2016: Player X vs Y vs Z

[doona]

Hadn't seen this thread here so thought I would start it. Pretty self explanatory title. I am just wondering on the 2-300K defenders.

Curious about thoughts on:
- Howe v McKenzie

 

[Thetrader15]

Libba v M Crouch...thoughts?

 

[mezaire]

Libba v M Crouch...thoughts?

Prob Libba based on his bye round but not starting with either at the moment. Gone with Graham instead

 

[Dan12]

Hall v Hunter is doing my head in at the moment

 

[Jozzy]

Hall v Hunter is doing my head in at the moment

With the form Hall finished the season in last year and how he's performed this NAB Cup it'll be very hard to pass him, how he'll go when Ablett, Prestia, Swallow and JOM return is the real question, he won't be there star man for that much longer. It appears those guys not playing really helped him. If you think those players won't affect his score or could even better him then you can't pass on him.

I'm after some opinions myself:

Option A:
Matthew Lobbe, Dan Hannebery & Jeremy Howe

Option B:
Zac Smith, Luke Parker & Bachar Houli/Kade Simpson

 

[doona]

With the form Hall finished the season in last year and how he's performed this NAB Cup it'll be very hard to pass him, how he'll go when Ablett, Prestia, Swallow and JOM return is the real question, he won't be there star man for that much longer. It appears those guys not playing really helped him. If you think those players won't affect his score or could even better him then you can't pass on him.

I'm after some opinions myself:

Option A:
Matthew Lobbe, Dan Hannebery & Jeremy Howe

Option B:
Zac Smith, Luke Parker & Bachar Houli/Kade Simpson

On form would have
Z. Smith > M. Lobbe.
Parker < Hanners
Houli/Simpson > Howe

I'd prob go b.

 

[Thetrader15]

With the form Hall finished the season in last year and how he's performed this NAB Cup it'll be very hard to pass him, how he'll go when Ablett, Prestia, Swallow and JOM return is the real question, he won't be there star man for that much longer. It appears those guys not playing really helped him. If you think those players won't affect his score or could even better him then you can't pass on him.

I'm after some opinions myself:

Option A:
Matthew Lobbe, Dan Hannebery & Jeremy Howe

Option B:
Zac Smith, Luke Parker & Bachar Houli/Kade Simpson

JOM and Swallow are out for a big chunk of the first half of the season so I'd go Hall.

I like option B as well

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Got a couple

Brodie Smith v Paul Seedsman

and

Pendles vs Dangerfield

 

[doona]

Got a couple

Brodie Smith v Paul Seedsman

and

Pendles vs Dangerfield

Danger verse any mid. Danger!!!

As for the otherone, I wouldn't go either but probably seeds

 

[mic59]

1. Wingard v Greene v S.Johnson.
2. Lobbe v Gawn v Sandilands.
3. Dangerfield v Pendlebury v Swan.

I'm a bit worried about Dangerfield. Not that I don't think he will deliver but that he has 1 fantasy score over 100 in the first 3 rounds for 6 years.

 

[I Lost My Keays]

1. Wingard v Greene v S.Johnson.
2. Lobbe v Gawn v Sandilands.
3. Dangerfield v Pendlebury v Swan.

I'm a bit worried about Dangerfield. Not that I don't think he will deliver but that he has 1 fantasy score over 100 in the first 3 rounds for 6 years.

1. don't like either player to be honest
2. Lobbe
3. Dangerfield

 

[snozulu]

Hadn't seen this thread here so thought I would start it. Pretty self explanatory title. I am just wondering on the 2-300K defenders.

Curious about thoughts on:
- Howe v McKenzie

Mckenzie has a higher cealing

 

[snozulu]

Got a couple

Brodie Smith v Paul Seedsman

and

Pendles vs Dangerfield

Brodie Smith as he seems to be over last years injuries and will get more midfield time with Dangerfield leaving. Also would go Dangerfield, he is in freakishly good form ATM

 

[snozulu]

1. Wingard v Greene v S.Johnson.
2. Lobbe v Gawn v Sandilands.
3. Dangerfield v Pendlebury v Swan.

I'm a bit worried about Dangerfield. Not that I don't think he will deliver but that he has 1 fantasy score over 100 in the first 3 rounds for 6 years.

wingard, Gawn and Danger

 

[Wrenny]

Nicholls vs Lobbe vs Sinclair vs McEvoy

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Nicholls vs Lobbe vs Sinclair vs McEvoy

Lobbe and Sinclair

 

[Wrenny]

Lobbe and Sinclair

Pick 1....

 

[I Lost My Keays]

Pick 1....

Oh Lobbe then

 

[HammerTime55]

Cripps vs Gibbs vs Libba? Its changed 15 times in the last 2 mins.

 

[doona]

Cripps vs Gibbs vs Libba? Its changed 15 times in the last 2 mins.

Cripps. Though I don't like Gibbs as he is as soft as butter.

 

[Spank2304]

Nicholls vs Lobbe vs Sinclair vs McEvoy

Sinclaire

 

[Spank2304]

Cripps vs Gibbs vs Libba? Its changed 15 times in the last 2 mins.

Cripps>Libba>Gibbs

 

[Spank2304]

1. Wingard v Greene v S.Johnson.
2. Lobbe v Gawn v Sandilands.
3. Dangerfield v Pendlebury v Swan.

Johnson
Gawn
Pendles

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Yeo vs Sheppard vs Sheridan vs other 350-450k defender

Really tough this one

 

[FlowersByIrene]

1. Wingard v Greene v S.Johnson.
2. Lobbe v Gawn v Sandilands.
3. Dangerfield v Pendlebury v Swan.

I'm a bit worried about Dangerfield. Not that I don't think he will deliver but that he has 1 fantasy score over 100 in the first 3 rounds for 6 years.

1. None, but Greene out of those
2. Gawn
3. Pendles, mr reliable.