2022 All Aus Predictions and Rolling teams

[STPer18]

So Richmond is the highest scoring team this year,

Tom Lynch has kicked more goals than Hawkins and Cameron

And we just want to fill the forward line with Geelong players? Stengle, Hawkins, Cameron?

Yeah, nah

Blicavs starting on the bench but can run forward too. Get all four of them down there I reckon.

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

Blicavs starting on the bench but can run forward too. Get all four of them down there I reckon.

Too bad they aren't premiership players cause Richmond knocked them out year after year

 

[STPer18]

Too bad they aren't premiership players cause Richmond knocked them out year after year

Hawkins has multiple premierships. How new to the sport are we?

 

[PhatBoy]

So Richmond is the highest scoring team this year,

Tom Lynch has kicked more goals than Hawkins and Cameron

And we just want to fill the forward line with Geelong players? Stengle, Hawkins, Cameron?

Yeah, nah

Who is ‘we.’ I still don’t think Stengle will make it or should make it. Squad yes team no.

Goals per game is great. It’s a very important figure and clearly that on its own impacts the scoreboard. But doing that, and virtually nothing else, is not reason enough to just disregard other players that have more than one facet to their game.

If it was that simple, the best tap ruckman would get picked every year, the midfielders would just be the ones with the highest possession count every year, the first defender picked would be someone that is the best spoiler in the league.

Very few players are picked for having one primary area of contribution unless that area is so far ahead of their rivals that it’s impossible to leave them out.

Think a Ben Brown winning a coleman medal by 20 goals.

Right now Lynch is the best pure goal kicking forward in the league. No one is suggesting otherwise. It doesn’t make him the best forward in the league.

 

[PhatBoy]

Too bad they aren't premiership players cause Richmond knocked them out year after year

That lends a lot to your argument and enhances its credibility

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Well Coleman Curnow must be a lock now. Lynch v Hawkins and Cameron will be an interesting choice... Have they ever selected 4 KPFs before with 1 on the bench?

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Hawkins has multiple premierships. How new to the sport are we?

Hard to know much about footy back then. Memberships were microwaved by May.

 

[morningbrown]

Can't wait for Falcon to turn up

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

Hawkins has multiple premierships. How new to the sport are we?

Nah just have memories of your blokes shitting the bed in finals forgot you had a dinosaur on your list

 

[PhatBoy]

Nah just have memories of your blokes shitting the bed in finals forgot you had a dinosaur on your list

Wouldn’t surprise me if you just didn’t know it given that I’m guessing you hadn’t watched a finals series before 2017.

 

[AG]

Well Coleman Curnow must be a lock now. Lynch v Hawkins and Cameron will be an interesting choice... Have they ever selected 4 KPFs before with 1 on the bench?

Yeah, even 4 in the forward line from memory during the early 2000s. Riewoldt, Tredrea, Fevola, Hall, Pavlich, Brown era

 

[STPer18]

Nah just have memories of your blokes shitting the bed in finals forgot you had a dinosaur on your list

Players like Cotchin, Martin and Riewoldt were all on the Tiggies list during that time.

 

[Young Gun #6]

Rozee !

 

[JasRulz63]

Well Coleman Curnow must be a lock now. Lynch v Hawkins and Cameron will be an interesting choice... Have they ever selected 4 KPFs before with 1 on the bench?

Not since 2011 it seems - Franklin, Cloke, Goodes, Petrie (I/C). Pavlich made the bench in 2006 and 2008 with 3 KPFs on the field too.

It's genuinely a pretty close call between them; I don't think it'd be outrageous to put one on the bench.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Rozee showdown medal, lock

 

[Trav 20]

I can’t see a circumstance in which they will leave out the player ranked #1 for score involvements, #1 for goal assists, and #2 for goals (may be third if Lynch kicks another one in the last 10 minutes).

When did he overtake Petracca ?

 

[RAPPA]

Wouldn’t surprise me if you just didn’t know it given that I’m guessing you hadn’t watched a finals series before 2017.

Spent his previous years microwaving memberships

 

[Boxhead_31]

Wouldn’t surprise me if you just didn’t know it given that I’m guessing you hadn’t watched a finals series before 2017.

He always thought football season ended after round 23

 

[PhatBoy]

When did he overtake Petracca ?

Apologies - they were equal #1 going into this round

 

[TheWhiteRhino]

Ok, might as well throw my hat in the ring:

FB: Sicily - Taylor - Docherty
HB: Sinclair - May - Daicos

C: Brayshaw (Freo) - Miller - Rozee

HF: Petracca - Cameron - Heeney
FF: Lynch - Curnow - Hawkins

Rucks: Gawn - Oliver - Neale

Interchange
Mills, Bolton, Blicavs, Laird

 

[Falcon3518]

Apologies - they were equal #1 going into this round

So still no lynch? Not even all 4 of them in the team?

Also if you wanna tell the other blokes I’m banned from that other thread that you be good. They wanted me to give a GMHBA home ground advantage calc.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Daka]

If Hawkins is in which I think he should be. Lynch has to be in the team to he has been more dominant, taken more contested marks & kicked more goals in less games.
Curnow & Cameron are both mobile don't see how you would not pick all four clearly worthy.

 

[Seeds]

If Hawkins is in which I think he should be. Lynch has to be in the team to he has been more dominant, taken more contested marks & kicked more goals in less games.
Curnow & Cameron are both mobile don't see how you would not pick all four clearly worthy.

hawkins shouldnt be in the team. stengle far more deserving,

 

[Seeds]

Who is ‘we.’ I still don’t think Stengle will make it or should make it. Squad yes team no.

Goals per game is great. It’s a very important figure and clearly that on its own impacts the scoreboard. But doing that, and virtually nothing else, is not reason enough to just disregard other players that have more than one facet to their game.

If it was that simple, the best tap ruckman would get picked every year, the midfielders would just be the ones with the highest possession count every year, the first defender picked would be someone that is the best spoiler in the league.

Very few players are picked for having one primary area of contribution unless that area is so far ahead of their rivals that it’s impossible to leave them out.

Think a Ben Brown winning a coleman medal by 20 goals.

Right now Lynch is the best pure goal kicking forward in the league. No one is suggesting otherwise. It doesn’t make him the best forward in the league.

Stengle has been one of the most destructive players in the competition in the second half of the season. He should be a lock. i would pick him ahead of hawkins easily. not just his goals but his run down tackles and smothers and freakish assists have been phenomenol.

 

[tastiger]

Nah, the three key forwards have been set 3 rounds ago.

22 games played in the season. Can't decide these thing with 3 games to go

Sent from my VOG-L09 using Tapatalk