2014 Brownlow Medal

Remove this Banner Ad

What if he comes top 3?
I'll be very surprised if he is top 5

some of the ardent dislike that seems to be there for gray is just odd. its not like he's a sniper, or a diver, or bailed on his old club etc. boak's season also wasn't as dominant as past years - he had around 4 clear great games, then a few reasonable ones.
Don't get me wrong, I love and admire Gray very much as a player and have rated him for some time. I just don't think he will poll so well that he is within a chance of the medal

lol. Are you basing Boak getting more votes off of stats?
I never allocate votes from stats. Between a couple friends and I, we watch every game and allocate votes.

I have a lot of 2's for Gray, not many BOGs. Boak won't do exceptionally well either - good even share amongst the Port boys in my tally.
 
We get your point, you don't think SJ will poll more than 1 in round 4. I'm not sure how you can be so sure though, umpires sometime vote for who they see getting the ball a lot regardless of disposal. Let me guess, you had Swan on 20 votes in 2011 because he butchered it more than Judd and Pendles?
coz I have been watching every game and replays for 5 years mate....not looking at stats until I have decided who I like....rnd 4 until I looked at the stats I had no dea stevie-j had 37 disposals...didn't look like that many,and i'm sure at least one umpire woulda seen the steviej blooper roll they put up in the 3rd quarter..seriously,as a cats fan,that was the most INEFFECTIVE game I have ever seen stevie j play..lol......
 

Log in to remove this ad.

coz I have been watching every game and replays for 5 years mate....not looking at stats until I have decided who I like....rnd 4 until I looked at the stats I had no dea stevie-j had 37 disposals...didn't look like that many,and i'm sure at least one umpire woulda seen the steviej blooper roll they put up in the 3rd quarter..seriously,as a cats fan,that was the most INEFFECTIVE game I have ever seen stevie j play..lol......

Umpires don't watch replays but they do look at stats
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Does anyone rate Cotchin a chance for Leader After Round 4 w/o Selwood?

And on some counts he is as high as 7 votes, while Ablett is 6 and Johnson anywherer from 4-6. Seems well and truly over the odds doesnt he?
 
Does anyone rate Cotchin a chance for Leader After Round 4 w/o Selwood?

And on some counts he is as high as 7 votes, while Ablett is 6 and Johnson anywherer from 4-6. Seems well and truly over the odds doesnt he?
Cotchin is a chance for the R4-Selwood

R1: Should get the 2 behind Ablett. 2 Votes
R2: Played better than I thought here, still think Murphy was BOG. 2-1 Votes
R3: Either he or Macrae will get the 3. Bulldogs winning may edge Cotchin out. 3-2 Votes
R4: Won't poll

So between 5-7 should be his mark. Either way he's good odds (assuming he's still around the 8.00 he was when I got on)
 
Kangas most votes - Does anyone give DalSanto a chance? His odds look way overs to me.

Harvey seems to be the unanimous pick here and Sportsbet odds reflect that ($1.33). But, I have him less than a vote ahead of Dal Santo ($8) and Cunnington another 1.5 votes behind ($3.75).

Also, Harvey hasn't cracked double figure votes past 3 years. Has this year been any better?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

2014 Brownlow Medal

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top