- Sep 5, 2013
- 6,704
- 11,395
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Western Bulldogs
Geez, just having a look at B Ellis, averaging 116 over the last 4
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Geez, just having a look at B Ellis, averaging 116 over the last 4
Unless you have Flynn at R2 , it’s premature to trade him out .... at worse he provides cover for the R14 byes of Gawndy
Can someone explain the Neale love .... last 4 years hasn’t ave over 100 .... he’s a SC must have, but i’m not seeing him as a must have in Fantasy ??
View attachment 1106990
Talk of Atkins dropped v Eagles tall fwd line. Was looking like an ok pick with a pair of 88’s but looked sh*t v North. Don’t need much of an excuse to cut another mid pricer.
Webster > Macrae Jr
Atkins > Titch
With some DPP swaps have wormed Burgess away from the backline for Bergman D6 so Highmore up can wait (him to Stocker could be a move). Leaves me with
Laird Doc Ridley Hind Fanta Bergman (Kosi Spudmore)
Macrae Zez Steele Titch Taranto Powell Jordon Macrae Jr (Berry Brock)
Grundy Flynn (Burgo)
Dunkley Phillips Stepho Gulden Warner Rowe (Treacy, Fullarspud)
110k itb. Hopefully Kosi goes ok v Crows as cover for Ridley.
Phillips/Flynn for Gawn/rook next week when Mummy inevitably returns.
Let’s see what goes wrong between now and then. Horse hasn’t reared his ugly head yet.. Swans rooks rested is the spanner I’m waiting for.
Sholl has a much better and safer role imo. On the wing is a great position for point scoring where Jiath whilst a free roaming defender, will get lock down jobs from time to time. Sholl finished last year with a 100 and a 90 (scaled) so it’s a 7 game sample of a 90+ average. I don’t think he’s an Uber (Lloyd, Laird, Docherty type) but I feel he’s a premium this year. He’s in that Short, Daniel, Duggan bracket but is 100k cheaper than those types
Like your thinking, in a similar boat but my mind always goes back to the 30k more expensive Treloar. Maybe it’s the name, or the fact he’s in a better team. Just seen Treloar’s CBA numbers and only ~40% . Tough decision !
Absolute fair points you raise there. You’ve got me considering Ward and banking 50kWith that said, Daniel will be cheaper than Sholl in two weeks, and Ridley and Houston will be around 650K, so do you hold off on trading in a midpricer, or bank cash to get likely Top 6 types who'll be a similar price?
It's why I'm giving Sholl a miss, as he's still in a Bottom 4 team, and he still only scores really well against Bottom 8 teams (and us in Round 1 who played like a bottom 4 team, lol). Up against Sydney, he only scored 47, and up against the Suns who aren't that great either, he scored 74. His run coming up after next week is very tough, so it could be a bit of a trap if the Crows are getting belted and not winning much ball.
If you jumped on at 500K it'd be worth it, but nearly 600K, you'd wanna be sure he's in the top 6-8 come the pointy end of the season IMO
It's fair to say most of the SP's have been tagged and performed poorly .....Piggy, Zerrett, Neale and even Cripps / DangerThink it helps that he's dropped over 150K, so people see a lot of upside there. With that said, I think at least half of his games for the rest of the season, he gets tagged. Will have some monster games, but when you've got Treloar, Brouch, Titch, Danger, all as underpriced too, it's hard to justify Neale when he's so much more susceptible to a tag than the rest of the aforementioned
Absolute fair points you raise there. You’ve got me considering Ward and banking 50k
It's fair to say most of the SP's have been tagged and performed poorly .....Piggy, Zerrett, Neale and even Cripps / Danger
Some players are more Fantasy relevant and some SC relevant ......I've just brought Neale in as a must have for SC ...yet my preference is Piggy in Fantasy
Interesting with Neale, in the last 4 games v CARL he's scored big in 3 of those games .....each time Curnow was playing
Ward is interesting, as he's got the Dogs this week which will probably be a 70-80, but could be very solid after that. If you had no choice, I'd choose him given the cash savings and his decent upside. If you do though and can get that bit higher, you're better off getting to a Brouch, Treloar, Neale, Titch, Ziebell etc. type
Anyone factoring in the byes with their upgrade targets?
I only have 12 premos but with RO'B in next week I'll have 6 premos out already for rnd 14 and 8 of my current rookies.
For me I'll be targeting the rnd 12-13 premos to spread the load a bit.
Anyone factoring in the byes with their upgrade targets?
I only have 12 premos but with RO'B in next week I'll have 6 premos out already for rnd 14 and 8 of my current rookies.
For me I'll be targeting the rnd 12-13 premos to spread the load a bit.
Gulden > Rowe would just about top that off
Doesn't appear Curnow has applied hard tags in a number of CARL games ......O'Connor GEEL's tagger is out with a heelThat is interesting re: Neale and the Curnow tag...
Maybe it gets a bit harder now though that Walsh is on the inside, Berry as a big body is not playing, and Williams is added to that midfield mix - so Neale doesn't win as much ball/makes it easier for Curnow to 'check' Neale, without having other mids try and stop him.
Absolute agree on Titch in Fantasy vs Neale in SC - completely different scoring schema and thus completely different when it comes to what players are best for that particular format
He’s only been playing that role the last couple weeks. Prior to that he was just running around like a headless chook. I’ve been following him closely as I’ve got him in all my keeper leagues. PrickWhat happened to Worpel?
He was one we debated on walsh versus worpel... I was convinced worpel would be better.
He's a shadow of himself in this defensive tagging role he seems to be playing. Will it stick?
If its only temporary he might be a good get in a couple weeks for a rookie upgrade.
My thinking is that as long as you have 18 scoring players each round, the byes will balance out over the three weeks.Would 4 midfielders and 7 overall premiums from the one bye round be considered too
Many? Just looked at an option where I could possibly get Neale in but already have Macrae, Zerrett, Walsh as round 13 bye premiums in the midfield