MRP / Trib. 2023 MRP Lotto

[giantroo]

You forgot the North Melbourne factor ..... 3 weeks

Of course, now known as the North MRP loading.

 

[Samsquanch]

Of course, now known as the North MRP loading.

Even if they say contact was high (which is marginally possible) the impact was low and the action was careless.

Honestly, it makes no difference to me if he's suspended apart from the point you make, which is that there is an inconsisteny in the way the AFL MRP operates, which is extremely frustrating.

 

[RHLK]

Didn't he attempt to soccer the ball before the swinging arm?

 

[rickety]

Didn't he attempt to soccer the ball before the swinging arm?

I think you're right. He's just following the example set by his Captain, that being about 10 seconds behind

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Didn't he attempt to soccer the ball before the swinging arm?

Indeed. You'd think if he's cited, we should run with the Ainsworth "nothing to see here" defence.

 

[Harris 10]

I’m not fussed if JHF gets a week, it’s all part of learning and it not going to impact our finals chances.
I remember a young Carey getting himself into trouble over undisciplined acts early days, he turned out pretty good(well kind of).

 

[giantroo]

Point of contact with Kelly's chin






Val Keating

View attachment jhf mrp.m4v

 

[gokangas]

Point of contact with Kelly's chin

View attachment 1422877




Val Keating

View attachment 1422878

UNDER the chin - big difference. Kelly grabbed his temple like he had been shot by JFKs sniper on the grassy knoll. He will get a week.

 

[the flying ham]

Deserves a holiday

 

[Samsquanch]

Deserves a holiday

Kelly?

I agree that he staged, but it's a fine for that I think.

JHF will probably cop a week, although going by the criteria of high contact, low impact and careless, he will be fined as well.

If the MRP cites him for more that that it will clearly indicate that they are inconsistent, possibly verging on corrupt.

 

[giantroo]

UNDER the chin - big difference. Kelly grabbed his temple like he had been shot by JFKs sniper on the grassy knoll. He will get a week.

Nah, it was still his chin, under, over, doesn't matter, it still hit his chin. But like I mentioned earlier, Kelly was already heading in a downward motion so it could be graded as careless. The next part would be whether its assessed as low or medium impact.

 

[Only Forwards]

Nah, it was still his chin, under, over, doesn't matter, it still hit his chin. But like I mentioned earlier, Kelly was already heading in a downward motion so it could be graded as careless. The next part would be whether its assessed as low or medium impact.

View attachment 1422885

If graded careless would it mean:

Medium - one down to a fine
Low - lesser fine

 

[giantroo]

If graded careless would it mean:

Medium - one down to a fine
Low - lesser fine

Medium would be one week. He was also fined against the Blues for his strike on JSOS.



Jason Horne-Francis, North Melbourne, has been charged with Striking Jack Silvagni, Carlton, during the third quarter of the Round Seven match between Carlton and North Melbourne played at Marvel Stadium on Saturday, April 30, 2022.

In summary, he can accept a $2000 sanction with an early plea.

Based on the available evidence, the incident was assessed as Intentional Conduct, Low Impact, Body Contact. The incident was classified as a $3000 sanction as a first offence. The player can accept a $2000 sanction with an early plea.

View attachment Untitled 2.mov

 

[shinboner magic]

Should cop two weeks












For not knocking that traitors head clean off

 

[Roosurgence]

Should cop two weeks












For not knocking that traitors head clean off

I just want us know where was Kayne?

Didn’t Noble tell us about his wonderful tagging job, yet Kelly was able to run free and dispose under no pressure on many occasions.

One of the worst hard tagging jobs I have ever seen.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Just a fine
Low impact
Kelly was fine also

 

[Tiberius]

I just want us know where was Kayne?

Didn’t Noble tell us about his wonderful tagging job, yet Kelly was able to run free and dispose under no pressure on many occasions.

One of the worst hard tagging jobs I have ever seen.

It was almost laughable at the ground. The boys had clearly decided or been told that they needed to bring the heat to Kelly. He was constantly knocked over after disposing of the ball, gently bumped into and at one point I think Hayden may have thrown him a dirty look. Kelly's response was generally to laugh it off and go and get the ball.
As for Turner, he didn't even go for the ball several times when he was the closest to it. He was basically escorting Kelly around the ground.

 

[Roosurgence]

It was almost laughable at the ground. The boys had clearly decided or been told that they needed to bring the heat to Kelly. He was constantly knocked over after disposing of the ball, gently bumped into and at one point I think Hayden may have thrown him a dirty look. Kelly's response was generally to laugh it off and go and get the ball.
As for Turner, he didn't even go for the ball several times when he was the closest to it. He was basically escorting Kelly around the ground.

From my view at the ground it looked as if Kayne was practising Social Distancing.

For Noble to praise that tag, was laughable.

 

[Val Keating]

Point of contact with Kelly's chin

View attachment 1422877




Val Keating

View attachment 1422878

Legend. Looks like he just clipped him. A week it is.

Assuming they grade it intentional

 

[Val Keating]

Just a fine
Low impact
Kelly was fine also

The lowest they can grade it is careless/low impact/high contact - fine

If they grade it intentional it’s a week.

 

[the flying ham]

Kelly?

I agree that he staged, but it's a fine for that I think.

JHF will probably cop a week, although going by the criteria of high contact, low impact and careless, he will be fined as well.

If the MRP cites him for more that that it will clearly indicate that they are inconsistent, possibly verging on corrupt.

Jason deserves a week. Shit act

 

[DarkPhoenix]

Commentary team knew it was borderline at best on the day, proved when they started talking about how it should be looked at under "potential to harm" rather than the standard grading.

My question to others, if he gets a week(s), would the club going into bat and challenging it send a message that he's wanted? Or would it just be potentially pissing away 10k.

 

[giantroo]

Commentary team knew it was borderline at best on the day, proved when they started talking about how it should be looked at under "potential to harm" rather than the standard grading.

My question to others, if he gets a week(s), would the club going into bat and challenging it send a message that he's wanted? Or would it just be potentially pissing away 10k.

We would have to be absolutely certain we can win if we challenge. It will cost us 10k from the soft cap if we lose.

 

[DarkPhoenix]

We would have to be absolutely certain we can win if we challenge. It will cost us 10k from the soft cap if we lose.

Yes, the question is, does that 10k move us closer to a signature, and is it worth it?

 

[Mav]

We would have to be absolutely certain we can win if we challenge. It will cost us 10k from the soft cap if we lose.

with all the resignations you'd think we would have a spare 10K in the cap.

But for me, it was a snipers act. A late whack that deserves a week.