List Mgmt. 2014 Draft Trade FA Megathread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Plough saying nothing we don't already know.

Pretty spot on I would think.

At least he is giving them kudo's for the direction and plan

predicts wooden spoon - no shit Sherlock
Correct...pretty spot on.

(Acres is honest, Riewoldt at the end - even though he was AA this year)
 
Bump from yesterday for people complaining about our lack of forwards. Spencedog, Roo, Membrey will be what we're working with at this stage. Maybe McKenzie as well depending on how the draft goes.

EDIT: Also Tom Lee. We're not devoid of options.


still devoid of options and still much too much reliant on reiwoldt
 
If we get an extra pick or a player like Tomlinson bundled with pick 4 for 1 then we simply pass on 41 back to GWS or to the Swans for membrey in good faith.

i agree and hopefully we can just get membrey on the list now

not sure i am reading your post right, but just in case, you still need the list spot though, so a player would have to go if we are taking tominlson (which was the point of my post). unless we are using pick 21 or 22 somehow, but i think that defeats the purpose of trading stanley out
 
i agree and hopefully we can just get membrey on the list now

not sure i am reading your post right, but just in case, you still need the list spot though, so a player would have to go if we are taking tominlson (which was the point of my post). unless we are using pick 21 or 22 somehow, but i think that defeats the purpose of trading stanley out

The way I see it we will draft 4 & upgrade 4 rookies plus add Membrey. That's 9 spots (Hayes, Jones, TDL, Dunell, Stanley, Milera, Schnieder, Gwilt & Maister).

If we take an extra early pick like 1 for 4 & 7 we wont use 41 (give it to GWS or Syd for Membrey). Same goes if a player is involved in the pick 1 deal - we don't use 41.
 
We signed Simpkin until 2015 which is nuts last year.

Chuck him on the rookie list to see out that contract IMO.

the only time you see a player moved to the rookie list is when they have an optional year on their contract or when both parties agree to it (usually they do it for bigger reasons, which just isnt applicable in this scenario). we are not going to do it, has bigger ramifications/problems/shit fight
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

The way I see it we will draft 4 & upgrade 4 rookies plus add Membrey. That's 9 spots (Hayes, Jones, TDL, Dunell, Stanley, Milera, Schnieder, Gwilt & Maister).

If we take an extra early pick like 1 for 4 & 7 we wont use 41 (give it to GWS or Syd for Membrey). Same goes if a player is involved in the pick 1 deal - we don't use 41.

great call!!! hopefully it gets done
 
the only time you see a player moved to the rookie list is when they have an optional year on their contract or when both parties agree to it (usually they do it for bigger reasons, which just isnt applicable in this scenario). we are not going to do it, has bigger ramifications/problems/shit fight
It is what i would do.. It doesn't mean the club would follow what ever i say.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top