- Sep 8, 2013
- 5,661
- 9,367
- AFL Club
- Richmond
Now that I’ve had time to think, I’m thinking Daniel might be the better option than Hall. Daniel is more likely a keeper than Hall you’d suspect ?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Do you really need to ask that question? Wish I had the opportunity of getting Gawn in.Which one is the better trade?
Option 1
Phillips -> Gawn
Gulden -> RCD
$7k in the bank
Option 2
Phillips -> Hall
Gulden -> RCD
$279k in the bank BUT I have to cop a donut for Flynn at R2
Do you really need to ask that question? Wish I had the opportunity of getting Gawn in.
As suggested earlier, maybe look at other combinations..What is a better strategy at this stage of the season:
Two mid 500s types for a rookie and an uber premium
Phillips and Warner --> RCD and Macrae
Two failed rookies/mid pricers for a cheaper and a rookie
Clark and Campbell --> Frederick and Daicos
Can you post your team, Ash? Might be a better option than treacy to trade out.Pretty sold on trading out Tex and Treacy, but not totally convinced with my ins. Any suggestions of combinations are greatly appreciated. (830k all together to work with)
View attachment 1118029
I was looking at Marshall too, he put up a score of 80 odd with Ryder back, might still have foot issues and has a BE 108 which might see him drop a bit in price too. Not really what I'm wanting at this stage from a 700k purchase. Gawn could quite well drop 50-60k with that 72 in his rolling average, he could also pump out consecutive 130's and not drop much.Only thing making me question Gawn is that he has a pretty high BE and is coming up against Hickey who hasn't been giving up heaps to rucks. Thinking Marshall this week and then I'll grab Max when he drops a bit more and swing Marshall fwd.
Get rid of Tyson and keep Treacy for now. Then you should be able to afford Gawn in ruck. Hopefully my maths is correct.Sure. Just looks pretty terrible at the moment not going to lie.
View attachment 1118048View attachment 1118050View attachment 1118052
Ash24 this is a good suggestion.Get rid of Tyson and keep Treacy for now. Then you should be able to afford Gawn in ruck. Hopefully my maths is correct.
I'm getting Hall this week because
1) I'm not winning a car anyway
2) the thought of two North potatoes getting 350 between them is too enticing. Imagine putting the C on one of them for 400.
Possible freo news:
Treacy played well for Peel, may be a chance to come back in this week.
Think Western might be close to a debut as well.
Hard to make a call until teams come out... if Flynn and Campbell are both named, your situation gets much better.Sure. Just looks pretty terrible at the moment not going to lie.
View attachment 1118048View attachment 1118050View attachment 1118052
Treacy on field will be tempting if Bryan and Flynn are both dead this week.I'm getting Hall this week because
1) I'm not winning a car anyway
2) the thought of two North potatoes getting 350 between them is too enticing. Imagine putting the C on one of them for 400.
Possible freo news:
Treacy played well for Peel, may be a chance to come back in this week.
Think Western might be close to a debut as well.
Yes Campbell into Guldens spot and trading Gulden would give him the extra cash if my suggestion is short which now that I’ve re-done it I think is $4k shortHard to make a call until teams come out... if Flynn and Campbell are both named, your situation gets much better.
With Flynn in, you can hold Treacy for another week with Flynn and McEvoy onfield. Then you can go Tex and Gulden out, giving you 1.1M to play with, so you can grab an Uber Premo and RCD...
He will probably get injured this week. He’s not durable enough to be a keeper I wouldn’t imagine but hopefully he makes enough cash prior to that to get an actual keeper.Is there a chance that Hall becomes a keeper? Forward line is pretty average this year so could be a chance up there?
Would you then be better off going a fallen Caleb Daniel who should be a defensive keeper? They’re exactly the same priceHe will probably get injured this week. He’s not durable enough to be a keeper I wouldn’t imagine but hopefully he makes enough cash prior to that to get an actual keeper.
Maybe but my forward line is complete shit. And Halls role looks juicy for quick cash. I’m not sold on Daniel based on a game against us. We don’t tend to defend much against an individual half back. If he does it again I’ll look at him.Would you then be better off going a fallen Caleb Daniel who should be a defensive keeper? They’re exactly the same price
Definitely dump Tex too. I’m getting rid of him this week. I should have done it 2 weeks agoThanks for the suggestion tigs2010. I've been neglecting trading out Tyson just because this week for example I have Tex who is taking up almost $10k per point over the last 3 weeks.
I'm not quite sure on who to prioritise because on one hand you have Tyson on the bench who takes up 400k but won't score anything. On the other hand you have Walker costing over 600k, and averaging in the last month less than Corbett or Cameron for almost 200k cheaper.
I would trade Gulden and Walker to stop bleeding cash. So maybe sideways swap them to Hall and Daniel (via DPP). Might not have enough cash to get both so Hall is the obvious choice of the two to get first.View attachment 1118071
Still so unsure what to do this week and only have 3k in the bank. I have this bad habit of giving underperforming players chance after chance because I'm so scared of them punishing me after I trade them out. All signs point to Tex being cooked but I just have a sense he might kick a few in the showdown...same with Jiath, maybe defenders can score well against the eagles....
Initial thoughts are:
Gulden to RCD
Rowe to Hall
but that only leaves me 46k for next week....
Other option is:
Gulden to RCD
Tex to Hall
Leaves me with 335k next week and an opportunity to to get both Ridley and Helmet cheaply (for Jiath and Fantasia)
Any other better trades that I'm not seeing?