2015; Player X or Player Y or Player Z

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Bennell or Buddy?

Not a joke, reckon Bennell could go very large this year..

EDIT: In before Martin or Bartel.. Have both and Gray.

 

[SnappyHappy]

Bennell or Buddy?

Not a joke, reckon Bennell could go very large this year..

EDIT: In before Martin or Bartel.. Have both and Gray.

Both solid options IMO, Buddy ahead though

 

[Super Gusto]

Bennell or Buddy?

Not a joke, reckon Bennell could go very large this year..

EDIT: In before Martin or Bartel.. Have both and Gray.

Bennell should be more consistent. Buddy will go large one week (Loves the Bombers so pencil a big score in Rd 1) and be frustrating the next. Overall I think Buddy will average more but may cost you games the week he put's in a quite preformance.

 

[echelon]

Malceski vs Hibberd? Can't decide. Hibberd is $75k cheaper but I don't need the cash per se

 

[gcsunsfc]

Fair enough.

I could just trade Swan for Salem & upgrade Leuy & Adcock to top line premiums.

But I like Swan @ F4.

I like your suggested solution

 

[gcsunsfc]

25th hour freak out.
Deciding to get Pendles in.

2 possible scenarios to get him in.

Out - Gibson In - Newnes
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendelbury

OR

Out - Lewis - In - Griffen
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendlebury

Or don't touch it and stick with Gibson, Sidebottom and Lewis.

Definitely second solution for mine. Although, I'm not sold on Collingwoods chances of being a decent team this year and having Sidebottom and Pendles in a losing team might detract some points. They will both be top 10 though would have thought.

 

[gcsunsfc]

25th hour freak out.
Deciding to get Pendles in.

2 possible scenarios to get him in.

Out - Gibson In - Newnes
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendelbury

OR

Out - Lewis - In - Griffen
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendlebury

Or don't touch it and stick with Gibson, Sidebottom and Lewis.

I also think that Griffen has a chance to be top 10.

 

[kenneje]

25th hour freak out.
Deciding to get Pendles in.

2 possible scenarios to get him in.

Out - Gibson In - Newnes
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendelbury

OR

Out - Lewis - In - Griffen
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendlebury

Or don't touch it and stick with Gibson, Sidebottom and Lewis.

I'd be getting Griffen and Pendles in and keeping Gibson.

 

[gh172]

Which 2 out of Griffen , Wines , Jordan Lewis and Parker?

 

[DKS17]

25th hour freak out.
Deciding to get Pendles in.

2 possible scenarios to get him in.

Out - Gibson In - Newnes
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendelbury

OR

Out - Lewis - In - Griffen
Out - Sidebottom In - Pendlebury

Or don't touch it and stick with Gibson, Sidebottom and Lewis.

Tossing up the exact same thing (getting pendles in)

If you don't have already too many round 12 players in the mids then I would be going with option 1

however if you're stacked with round 12 mids then option 2 is definitely the best i think

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Which 2 out of Griffen , Wines , Jordan Lewis and Parker?

Parker and Griffen for me easy

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Which 6 would you rather take?

Simpson,Burgoyne,Taylor,Griffen,Minson and TBC
or
M.Johnson,Ibbo,Goodes,Ablett,Nic Nat and Buddy

 

[Kadog]

Mumford Dangerfield v

Jacobs Parker v

NicNat Rockliff

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Mumford Dangerfield v

Jacobs Parker v

NicNat Rockliff

Jacobs and Parker

 

[Lums23]

JPK and Watson for me. Reckon now with this ASADA stuff off his back Jobe can get back to 2012 form.

Need to pick two of Griffen/Danger/Watson?

2012 he won a brownlow and averaged 121, which is one of only two years he has averaged over 110 and 10 points better than his next best average.

 

[HTPunter]

Bennell should be more consistent. Buddy will go large one week (Loves the Bombers so pencil a big score in Rd 1) and be frustrating the next. Overall I think Buddy will average more but may cost you games the week he put's in a quite preformance.

Bennell isn't that consistent at all. In 2013 he had a run of 53, 119, 62, 121, 78, 106, 86...finished the year off with a run of 5 100's.

In 2014 Bennell didn't get consecutive 100's at all - at one stage going 100, 77, 167, 76, 110...and then 35, 115, 99, 144, 82, 73 to finish the year off.

Buddy can string together multiple good games and has a good 6+ week stretch at least every year in the last few...

I wouldn't start with either to be honest, at one stage both will have a shitty couple of weeks and you'll be able to snap them up cheaply if you want, but I guess Franklin has the proven premo status (averages of 107 in 2008, 107.5 in 2010, 110.8 in 2011, 115.5 in 2012 and even 99.9 in 2014)

 

[HTPunter]

2012 he won a brownlow and averaged 121, which is one of only two years he has averaged over 110 and 10 points better than his next best average.

He actually was on track for approx 114-116 average both years but got unlucky injuries both years (random hip injury in 2014 that is apparently very rare and think he did his shoulder 2013 which he has had no trouble since).

If you can predict a contact injury than that's good, but he's worth picking up on his scoring history at 574k

 

[dees 4 life]

Nic Nat or McEvoy?

Not sold on NicNat

 

[Spanish Sahara]

Nic Nat or McEvoy?

Not sold on NicNat

Not sold on Mcevoy either. Hawks will probably rotate Hale, Ceglar and Mcevoy all season

 

[brentman]

T Mitchell or Christensen, draft league so price has no bearing.

 

[Lachy Jamison]

T Mitchell or Christensen, draft league so price has no bearing.

Christensen

 

[Daniel McL]

Hibberd or James Kelly?

 

[Daniel McL]

And Jobe Watson, Dyson Heppell or Toby Greene?

 

[SnappyHappy]

And Jobe Watson, Dyson Heppell or Toby Greene?

Joben

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

And Jobe Watson, Dyson Heppell or Toby Greene?

Watson by the length of my d!ck...

So... a cupla millimetres...