Opinion 2010 Top 50

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

omit said:
I'm curious to know if you think Barlow will still be in the top 50 come seasons end?
Click to expand...
Not sure, 6 missed games is the cutoff so he'll start dropping by a fair bit after R20. He'll probably stay in at this stage because I'm not happy with the bottom 8 on the list and the only way he will go out is if I'm positive others have been better than him.


EDIT: I'll keep him, seems stupid that someone who was in the top 10 for 13 rounds doesn't make the top 50.
 
top50r19.png


Fixed the middle part of the list up because I had just put all the forwards next to each other, same with the defenders. Realistically midfielders should be in between some of them. Little things like Cross being ahead of Hall makes more sense, same with Mundy ahead of Pavlich. Swan takes no.1 spot for the first time but they are pretty much level imo. Goddard is outright 3rd now as well. From the changes SJ the only one I'm not sure about so maybe he should be 50th instead of Rischitelli.

totwr19.png


Finally watched a fair bit of football. Watched everything apart from WCE v BRI, NTH v FRE and the second half of STK v PTA.
 
Nice update AG. I think it's the right call putting Swan ahead of Hodge atm.

Personally I think Chapman is a little bit too high. From my perspective Chapman, Ablett and Selwood are pretty hard to separate as the Cats best player this year.

I probably don't think Chappy kicks enough goals or gets enough contested footy and clearances to be number 4 though.

But great work as usual.:thumbsu:
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Not sure what Jobe did to go down. He was probably our best player.
 
Now guys like Deledio seem way too low. I've got the AA team in the back of my mind when I do this so that's why it's hard to separate Deledio/Enright/Gilbert/Frawley/Malceski and Hall/Pav/Goodes. Plus the gaps between players like Riewoldt and Hall for example.
 
Nice one AG, can't fault it myself.. Swan in his rightful #1 position and Didak rising each week..
 
Yeh i think Swan is the rightful number 1 too.

I'm happy to see K.Jack come into the 50 as well, he has a remarkable season and may well be the next captain of the Swans.

Rischitelli is also a deserved inclusion.
 
AUSSIE GUN said:
Now guys like Deledio seem way too low. I've got the AA team in the back of my mind when I do this so that's why it's hard to separate Deledio/Enright/Gilbert/Frawley/Malceski and Hall/Pav/Goodes. Plus the gaps between players like Riewoldt and Hall for example.
Click to expand...
You picking a squad first or just going straight at the AA 22?
 
Not at all imo. I think Mumford and Hudson are clearly ahead on impact in games. Stats don't really tell the story with them.

Coaches votes give a good indication in this regard. I don't like using stats or votes to much but in this case:

Sandilands 68 votes (polled in 12 games)
Jamar 29 votes (8 games)
Mumford 29 votes (7 games)
Hudson 23 votes (8 games)
Ryder 4 votes (1 game)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion 2010 Top 50

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top