MVP 2011 POTY Round 4 vs Geelong

[Dangas]

Vote away peeps...YPOTY: Sam Reid, Craig Bird, Alex Johnson, Gary Rohan, Lewis Jetta, Dan Hannebery, Andrejs Everitt

 

[AG]

5. Kieren Jack
4. Josh Kennedy
3. Ted Richards
2. Shane Mumford
1. Rhyce Shaw

YPOTY: Daniel Hannebery

 

[Dangas]

5. Richards (Thought he was great, gives his all every match)
4. Kennedy (Tough in hard)
3. Jack (Continues to burrow through)
2. Mumford (Ottens played well, so did Mummy)
1. McGlynn (Thought his attack on the footy was good, shame he didn't kick a couple)

YPOTY:Hanners

 

[Mick Oxlong]

5. Kennedy
4. Jack
3. Mummy
2. Smith
1. Goodes

YPOTY: Hanners

 

[BarneyBent]

I might make some changes after watching a replay, but:

5. Kennedy
4. Jack
3. Mumford
2. Richards
1. Goodes

YPOTY: Craig Bird. Great job on Kelly.

 

[Dangas]

I might make some changes after watching a reply, but:

5. Kennedy
4. Jack
3. Mumford
2. Richards
1. Goodes

YPOTY: Craig Bird. Great job on Kelly.

I tend to agree, I'll watch Shaw closely, I am probably being a tad critical

 

[grimlock]

5. Mumford - Horse is really flogging him to death, needs some relief!
4. Kennedy - brilliant in close, kicking not so flash at times
3. Richards - doing his best, would be good if he could get some more help at times.
2. Jack -
1. Goodes - Not really sure on this one, he did go missing for long periods

YPOTY: Bird

 

[CAS79]

5: Kennedy
4: Jack
3: Mumford
2: Richards
1: McGlynn

YPOTY:

C.Bird
No youngster really coverd themselvesd with glory but Bird at least broke even with a class opponent in conditions for mature bodies.

 

[Aardvark]

5. Kennedy
4. Richards
3. Jack
2. Mummy
1. McGlynn

YPOTY Bird

 

[AlibiMonday]

5. Richards
4. McGlynn
3. Mumford
2. Kennedy
1. Shaw

YPOTY: Bird

 

[Swans120]

5. Josh Kennedy
4. Shane Mumford
3. Kieren Jack
2. Ted Richards
1. Rhyce Shaw

YPOTY: Craig Bird

 

[dobbins]

5. Mumford S

4. Richards T

3. Kennedy J

2. Jack K

1. McGlynn B

YPOTY : Bird C

 

[MVP_PaulRoos]

5. McGlynn - We were competitive while the ball was going through his hands. Should have ended up with a couple of goals, but Sam Reid's poor disposal cost him one, and a few non-cals cost him some others. But he beat his opponent all ends up for mine.

4. Jack - Flourished in the conditions. Tough as nails and like McGlynn, we were competitive when Jack was up an about. The kid is going to be a star.

3. Mumford - We need a second ruckman to take some of the pressure off Mumford. Besides, it takes away his athletic advantage if two ruckman are rotating against him (not really what happened this game, just a general note). Once again, battled superbly.

2. Kennedy - Probably deserves to be higher. Does the hard, tough work every week and makes everyone around him look and play better. My God, we really bent Hawthorn over at the trade table picking up him and McGlynn.

1. Richards - Again, probably deserves to be higher. Has really stood out in defence. Only gets beaten when a perfect entry kick comes in, and even then he doesn't get beaten all them time. Deserves more credit than he gets.

YPOTY. Bird - I wasn't overly impressed with any of the young guys. Having said that, I would give Bird maybe a B to a B+ for his work as a shut-down player, so I'll give my vote to him. I'd give Hanners a C+, Reid a C- and I'd reserve judgement on Johnson. I'd give everybody else an F.


Honourable mention
Nick Smith - You might not have noticed him, but you would have noticed if he wasn't there, believe me. Stevie J was not the cause of our demise in this game.

 

[Dangas]

5. McGlynn - We were competitive while the ball was going through his hands. Should have ended up with a couple of goals, but Sam Reid's poor disposal cost him one, and a few non-cals cost him some others. But he beat his opponent all ends up for mine.

4. Jack - Flourished in the conditions. Tough as nails and like McGlynn, we were competitive when Jack was up an about. The kid is going to be a star.

3. Mumford - We need a second ruckman to take some of the pressure off Mumford. Besides, it takes away his athletic advantage if two ruckman are rotating against him (not really what happened this game, just a general note). Once again, battled superbly.

2. Kennedy - Probably deserves to be higher. Does the hard, tough work every week and makes everyone around him look and play better. My God, we really bent Hawthorn over at the trade table picking up him and McGlynn.

1. Richards - Again, probably deserves to be higher. Has really stood out in defence. Only gets beaten when a perfect entry kick comes in, and even then he doesn't get beaten all them time. Deserves more credit than he gets.


Honourable mention
Nick Smith - You might not have noticed him, but you would have noticed if he wasn't there, believe me. Stevie J was not the cause of our demise in this game.

don't forget ypoty!

 

[SM]

5. McGlynn
4. Jack
3. Mumford
2. Smith
1. Kennedy

YPOTY: Bird

 

[RW]

5. Mumford
4. Jack
3. Shaw
2. Richards
1. Smith

YPOTY: Hannebery

 

[Jack2Johnston]

5. Richards - If a few more of our defenders were as good as he was last night would be an entirely different result. seemingly the only Swans player able to mark a wet ball.
4. Jack
3. Shaw
2. Kennedy
1. Mumford

YPOTY: Bird

 

[set shots]

5.Jack
4.Kennedy
3.Mumford
2.Mcglynn
1.Richards

YPOTY - Bird

 

[bedford]

5 Jack
4 Kennedy
3 Mumford
2 Smith
1 Goodes

 

[bungee]

1. Shaw
2. Richards
3. Jack
4. McGlynn
5. McVeigh

YPOTY : Hannerbery

 

[MF]

5. Richards - Repelled at least 3 or 4 inside 50's that seemed to be certain goals and did all the basics well. Easily our best defender this season.

4. Jack - Great defensively in the first half and offensively in the 2nd.

3. Kennedy - Imposed himself on the game when it was there to be won. Unfortunately our senior players couldn't do the same.

2. McGlynn - Was great early and should have been rewarded with a couple of goals.

1. Mumford - A good battle with Ottens and a couple of goals.

YPOTY - Bird - Doing the shutdown roles well at the moment and continuing his apprenticeship in the middle.

 

[bigswan]

5-Kennedy
4-Jack
3-Richards
2-Mumford
1-McGlynn

 

[AG]

Not sure why, but I felt like doing it this week.