Strategy 2022 Planning Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
WaynesWorld19 said:
Steve, Dusty is dead as a Fantasy player .....he's been on a slow decline the last few years ...and this year has spelt his death knell, he won't rebound back
Click to expand...
Did your crystal ball tell you that? 😂

Still averaging 92.5 which includes two games where he was subbed off early with injury.

As I said, I won't start him, but if he's playing well, if there's no other forward premos and he's cheap, I'll 100% consider him
 
Seymour Skinner said:
Duncan has been very durable over the years.
Write off this year.
Not including his debut season he's only missed;
4 (don't know if these were injuries or just not established best 22 yet), 1, 0, 0, 11, 0, 1, 2, 0 and 1.
So only the 2 really significant injuries over his career, worth backing in imo.
Click to expand...
I'll stand to be corrected .....but I count 3 injuries this year alone ....not sure PS, but a hammy and now his current knee
Just a bad run this year, or a sign ?

1626999890486.png
 
stevebbb said:
Did your crystal ball tell you that? 😂

Still averaging 92.5 which includes two games where he was subbed off early with injury.

As I said, I won't start him, but if he's playing well, if there's no other forward premos and he's cheap, I'll 100% consider him
Click to expand...
Absolutely no-way I have Dusty in my side at any price .....he's aging and aspects of his game that were his strength, are now becoming less effective
 

Log in to remove this ad.

stevebbb said:
Did your crystal ball tell you that? 😂

Still averaging 92.5 which includes two games where he was subbed off early with injury.

As I said, I won't start him, but if he's playing well, if there's no other forward premos and he's cheap, I'll 100% consider him
Click to expand...

The Dusty dynamic is very funny this year.

Apparently Dusty is no good anymore.

But now Richmond can't win because this player that is no good is out.

Will be one of the most owned players yet again next season come round 1. Bank on it.
 
WaynesWorld19 said:
Absolutely no-way I have Dusty in my side at any price .....he's aging and aspects of his game that were his strength, are now becoming less effective
Click to expand...
Each to their own mate :shrug:
 
Andrew Birch said:
First picked.

View attachment 1184379
Click to expand...
Averaged 102.9 last year. Doubt he gets more than 10% discount so would be around $480-500k. Hard to pass at that price. Surely takes every kick in for the hawks.

Only issue is can Sicily, Day, Scrimsook, Hardwick, Jiath, and Impey all play in the back half and how do the points get shared around.

Hawthorn will be bottom 4 again next year so at least there will be a lot of ball in their defense.
 
Maybe Tomorrow said:
Averaged 102.9 last year. Doubt he gets more than 10% discount so would be around $480-500k. Hard to pass at that price. Surely takes every kick in for the hawks.

Only issue is can Sicily, Day, Scrimsook, Hardwick, Jiath, and Impey all play in the back half and how do the points get shared around.

Hawthorn will be bottom 4 again next year so at least there will be a lot of ball in their defense.
Click to expand...

SP Bramble has taken his spot. Sicily to play full forward.
 
Maybe Tomorrow said:
Averaged 102.9 last year. Doubt he gets more than 10% discount so would be around $480-500k. Hard to pass at that price. Surely takes every kick in for the hawks.

Only issue is can Sicily, Day, Scrimsook, Hardwick, Jiath, and Impey all play in the back half and how do the points get shared around.

Hawthorn will be bottom 4 again next year so at least there will be a lot of ball in their defense.
Click to expand...

Why would he only get a 10% discount? He's missed 18 months. Surely he gets the full 30% discount?
 
Andrew Birch said:
Why would he only get a 10% discount? He's missed 18 months. Surely he gets the full 30% discount?
Click to expand...
Why does he get 30%?

Titch missed a whole season and got 10%

Sicily with a 30% discount will be $400k and in every team. No way the SC nerds let that happen. He'll be priced high enough that not everyone picks him.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Maybe Tomorrow said:
Why does he get 30%?

Titch missed a whole season and got 10%

Sicily with a 30% discount will be $400k and in every team. No way the SC nerds let that happen. He'll be priced high enough that not everyone picks him.
Click to expand...

Titch was the exception not the norm though as far as injury discounts to premo's go. He was #1 SC player/scorer (129 average) before he was injured. I'd be surprised if Sicily receives any less than 20%-25% after missing 1 & 1/2 seasons. I'm pretty sure Doch received a 30% discount after missing 2 seasons.
 
Andrew Birch said:
Titch was the exception not the norm though as far as injury discounts to premo's go. He was #1 SC player/scorer (129 average) before he was injured. I'd be surprised if Sicily receives any less than 20%-25% after missing 1 & 1/2 seasons. I'm pretty sure Doch received a 30% discount after missing 2 seasons.
Click to expand...
I guess we'll see. I hope he's not too cheap as then he will be in every team and he's irrelevant really.

Yeah Doc only got 30% after two seasons out.

I think they just pull these things out of their arse a bit. It should be a consistent formula, but this is SC.
 
Maybe Tomorrow said:
I guess we'll see. I hope he's not too cheap as then he will be in every team and he's irrelevant really.

Yeah Doc only got 30% after two seasons out.

I think they just pull these things out of their arse a bit. It should be a consistent formula, but this is SC.
Click to expand...

30% is the maximum discount they give anyone and a lot of people still didn't start with Doch despite the full discount because 2 years is a long time. By the time Rd1 comes along it will have been 20 months since Sicily did his injury so not much difference in downtime. Hopefully many won't take the risk after such a long lay off even if he does start at low 400k.
 
Andrew Birch said:
30% is the maximum discount they give anyone and a lot of people still didn't start with Doch despite the full discount because 2 years is a long time. By the time Rd1 comes along it will have been 20 months since Sicily did his injury so not much difference in downtime. Hopefully many won't take the risk after such a long lay off even if he does start at low 400k.
Click to expand...

Sicily & Milera in the backline to start the year what could go wrong.....

why not both.gif
 
Andrew Birch said:
30% is the maximum discount they give anyone and a lot of people still didn't start with Doch despite the full discount because 2 years is a long time. By the time Rd1 comes along it will have been 20 months since Sicily did his injury so not much difference in downtime. Hopefully many won't take the risk after such a long lay off even if he does start at low 400k.
Click to expand...
I heard him on Triple M a few weeks ago, sounded like he could play now, but they are holding him back until next year. He didn't sound very happy about it. But the tank is on I guess.

If he's low $400k's he'll be in 60% of teams round 1.
 
pincrusher said:
Stuck at full forward for the first 5 weeks. Price plummets, everyone trades him out and then Clarko decides to put him back in his best position. Bookmark it.
Click to expand...

Haha can you imagine. I think we'll get a good idea what Clarko's plans are for Sicily over the pre-season & how he's used in the praccy games.
 
Andrew Birch said:
Why would he only get a 10% discount? He's missed 18 months. Surely he gets the full 30% discount?
Click to expand...

Isn't it 20% if they miss the whole season?

But yeah, like with Titch they just pick and choose who gets what discount, and don't go by the precedent that they've set.
Surely Sicily isn't a big enough no brainer pick that they don't give him a proper discount tho.
A lot has changed in the Hawks backline since he went down.
 
Seymour Skinner said:
Isn't it 20% if they miss the whole season?

But yeah, like with Titch they just pick and choose who gets what discount, and don't go by the precedent that they've set.
Surely Sicily isn't a big enough no brainer pick that they don't give him a proper discount tho.
A lot has changed in the Hawks backline since he went down.
Click to expand...
Schrimshaw 👀
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

WaynesWorld19
Discussion 2025 Pre-Season Planning Discussion
14 15 16 17 18
Replies
425
Views
23K
Makeshift Park
Makeshift Park
stevebbb
  • Locked
Strategy 2024 Planning Thread
25 26 27 28 29
Replies
709
Views
52K
WaynesWorld19
WaynesWorld19
Jiska
  • Locked
BBL Supercoach Thread
Replies
0
Views
2K
Jiska
Jiska

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top