownlow medalist" is overated.Wish my beloved tigers had overated players like Judd,Betts,Natanui.We would win a flag overnight.1. Natanui
2. Dangerfield
3. Gibbs
4. Ryder
5. Rioli
6. Scully
7. O'Brien
8. Zaharakis
9. Maxwell
10. Dawes
Natanui,the laughs still keep rolling in.Natanui is the best player i've ever seen and will,barring injury,retire in the best few players of all time.This thread is becoming laughable and although people are entitled to their opinion,Too see players like Judd,Betts,Natanui,Martin,on the overated list,almost makes one wonder if some actualy are entitled to an opinion with such laughable views,i mean,someone could say,it's my opinion that Gary Ablett is overated,would we even listen to a so called opinion like that.Natanui overated,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL.I Still can't get over the idiot/fool/something that said a certain "dual brownlow medalist" is overated.Wish my beloved tigers had overated players like Judd,Betts,Natanui.We would win a flag overnight.
Yes,grammar is very underatedCould you please show grammar a little respect?
The best player to ever play the game can still be overated, and there is no guarantee Nic Nat will be in the best few of all time, even the top 50...Natanui,the laughs still keep rolling in.Natanui is the best player i've ever seen and will,barring injury,retire in the best few players of all time.This thread is becoming laughable and although people are entitled to their opinion,Too see players like Judd,Betts,Natanui,Martin,on the overated list,almost makes one wonder if some actualy are entitled to an opinion with such laughable views,i mean,someone could say,it's my opinion that Gary Ablett is overated,would we even listen to a so called opinion like that.Natanui overated,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL.I Still can't get over the idiot/fool/something that said a certain "dual brownlow medalist" is overated.Wish my beloved tigers had overated players like Judd,Betts,Natanui.We would win a flag overnight.
1. Natanui
2. Dangerfield
3. Gibbs
4. Ryder
5. Rioli
6. Scully
7. O'Brien
8. Zaharakis
9. Maxwell
10. Dawes
Ziebell would go pretty close to making the top10, in fact switch Gibbs out for Ziebell and that list is pretty good.
Natanui,the laughs still keep rolling in.Natanui is the best player i've ever seen and will,barring injury,retire in the best few players of all time.This thread is becoming laughable and although people are entitled to their opinion,Too see players like Judd,Betts,Natanui,Martin,on the overated list,almost makes one wonder if some actualy are entitled to an opinion with such laughable views,i mean,someone could say,it's my opinion that Gary Ablett is overated,would we even listen to a so called opinion like that.Natanui overated,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL,LOL.I Still can't get over the idiot/fool/something that said a certain "dual brownlow medalist" is overated.Wish my beloved tigers had overated players like Judd,Betts,Natanui.We would win a flag overnight.
He's a good player, but i think people are entitled to raise a few eye brows when a no1 DP is playing as a HBF or a Tagger after 4 or 5 years in the system, you don't use your no1 DP on a player to fill those positions.
No,i don't watch just the eagles play.My view is not biased,obviously,but people need to remember that players his size rarely mature before early to mid 20s and before Natanui was drafted,it was clearly stated that he was raw to footy and was going to take more time than most to learn the trade.Never mind about his average stats,12 touches a game from a player that freakish is enough for now.Just waite till he fully grasps the game,he will be near unstoppable.He has the speed and agility of a mid and a leap like no other and despite my not so great liking of the eagles,this guy will be a phenom.And you are questioning why Nic Nat is overated??? If he is the best player you have ever seen then you must only watch Eagles play - and when they do play only watch 1 player.
Averages 4.2 kicks, 1.7 Marks, 7.7 handballs, 0.5 goals and 17.7 hit outs. He has a long long way to go to being anywhere near the best in the comp let alone ever. Sure he can do some freaky things but so could Alan Jackovich. He could just end up another side show.
No,i don't watch just the eagles play.My view is not biased,obviously,but people need to remember that players his size rarely mature before early to mid 20s and before Natanui was drafted,it was clearly stated that he was raw to footy and was going to take more time than most to learn the trade.Never mind about his average stats,12 touches a game from a player that freakish is enough for now.Just waite till he fully grasps the game,he will be near unstoppable.He has the speed and agility of a mid and a leap like no other and despite my not so great liking of the eagles,this guy will be a phenom.
1. Natanui
2. Dangerfield
3. Gibbs
4. Ryder
5. Rioli
6. Scully
7. O'Brien
8. Zaharakis
9. Maxwell
10. Dawes
Great list IMOMy Top 10
1.Waite - Whilst injured has gone from moderate 3rd tall forward/defender to becoming a star forward that could have led Carlton to a flag.
2.Dangerfield - Gets talked up every year as the next "big thing". Has had a great run with injury yet still can't break into Adelaides average midfield on a regular basis. Will this be his break out year ????
3.Watts - Got plenty of accolades for his improvement last year yet was playing a soft role accross half back instead of getting valuable KP development time in a Melbourne side that didn't have many KP forwards.
4.Dawes - For all the accolades he was recieving, paticularly early last year he has only managed more than 3 goals twice in the last 2 years when Collingwood have been the dominant team in competition.
5.Zeibell - Gets talked up a lot by North supporters as a superstar. He will be a good player but when i watch him i just see him reaching those heights
6.Ward - Similar to Zeibell above but on more coin
7.Boyd - Good for DT but Stats amount to little on the field
8.Maxwell - Not a paticularly talented loose man in defence
9. Hodge - As good as he is has spent far to much time floating accross half back considering all his accolades
10. Clarke - Had a very poor 2011 who's only real highlight was mimicking the Tarrant strut.
5.Zeibell - Gets talked up a lot by North supporters as a superstar. He will be a good player but when i watch him i just see him reaching those heights
My Top 10
1.Waite - Whilst injured has gone from moderate 3rd tall forward/defender to becoming a star forward that could have led Carlton to a flag.
2.Dangerfield - Gets talked up every year as the next "big thing". Just hasn't shown that he can get enough of the pill so still can't break into Adelaides average midfield on a regular basis. Will this be his break out year ????
3.Watts - Got plenty of accolades for his improvement last year yet was playing a soft role accross half back instead of getting valuable KP development time in a Melbourne side that didn't have many KP forwards.
4.Dawes - For all the accolades he was recieving, paticularly early last year he has only managed more than 3 goals twice in the last 2 years when Collingwood have been the dominant team in competition.
5.Zeibell - Gets talked up a lot by North supporters as a superstar. He will be a good player but when i watch him i just see him reaching those heights
6.Ward - Similar to Zeibell above but on more coin
7.Boyd - Good for DT but stats amount to little on the field
8.Maxwell - Not a paticularly talented loose man in defence
9. Hodge - As good as he is has spent far to much time floating accross half back considering all his accolades
10. Clarke - Had a very poor 2011 who's only real highlight was mimicking the Tarrant strut.
What a crock about Hodge hasn't played half back since 2009 was AA Captain and centre in 2010. Maybe watch more footy or congrats for waking up from your coma, 2 years is along time to be asleep!
10. Leon Davis (plays alright in H&A season but constantly goes missing in finals, his performance in the 2011 GF was better though)
9. Kirk Tippett - Gets alot of press but is no where near a danger target as he is too easy to shut down
8. Angus Monfries - too flashy and not enough substance, likes to play for free kicks too
7. Tom Scully - highest paid player in the AFL.... ahead of Judd, Swan, Ablett....
6. Justin Koschitzke - Doesn't get involved consistantly in games and his presence is often overstated
5. Lindsay Thomas - too inconsistant, has a big bag against a bottom 8 side and goes missing when it counts
4. Aaron Davey - Love the flash but cannot handle a tag, his mental toughness also took a massive battering and as a result needs to rediscover form
3. Tom Hawkins - Loved his finals performances but during the season was all over the place, Cats fans who hated him and now love him and claim was great all along...
2. Robert Murphy - Decent player but AA selection? Nah don't think so
1. Chris Judd - Ok this one is tough because I still think he is in the top 5 players atm but it kills me watching a Carlton games because the hype on Judd is bordering on psychotic asphyxiation. I still think his West Coast days were more consistant but theres no denying that he can produce the goods when it counts
What a crock about Hodge hasn't played half back since 2009 was AA Captain and centre in 2010. Maybe watch more footy or congrats for waking up from your coma, 2 years is along time to be asleep!
My rating of Hodge was over his career
I'm sorry but to me he has never been an elite midfielder, even in his AA season in 2010.
Not saying he is not a great player because he clearly is but that dosen't mean he can't be overated
Fair pointMy rating of Hodge was over his career
I'm sorry but to me he has never been an elite midfielder, even in his AA season in 2010.
Not saying he is not a great player because he clearly is but that dosen't mean he can't be overated