What l'm referring is it seems there are different standards of performance expectations depending on your name.
2nds 2018 Suns Reserves and NEAFL
- Thread starter lucylou
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Peel67skin
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 21, 2017
- 8,387
- 3,941
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
- Banned
- #827
Of course they are ,some in leadership group (touk ,swallow) , some just returning from injuries or interrupted pre season ( ah chee),some playing in various position ( Martin , Bowes) , high profile trade in ( Weller) only 22 years with four pre season .
It's true. Sexton has impacted MAYBE 3 games at best this year but gets a game each week. Young the same. Day has gone goalless in 6 games already too.
the only reason to be playing someone each week who ISNT impacting the game, is if they're a younger player like Bowes, Ballard or Ainsworth who need the experience, which does beg the question: Why aren't Brodie and Scrimshaw playing
Last edited:
gcsunsfc
Cancelled
- Oct 24, 2012
- 7,619
- 7,901
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Milwaukee Bucks
Where do those bests come from
Lowah with 9 possessions 5 tackles and a goal was our best player?
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
Those are made by journos on the day I think who watch the game. They aren't related to Coaches votes.
SunnerSS
GCSUNSCAST HOST
- Sep 3, 2016
- 2,133
- 2,471
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
Thats 5 of the 6 listed bests in grimlocks post. Some one from the suns is obviously having an input.
grimlock
Hall of Famer
Not 100% sure but from years observation I think it's someone from each team inputting them. This is because sometimes after the game, there is one team that has put in their bests, but the other team hasn't yet.
Sometimes the bests change from the NEAFL site to the official site, the Swans have done this a few times, but not it's not a regular occurrence. My thoughts are that they've watched the replay or looked at the stats a day or two after and adjusted them.
Sometimes the bests change from the NEAFL site to the official site, the Swans have done this a few times, but not it's not a regular occurrence. My thoughts are that they've watched the replay or looked at the stats a day or two after and adjusted them.
Rocketman1984
Cancelled
- Jul 9, 2017
- 254
- 181
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
The correct stats are now in if someone wants to copy them from neafl site
grimlock
Hall of Famer
Thanks will correct later.
Sunny_
Brownlow Medallist
2MP the only Sun to get Coaches votes.
Peter Wright has collected two votes in the NEAFL MVP Award for his efforts against Sydney on Saturday.
Despite going down to the experienced Swans side 15.17 (107) to 6.4. (40), Wright kicked the opening two goals of the match and finished with 22 disposals.
Wright has been showing consistent performances in the NEAFL as he regains his match fitness and will certainly put his hand up for senior selection this week.
The NEAFL MVP Award is presented to the player uniquely judged the best in the competition by a combination of umpire and coaches votes.
The votes are submitted post-game cast on a 5-4-3-2-1 basis. As such, the maximum amount of votes a single player can earn per match is 10 – courtesy of the maximum five votes from both umpires and coaches.
NEAFL MVP VOTES – Round 11
Gold Coast v Sydney9: Darcy Cameron (Sydney)
8: Dan Robinson (Sydney)
7: Colin O’Riordan (Sydney)
4: James Rose (Sydney)
2: Peter Wright (Gold Coast)
NEAFL MVP LEADERBOARD – Round 11
51: Mitch Maguire (Canberra)
50: Josh Clayton (Southport)
46: Andrew Boston (Southport)
45: Matthew Payne (Aspley)
41: Dan Robinson (Sydney)
40: Tom Bell (Brisbane)
37: Andrew Swallow (Aspley)
35: Nic Newman (Sydney)
35: Craig Bird (Sydney Uni)
34: Alex Smout (Canberra
Peter Wright has collected two votes in the NEAFL MVP Award for his efforts against Sydney on Saturday.
Despite going down to the experienced Swans side 15.17 (107) to 6.4. (40), Wright kicked the opening two goals of the match and finished with 22 disposals.
Wright has been showing consistent performances in the NEAFL as he regains his match fitness and will certainly put his hand up for senior selection this week.
The NEAFL MVP Award is presented to the player uniquely judged the best in the competition by a combination of umpire and coaches votes.
The votes are submitted post-game cast on a 5-4-3-2-1 basis. As such, the maximum amount of votes a single player can earn per match is 10 – courtesy of the maximum five votes from both umpires and coaches.
NEAFL MVP VOTES – Round 11
Gold Coast v Sydney9: Darcy Cameron (Sydney)
8: Dan Robinson (Sydney)
7: Colin O’Riordan (Sydney)
4: James Rose (Sydney)
2: Peter Wright (Gold Coast)
NEAFL MVP LEADERBOARD – Round 11
51: Mitch Maguire (Canberra)
50: Josh Clayton (Southport)
46: Andrew Boston (Southport)
45: Matthew Payne (Aspley)
41: Dan Robinson (Sydney)
40: Tom Bell (Brisbane)
37: Andrew Swallow (Aspley)
35: Nic Newman (Sydney)
35: Craig Bird (Sydney Uni)
34: Alex Smout (Canberra
Rocketman1984
Cancelled
- Jul 9, 2017
- 254
- 181
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Rocketman1984
Cancelled
- Jul 9, 2017
- 254
- 181
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Gold CGC
3.1-19
4.1-25
4.3-27
6.4-40
SydneySYD
3.4-22
6.8-44
12.13-85
15.17-107
GOLD COAST
Goal Kickers: P. Wright 2, J. Gore, B. Crossley, C. Nutting, T. Lowah
Best Players: C. Graham, P. Wright, J. Dawson, M. Spencer, C. Budarick, T. Lowah
SYDNEY
Goal Kickers: D. Cameron 3, J. Rose 3, D. Towers 2, J. Stern 2, J. Dawson, B. Stewart, M. Rogers, R. Stoddart, S. Wicks
Best Players: D. Cameron, N. Newman, J. Rose, D. Robinson, C. O''Riordan, R. Fox
Great to see Scrimshaw, Lonergan, KK all in especially KK. Crossley's brother is emergency. 11 listed players.
B: 51. Kwaby Boakye 43. Max Spencer 46. Fitzroy Greenwool
HB: 53. Lachlan McDonald 2. Jack Scrimshaw 27. Wil Powell
C: 10. Kade Kolodjashnij 18. Bradley Scheer 52. Ryan Gilmore
HF: 42. Connor Nutting 47. Josh Gore 41. Will Brodie
F: 48. Timakoi Bowie 37. Josh Jaska 50. Emmanuel Baru
FOLL: 32. Brayden Crossley 40. Jacob Heron 7. Jesse Lonergan
INT: 49. Brodie Foster 57. Cooper Portelli 54. Tui Lowah 22. Matthew Conroy
EMG: 60. Ashton Crossley 59. Kane Haua 58. Harrison Arnold
B: 51. Kwaby Boakye 43. Max Spencer 46. Fitzroy Greenwool
HB: 53. Lachlan McDonald 2. Jack Scrimshaw 27. Wil Powell
C: 10. Kade Kolodjashnij 18. Bradley Scheer 52. Ryan Gilmore
HF: 42. Connor Nutting 47. Josh Gore 41. Will Brodie
F: 48. Timakoi Bowie 37. Josh Jaska 50. Emmanuel Baru
FOLL: 32. Brayden Crossley 40. Jacob Heron 7. Jesse Lonergan
INT: 49. Brodie Foster 57. Cooper Portelli 54. Tui Lowah 22. Matthew Conroy
EMG: 60. Ashton Crossley 59. Kane Haua 58. Harrison Arnold
Sunraysia
Club Legend
- Mar 16, 2015
- 1,476
- 1,763
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Gold Coast
Will be 10 Listed - One of Brodie, Spencer, Heron or Crossley will be off to the Tassie cold as emergency..
Lonergan also playing managed minutes …?
Yes, Haines mentioned that Lonergan will play limited minutes.
17er
Cancelled
- Oct 21, 2017
- 2,500
- 1,829
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
No Allies game for the Academy boys, so it is good to see Lachlan McDonald back in the NEAFL side - keep an eye on him because he could be high on our Draft board after starring for the Allies. Ryan Gilmore has also come back from Allies and is also a big chance of getting drafted.
This is a very, very young NEAFL team with 23 year old Jesse Lonergan the oldest, however, there are some great stories here for our list development. Lonergan and Kolodjashnij returning to football with a couple of months to stake a claim for the futures. Josh Jaska returns from injury to play FF, one of 3 Rookie listed players who will be hoping to consolidate their places on the list. There are 5 Top age Academy players, 4 of whom have represented the Allies at the U18 National Championships, who will be looking to promote their Draft stocks. There are a further half dozen Draft eligible guys who will return next year to the Academy if they are unsuccessful this year. Bottom agers Josh Gore and possibly Ashton Crossley will play in a side with 4 players who've had 20th birthdays.
Heres a breakdown of player ages and status
Senior S
Jack Scrimshaw S 19
Wil Powell S 18
Kade Kolodjashnij S 22
Bradley Scheer S 19
Brayden Crossley S 18
Jesse Lonergan S 23
Will Brodie S 19
Connor Nutting S 18
Rookie R
Max Spencer R 20
Jacob Heron R 18
Josh Jaska R 20
Allies A
Ryan Gilmore A DE 17
Lachlan McDonald A 18
Top agers last TA
Timakoi Bowie A TA 19
Emmanuel Baru A TA 18
Harrison Arnold TA 19
Kwaby Boakye TA 19
Brodie Foster TA 19
2018 Draft eligible DE
Cooper Portelli DE 18
Fitzroy Greenwool DE 18
Tui Lowah DE 18
Matthew Conroy DE 17
Kane Haua DE 17
Bottom agers can't be drafted BA
Josh Gore BA 17
Ashton Crossley BA 16
1QTR, GC leading by 1 point. Nice contest, tackling by Suns. Missing tall forward. Highlights, Scrimshaw's one-hand mark, Crossley's bump. Brodie is the best for me, Scrimshaw also good. I especially like that may be for the first time I see Brodie and Scrimshaw organising troops. Scheer also good.
Playing with good pressure
Peel67skin
Norm Smith Medallist
- May 21, 2017
- 8,387
- 3,941
- AFL Club
- Gold Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
- Banned
- #847
Like the look of Mcdonald look play like a footballer .
