List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

[SK_MD_#7]

Sam Frost + Pick 7 for Pick 3.

Pick 3 (McCartin) + 4 (Wright) for pick 1.

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Would prefer Pick 4 + 7.

Even if it was 4 + Tomlinson i'd prefer Wright/McCartin personally.

As long as we invested on a highly rated mid at 4 then I would prefer Tomlinson over 7. Looks like a being very solid citizen that comes with extremely low bust factor.

 

[saintbill]

Would you take 4 & Tomlinson? A player like Laverde @4 would compliment the trade in of Tomlinson quite nicely.

I would take this. I would like to see us get Tomlinson and Wright, and have a crack at mids later. Still might be able to snag a Duggan or similar to 21/22. I think we could groom Tomlinson as a potential Fisher replacement.

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Sam Frost + Pick 7 for Pick 3.

Pick 3 (McCartin) + 4 (Wright) for pick 1.

I like the way you are thinking however we would need to throw in something to the Dees

StK
In: 3 & 4
Out: 1 & 22

Dees
In: 7, 22 & Frost
Out: 3

GWS
In: 1
Out: 4, 7 & Frost

 

[TheLastEmperor]

I would take this. I would like to see us get Tomlinson and Wright, and have a crack at mids later. Still might be able to snag a Duggan or similar to 21/22. I think we could groom Tomlinson as a potential Fisher replacement.

I wouldn't invest in a soft 202cm ruck/forward at pick 4. We just go rid of one of them. Other than that agree with the rest of your post.

 

[Joffaboy]

Plough List Manages the Saints next

 

[dewah07]

Saints list management happening after the break

 

[SK_MD_#7]

You all better not go hating on Plough.

 

[dewah07]

You all better not go hating on Plough.

I remember last year when he expected roo to decline.....

 

[Half Back Pocket]

I like the way you are thinking however we would need to throw in something to the Dees

StK
In: 3 & 4 & 23
Out: 1 & 21

Dees
In: 7, 21 & Frost
Out: 3 & 23

GWS
In: 1
Out: 4, 7 & Frost

Thats better...heavily skewed

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Tambling over Buddy

 

[TheLastEmperor]

Thats better...heavily skewed

Melb would go close to taking that IMO. They slide from 3 to 7 but add pick 22 & Frost. Not bad all round IMO.

Edit: Just realised you edited my post!

 

[BrianSpeaking]

Don't think Brian means that we'll take him with #1 here. Pelchen did go on radio saying that other clubs are working on deals to get more picks to trade up for Pick 1, so I think we could see the Saints trade down and snare Paddy.

Correct, just reading the tea leaves, a like for like swap.

 

[Defacto]

Would prefer Pick 4 + 7.

Even if it was 4 + Tomlinson i'd prefer Wright/McCartin personally.

list spots are also an issue

 

[saintbill]

I wouldn't invest in a soft 202cm ruck/forward at pick 4. We just go rid of one of them. Other than that agree with the rest of your post.

Probably correct, we would only develop him to the point where he was on the cusp of being awesome and then move him on for a 2nd rounder.

#notoverityet

 

[SK_MD_#7]

list spots are also an issue

8 currently 9 when Schneids is likely moved on.

1. Pick 4
2. Pick 7
3. Pick 21
4. Pick 22
5. Pick 41
6. Eli
7. Minch
8. Shents
9. Tim Membrey

Easy.

 

[Rors]

Cameron & pick 4 for pick 1 & Milera

Seems legit....

 

[Hayes4PM]

Please swoop in on a Boyd deal Pelch & co....

 

[Persevering Saint]

8 currently 9 when Schneids is likely moved on.

1. Pick 4
2. Pick 7
3. Pick 21
4. Pick 22
5. Pick 41
6. Eli
7. Minch
8. Shents
9. Tim Membrey

Easy.

We've officially heard Mav has been given a two year contract. I presume that's not a 2 year ROOKIE contract, so he'll be upgraded as well.

Did you include Stanley as one of those gone already in that list of 8 to 9?

 

[SK_MD_#7]

We've officially heard Mav has been given a two year contract. I presume that's not a 2 year ROOKIE contract, so he'll be upgraded as well.

Did you include Stanley as one of those gone already in that list of 8 to 9?

Included Rhys and Milera along with Schneids.

Then we either elevate Mav instead of using pick 41 or make the tough call of moving one of Simpkin/Siposs on or to the rookie list.

 

[Defacto]

Included Rhys and Milera along with Schneids.

Then we either elevate Mav instead of using pick 41 or make the tough call of moving one of Simpkin/Siposs on or to the rookie list.

moving one of siposs/simpkin wont happen

 

[SK_MD_#7]

moving one of siposs/simpkin wont happen

Well then we don't use pick 41 and elevate Weller instead.

 

[Defacto]

Well then we don't use pick 41 and elevate Weller instead.

my original comment was in regards to tominlson, did you add him...see what i mean

 

[saintbill]

Acres is an "honest" type is he Terry. Shut the ferk up, I doubt you even know who he is.

 

[SK_MD_#7]

my original comment was in regards to tominlson, did you add him...see what i mean

We won't get pick 4, 7 and Tomlinson though pretty unlikely.