Preview 2022 Goodbye (To 2023) New; Preseason Discussion

[Wargreymon90]

Yeah ones a brownlow medalist, 3x all australian, 4x best and fairest.

And the other got his pants pulled down by fogarty in the last game of the season.

I thought winning premierships was the only thing that matters?

Cripps has never even played in a final.

 

[PatientMental]

Well I can absolutely understand how a doctor feel and a mental patient would get along

His alias is literally the shitposting 'feels' meme in prison bars

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

As much as I hate to say it, Fogarty isn't a punchline anymore. Averaged 2.5 goals in his last 12 games of the season. Jonas wasn't the first guy to get his pants pulled down by Fogarty and he won't be the last. It's like shitcanning someone because Todd Marshall kicked a few goals on them.

Yeah it fking hurts.

Though I'm clinging onto the last hope it was just for a new contract as he was heading in the wrong direction...

Slim. But I can hope.

 

[PatientMental]

I thought winning premierships was the only thing that matters?

Cripps has never even played in a final.

Port is supposed to exist to win flags.

Carlton are supposed to exist.

Different measurements for success.

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

Port is supposed to exist to win flags.

Carlton are supposed to exist.

Different measurements for success.

Now that's just dumb.

Given they've won as much as anyone.

Granted, vfl BS. But if we wanna discount them, we've won 1 too.

 

[PatientMental]

Now that's just dumb.

Given they've won as much as anyone.

Granted, vfl BS.

Carlton have 1 flag.

That's barely existing.

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

Carlton have 1 flag.

That's barely existing.

So do we by that logic.

Though you've made a habit of contradicting yourself and having different rules when it suits...

For 10 plus years of irrelevance I didn't hear 1 call for them to be shifted to Tassie...

 

[PatientMental]

So do we by that logic.

Though you've made a habit of contradicting yourself and having different rules when it suits...

I just have far higher expectations of my own team than one that should have been dissolved the moment they got done for salary cap breaches.

 

[Wargreymon90]

Port is supposed to exist to win flags.

Carlton are supposed to exist.

Different measurements for success.

I don’t disagree re Carlton. But you want Jonas to be more like their captain.

What exactly is the point you’re trying to make?

Jonas shouldn’t be captain? Sure, given his age and his position, I think most of this board would agree.

Jonas shouldn’t be best 22? He clearly is, still a good player (not great), but better than what we have (besides Aliir)

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

I just have far higher expectations of my own team than one that should have been dissolved the moment they got done for salary cap breaches.

Yeah well, you don't dissolve teams because they cheat.

You dissolve them because no one cares.

Luckily we've come a hell of a long way since those days.

 

[PatientMental]

Yeah well, you don't dissolve teams because they cheat.

You dissolve them because no one cares.

Luckily we've come a hell of a long way since those days.

Bullshit

If port pulled what carlton did with salary cap cheating or essendon did with doping we would have been instantly dissolved rather than the resulting slap on the wrist they got.

 

[DaTBird187]

This thread......

 

[Jonts]

i don’t think you can question Jonas’s dedication or conditioning.

Sure he’s a limited footballer, being a third tall, and maybe it’s time for him to move on from being captain, but he’s still easily in our best 22.

And lol at using the perennial loser, Patrick Cripps, as an model example of a captain.

What? Patrick Cripps is a great captain

Rewatch that round 23 game

 

[manureid]

Jonas is so fat after his big off season he can be Co Captains by himself.

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

Bullshit

If port pulled what carlton did with salary cap cheating or essendon did with doping we would have been instantly dissolved rather than the resulting slap on the wrist they got.

God, here comes the conspiracy crap again.

Yeah we may been dissolved, but not cause of Vic Bias. Cause we were a fking basket case on the field, off the field, everywhere. We got friends and family to the games....

Carlton, well they still pulled crowds, still rated on TV, still commanded Friday Nights....

Essendon even dumber to compare with.

 

[PatientMental]

God, here comes the conspiracy crap again.

Yeah we may been dissolved, but not cause of Vic Bias. Cause we were a fking basket case on the field, off the field, everywhere. We got friends and family to the games....

Carlton, well they still pulled crowds, still rated on TV, still commanded Friday Nights....

Essendon even dumber to compare with.

Basket cases that haven't been dissolved but should be.

Gc
Gws
North
St kilda
Western bulldogs

I could go on.


Also, why is everything you disagree with a conspiracy.

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

Basket cases that haven't been dissolved but should be.

Gc
Gws
North
St kilda
Western bulldogs

I could go on.

If you are gonna dissolve them, and you can list others, please tell me how we aren't next or in that group too?

Given GWS, Saints and Dogs have played in GFs or won flags since we've done it.

 

[PatientMental]

If you are gonna dissolve them, and you can list others, please tell me how we aren't next or in that group too?

Given GWS, Saints and Dogs have played in GFs or won flags since we've done it.

Because we are integral to the afls functionality as a national sport.

Those teams are not.

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

Because we are integral to the afls functionality as a national sport.

Those teams are not.

The Way SAs population is trending compared to say Victoria..... There is only 1 way our futures are heading unless we can stop Crows parents forcing their kids to follow the Crows.

Vic is going to overtake NSW one day.

SA is going to go the way of Alice Springs at this rate.

 

[PatientMental]

The Way SAs population is trending compared to say Victoria..... There is only 1 way our futures are heading unless we can stop Crows parents forcing their kids to follow the Crows.

Vic is going to overtake NSW one day.

SA is going to go the way of Alice Springs at this rate.

Jfc you're negative

 

[PAFC_FOREVER]

Jfc you're negative

Uh no. SA recently had a forecast for negative population growth. May have changed though during covid....

But regardless, Vic is trending and expecting to overtake NSW.

We are also a state full of old bastards.

Victoria isn't.

You've been negative all day.

 

[Ford Fairlane]

 

[Doctor Feel]

Jonas is so fat after his big off season he can be Co Captains by himself.

Gagging on Donuts if you know what I mean.

Tom Jonarse.

 

[Alyx]

I heard Tom Jonas went into a restaurant, and ate everything in the restaurant, and they had to close the restaurant.

 

[Ford Fairlane]