Position 2013 SC Defenders

[Doss]

I'm not sure if Doss takes bribes. Plus I wouldn't give him the satisfaction that it bothers me or other Pie fans.

It's only one week, one VERY LONG week.

No taking of bribes here, mate. Plus, red and black suits you.

Don't worry, when you guys inevitably get one back on us soon, I'll be the one proudly* sporting a Pies logo.

*read: with disgust and discomfort

 

[HirdyLannister]

Harry Taylor is starting to get my attentions and might be worth considering as a future premium for the backline

 

[Patty Healey]

Glad I grabbed Hartlett this week, Suban was killing me! Finally Suban does OK this week as well haha.

 

[Zach Package]

thoughts on trent mckenzie?

starts with a lazy 108 in his first game back.

giving it another week to assess but potentially a virtual straight swap (give or take 70k ish for someone like lewis stevenson next week before his bubble bursts.

 

[Patty Healey]

thoughts on trent mckenzie?

starts with a lazy 108 in his first game back.

giving it another week to assess but potentially a virtual straight swap (give or take 70k ish for someone like lewis stevenson next week before his bubble bursts.

I wouldn't risk picking MacKenzie can have some shocking games.

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Opinion guys.
Who will be the top 8 defenders come season's end?
Need some opinions so I can think of who to bring in cheers!

 

[Daniels]

Opinion guys.
Who will be the top 8 defenders come season's end?
Need some opinions so I can think of who to bring in cheers!

Not in order

Gibbs, Goddard, Hartlett, H. Shaw, Birchall, Hanley, Taylor, Heppell

 

[Deliverance]

Opinion guys.
Who will be the top 8 defenders come season's end?
Need some opinions so I can think of who to bring in cheers!

Total points from now until the end of the year, in no particular order:
Birchall, Goddard, Heppell, Shaw, Hanley, Hartlett, Dixon, Waters/Hibberd

 

[Daniels]

Saying that, would be great to have that DEF line up by Round 18 or so

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Thanks Delierance and Daniels, great input there.
Will get the common players both of you have mentioned

 

[toxic]

Opinion guys.
Who will be the top 8 defenders come season's end?
Need some opinions so I can think of who to bring in cheers!

Waters, Goddard, Scotland, Gibbs, Hartlett, H Shaw, Heppell, Birchall & Adcock (yes the forgotten one for a roughie as my 9th)

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

So Heath Shaw's name appears 3 times and for such a cheap price, I should definitely be considering him.
Question is, is now the right time to bring him in? With Toovey out, who knows what role he will now play.

 

[toxic]

So Heath Shaw's name appears 3 times and for such a cheap price, I should definitely be considering him.
Question is, is now the right time to bring him in? With Toovey out, who knows what role he will now play.

Heath is the true roller coaster - 120 one week 75 the next, 130 the next, 70 the next - however as an average you'd expect it will only go up from here

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Assuming I trade Pittard out (most likely will), I will have $545k in the bank for one of these below:

Charlie Dixon ($477k)
Hamish Hartlett ($538k)
Harry Taylor ($490k)
Heath Scotland ($510k)

So Shaw the best deal?

 

[Daniels]

Assuming I trade Pittard out (most likely will), I will have $545k in the bank for one of these below:

Charlie Dixon ($477k)
Hamish Hartlett ($538k)
Harry Taylor ($490k)
Heath Scotland ($510k)

So Shaw the best deal?

Yes

 

[Werewolf]

What do people think of Brandon Ellis as a cheap POD defender? He was subbed on/off in the first 4 rounds, finally played a full game last week and got 134. Has dropped in price from $300k and looks tempting at $238k...

 

[Stealthchicken]

What do people think of Brandon Ellis as a cheap POD defender? He was subbed on/off in the first 4 rounds, finally played a full game last week and got 134. Has dropped in price from $300k and looks tempting at $238k...

Yeah good cash cow or first bench/occasional get me out shit type player. Float around the 70pts.
I ganna try it on Sultana O'hAilpin as a POD.

 

[Fiasco]

Don't get Setanta this week I'm pretty sure he's not playing!

 

[toxic]

What do people think of Brandon Ellis as a cheap POD defender? He was subbed on/off in the first 4 rounds, finally played a full game last week and got 134. Has dropped in price from $300k and looks tempting at $238k...

i think its a matter of gauging job security now when downgrading to rookies or players like Ellis - if you like his job security then with his b/e this is the best week to get him

 

[Krujan]

Yeah good cash cow or first bench/occasional get me out shit type player. Float around the 70pts.
I ganna try it on Sultana O'hAilpin as a POD.

"Forward Setanta O'hAilpin will also miss Saturday's match against Essendon with a calf injury."

 

[Stealthchicken]

Don't get Setanta this week I'm pretty sure he's not playing!

oh really any reason why?
Just have to wait till tonight spose.

 

[Stealthchicken]

"Forward Setanta O'hAilpin will also miss Saturday's match against Essendon with a calf injury."

I Give Up

 

[tracygrimshaw]

I Give Up

get Winderlich, about the same price and actually has a history of scoring well!

 

[Stealthchicken]

Copy that!

 

[Deliverance]

This should be the "Let's predict who's going to be out this week" thread