pulpdriver
Brownlow Medallist
Physically he's the best I've ever seen him.
Position 2017 Midfielders
- Thread starter TheBeardAmigos
- Start date
-
- Tags
- 2017 midfielders supercoach
- Tagged users None
- Status
Physically he's the best I've ever seen him.
- Banned
- #177
What are people's thoughts on Sam Menegola as a POD at an M6? $486K?
Probably my Cats bias talking but in his 6 H&A games in 2016 he went 97, 77, 94, 91, 133, 103.
SC doesn't tell me his two SuperCoach scores in the AFL finals because the SC finals were over by then, so can only go by fantasy points in the AFL finals and in QF & PF he scored 82 & 63 so not sure what that equated to in terms of SC scores.
The game that stands out to me is Round 22 when he got 133 (was only against the Lions though...) from only 71% game time (low compared to the other midfielders), so with a full pre-season this year his game time should be up meaning more points.
He will be that 3rd midfielder in the centre alongside Dangerwood, which is one of the reasons Caddy left because he wasn't gonna be played in the middle ahead of Menegola. He's also ahead of Duncan & Guthrie who are more outside types.
Again big Geelong bias so want to know other people's thoughts on him
Probably my Cats bias talking but in his 6 H&A games in 2016 he went 97, 77, 94, 91, 133, 103.
SC doesn't tell me his two SuperCoach scores in the AFL finals because the SC finals were over by then, so can only go by fantasy points in the AFL finals and in QF & PF he scored 82 & 63 so not sure what that equated to in terms of SC scores.
The game that stands out to me is Round 22 when he got 133 (was only against the Lions though...) from only 71% game time (low compared to the other midfielders), so with a full pre-season this year his game time should be up meaning more points.
He will be that 3rd midfielder in the centre alongside Dangerwood, which is one of the reasons Caddy left because he wasn't gonna be played in the middle ahead of Menegola. He's also ahead of Duncan & Guthrie who are more outside types.
Again big Geelong bias so want to know other people's thoughts on him
pulpdriver
Brownlow Medallist
What are people's thoughts on Sam Menegola as a POD at an M6? $486K?
Probably my Cats bias talking but in his 6 H&A games in 2016 he went 97, 77, 94, 91, 133, 103.
SC doesn't tell me his two SuperCoach scores in the AFL finals because the SC finals were over by then, so can only go by fantasy points in the AFL finals and in QF & PF he scored 82 & 63 so not sure what that equated to in terms of SC scores.
The game that stands out to me is Round 22 when he got 133 (was only against the Lions though...) from only 71% game time (low compared to the other midfielders), so with a full pre-season this year his game time should be up meaning more points.
He will be that 3rd midfielder in the centre alongside Dangerwood, which is one of the reasons Caddy left because he wasn't gonna be played in the middle ahead of Menegola. He's also ahead of Duncan & Guthrie who are more outside types.
Again big Geelong bias so want to know other people's thoughts on him
He scored 89 in SC when you beat Hawks. Doesn't seem to be any scores about for the Sydney game available but considering your midfield seemed like a two man show that night I doubt it would be much. His scoring was decent and consistent and it seems reasonable to expect he could expect more games and potentially increased output with no Caddy along with natural development, but that price is seriously offputting imo. Beams, Murphy, Kelly, Watson and B. Crouch are all cheaper and objectively speaking do you think he will score higher than any of those players? He might but I dunno if I'd risk it. If he explodes you're a genius but anything less than tons every week he's gonna bleed cash and even then it's likely you'd be getting higher output from similarly priced players or cheaper players. Bit too much risk for me.
croweyrocks
All Australian
- Nov 29, 2014
- 976
- 1,311
- AFL Club
- Port Adelaide
What are people's thoughts on Sam Menegola as a POD at an M6? $486K?
Probably my Cats bias talking but in his 6 H&A games in 2016 he went 97, 77, 94, 91, 133, 103.
SC doesn't tell me his two SuperCoach scores in the AFL finals because the SC finals were over by then, so can only go by fantasy points in the AFL finals and in QF & PF he scored 82 & 63 so not sure what that equated to in terms of SC scores.
The game that stands out to me is Round 22 when he got 133 (was only against the Lions though...) from only 71% game time (low compared to the other midfielders), so with a full pre-season this year his game time should be up meaning more points.
He will be that 3rd midfielder in the centre alongside Dangerwood, which is one of the reasons Caddy left because he wasn't gonna be played in the middle ahead of Menegola. He's also ahead of Duncan & Guthrie who are more outside types.
Again big Geelong bias so want to know other people's thoughts on him
Waste of a pick IMO.
He scored 89 vs Hawks and 56 vs Swans in the 2 finals.
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
Don't do this to me
- Jun 29, 2008
- 22,480
- 31,843
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Token American sports team
- Banned
- #184
GAJ averaged 140+ one year, Danger didn't even get close. Danger isn't worth a hair on GAJ's beautiful arse.
stevebbb
Brownlow Medallist
- May 21, 2013
- 23,722
- 61,105
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Fluminense; Blue Jays
*assuming he makes it through the preseason
Needs more Bull...
Get him into the Gym!!
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
Dang. I aint ever seen him like that.
toxic
Hall of Famer
Lmao
toxic
Hall of Famer
Talk of him being captain
Yeah he's unlikely to be as good as GAJ. But IMO will be along with Fyfe the lock of next few years.
fantasyunit
All Australian
Danger
Gablett *
Fyfe *
Rocky *
Bont
*Might just be the year they all stay on the park for 22 games.
Gablett *
Fyfe *
Rocky *
Bont
*Might just be the year they all stay on the park for 22 games.
stevebbb
Brownlow Medallist
- May 21, 2013
- 23,722
- 61,105
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Fluminense; Blue Jays
my first effort and i've ended up with:
Danger, Treloar, Bont, Cripps and Fyfe
Pendles, Neale, Zerrett and Rocky on my radar though
Danger, Treloar, Bont, Cripps and Fyfe
Pendles, Neale, Zerrett and Rocky on my radar though
fantasyunit
All Australian
Surely you can't pick Zerrett with all the bombers returning?
stevebbb
Brownlow Medallist
- May 21, 2013
- 23,722
- 61,105
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Arsenal, Fluminense; Blue Jays
the kid is an absolute jet, he'll be better with help imo
- Jan 18, 2015
- 5,127
- 12,698
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
What are peoples expectations of the Bont this year. Seems to be getting lots of love. I'm seeing him as a tier below Rocky, Fyfe, JPK etc and likely to average around 105-110. Got a lot of big scores last year thanks to his heroic acts in the last few minutes of close games which isn't really sustainable in the long term. I feel he's still a year or maybe 2 off being a Super Premo.
Thoughts?
Thoughts?
Here2tellyouwhy
SA GREAT
I agree. In this game no one is a lock but Bont is a nice price for a healthy output with the potential to go SP 120+ and CD love him.
Hard to pass up but by no means a lock.
Obese Arachnid
Diplomatic Immunity
- Jan 11, 2008
- 24,675
- 91,108
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- There are no other teams.
Mentally he's still a knob though.
- Banned
- #200
Bont has a broken toe and hasn't done much of the pre season at all. Similar to last year it may take him a while to get going during the year because of a lack of pre season.
- Status
