Teams 2023 Fantasy - Rate My Preseason Team

[WaynesWorld19]

​

 

[11kgm]

Just waiting for Bevo to do something stupid now he hates being upstaged

Bailey Smith full forward would do that

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Bailey Smith full forward would do that

 

[happy_eagle]

Marshall will be having Tommy Campbell with him according to Ross

Surely this is just until they get some tall players back ?

 

[11kgm]

Surely this is just until they get some tall players back ?

Also could be because Romo is a shit ruckman, Rods wants a good tap Ruckman

 

[11kgm]

View attachment 1629654

Macrae to wing and McLean guts would just about make me cry

 

[wahooo]

Fairly settled on this as my starting squad.

Greatest concern is who will score better out of Long/Greene for F8.



Edit: greatest concern is now Marshall, ty Ross.

 

[happy_eagle]

Also could be because Romo is a s**t ruckman, Rods wants a good tap Ruckman

Its probably too late to restructure the rucks, and everyone will be starting Marshall.

At least in this format we can give it a couple of weeks and then make a call if we need to trade.

 

[11kgm]

But wait there is more coming

 

[Gunf]

Its probably too late to restructure the rucks, and everyone will be starting Marshall.

At least in this format we can give it a couple of weeks and then make a call if we need to trade.

Wanna bet my finger is on the reset tam button now

 

[SM]

Could go RoMo to English I think..

EDIT: Nope. had it in my head they were similar price.

 

[Zevon]

I was dubious about Marshall earlier in the pre season when St Kilda talls were all dropping like flies, so I’m not as attached to him as some might be.

Question is who on earth would we replace him with anyway??

Guess I could go with Witts or Darcy to accompany English.

 

[Dupogi]

Have come to the conclusion, that I have no conclusions for the bottom half of my backline/the 400K guys and who will work out - so have gone f*ck it and gone with all 4 of them.

Rationale here is, I know that my backline is a mess, and I know I can't predict who will make it, so I'm not even gonna try. Same goes with the 400K guys. One of them will f*ck up, but I don't know who at this stage. So I'm just gonna go low risk/high reward, bank some cash, have a solid bench, and then flick whoever of Hollands or Phillips performs better in Round 1, on to the field in place of 1 of them.

Jones has Best 22 security and looks to be intercepting well based on the PS match, so that's enough for me tbh. I need Wilmot on field, as rookie space is running out, and I think he'll be the best of the 3 given his half back/wing role.

Darcy will become English down the track if need be, but English's draw to start the season is awful, so I can't bring myself to have him in there from the get go - especially after his PS niggles.

Haven't changed this for days now, and knowing that I have spare cash to essentially flick one of the rooks on field and then upgrade one of my defensive options, fills me with great comfort - rather than trying to predict the future. Think this is close to my final team now:

View attachment 1629629

258K remaining

Pretty similar, i think i like JHF over either Bruhn or Mclean though.
What are your thoughts on not selecting JHF?

 

[Gunf]

I was dubious about Marshall earlier in the pre season when St Kilda talls were all dropping like flies, so I’m not as attached to him as some might be.

Question is who on earth would we replace him with anyway??

Guess I could go with Witts or Darcy to accompany English.

If Hawks name Meek sole ruck i may do something crazy. so send help if they do

 

[tigs2010]

If Hawks name Meek sole ruck i may do something crazy. so send help if they do

If Meek is sole ruck he will have 99.9% ownership amongst active teams. Only TedDougChris would leave him out

 

[Zevon]

If Hawks name Meek sole ruck i may do something crazy. so send help if they do

Hope they name 3 rucks just to slap you back to reality!!!

 

[tigs2010]

Hope they name 3 rucks just to slap you back to reality!!!

That’s round 2 with nowhere to move lol

 

[Gunf]

That’s round 2 with nowhere to move lol

Surely by round 2 we can all jump on the Bevo super ruck Helmet

 

[TheRednWhite]

Marshall and Ladhams were my rucks....Hickey returning sooner than I expected and Marshall not solo ruck has thrown the team structure into disarray

I've blown the team up now, all the pieces are left scattered on the floor

Tonight will be a busy night after work

 

[TedDougChris]

If Meek is sole ruck he will have 99.9% ownership amongst active teams. Only TedDougChris would leave him out

Oh no - I fell for Preuss last year, not falling for that shit again !!

 

[Fyfetheknife]

This team has 293k left in the bank. What do I do with it?
(Serong stays)

 

[Mezzoculo]

 

[FlowersByIrene]

This team has 293k left in the bank. What do I do with it?
(Serong stays)


View attachment 1629682

Me personally? I would put Dunkley back in the forward line and turn Errol into an Uber midfielder. This is very similar to my side with that move.

 

[tigs2010]

Have I got the right Reuben Ginbey in my team? Is there 2 different blokes? WTF?

 

[11kgm]

View attachment 1629684View attachment 1629685

Have I got the right Reuben Ginbey in my team? Is there 2 different blokes? WTF?

Gingers are a rare breed because they don't breed so there can't be 2

 

[tigs2010]

Gingers are a rare breed because they don't breed so there can't be 2

But why is there 2? Both taken off desktop version lol