Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[JuddgementDay]

BCox vs DCameron

POD vs Plodder no more (DPP appeals)

 

[Scythe94]

BCox vs DCameron

POD vs Plodder no more (DPP appeals)

Cameron

 

[SloppyJoe]

BCox vs DCameron

POD vs Plodder no more (DPP appeals)

Yeah, definitely DC

 

[Dundalis]

Worpel v Chandler?

Latter leaves me an extra 180k in the bank (300k vs 115k for trades next week), but the former gives me the extra points on field. Feel like they both have similar money making potential, but it only takes one big score from Chandler to make that money much faster. Very torn on this one, when Hopper is back Worpel would be my M7, Callaghan M8, with both Ashcroft and Mackenzie on my bench (lot of cash and potentially decent points there). Of course Callaghan will be out if he doesn't score well this week.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Worpel v Chandler?

Latter leaves me an extra 180k in the bank (300k vs 115k for trades next week), but the former gives me the extra points on field. Feel like they both have similar money making potential, but it only takes one big score from Chandler to make that money much faster. Very torn on this one, when Hopper is back Worpel would be my M7, Callaghan M8, with both Ashcroft and Mackenzie on my bench (lot of cash and potentially decent points there). Of course Callaghan will be out if he doesn't score well this week.

Chandler in that situation.

 

[Korupt]

I have Witts and Marshall as R1 and R2.

But seriously considering getting Darcy Cameron in as a forward. Though it means I miss Ziebell. So it comes down to:

D. Cameron vs Ziebell + $110k?

I'm in the same predicament and leaning towards Cameron. Will finish a better forward and has a safer role imo.

 

[Wellsy35]

Missing Mckenna, and have enough cash to turn any of my lower performing rookies to him via DPP.

Who would you turn into mckenna from:

Cowan, Baker, Constable, Greene/ skip mckenna and just hold.

Constable looks like he’s getting dropped, so maybe him?

 

[kaiserchief13]

Who would you start at F6 out of these players this week: Greene, Davey, Phillipou or Caminiti?

 

[Dalsantowhatastar]

H.Young, Naicos and Setterfield/Ziebell
Or
Docherty, Naicos and Chesser

Thoughts?

 

[kaiserchief13]

H.Young, Naicos and Setterfield/Ziebell
Or
Docherty, Naicos and Chesser

Thoughts?

1st one easily if Young is fit

 

[Mr Meow]

H.Young, Naicos and Setterfield/Ziebell
Or
Docherty, Naicos and Chesser

Thoughts?

First one. The difference between Setterfield/Ziebell and Chesser could be 60 plus points. Doubt Docherty, as good as he is, will outscore Young by that much.

 

[pieman123]

H Young or Docherty, which plodder to keep?

 

[Scythe94]

H Young or Docherty, which plodder to keep?

Docherty

 

[evo]

Rowston v Phillips? Assuming Phillips gets picked even though LDU is back.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Rowston v Phillips? Assuming Phillips gets picked even though LDU is back.

Simpkin to come back as well.

Can we extend it to Rowston vs Phillips vs Ryan?

 

[toxic]

Rowston v Phillips? Assuming Phillips gets picked even though LDU is back.

Bytel is the one

 

[Mavefromdelburn]

Thoughts on these for my 2 teams:

Team 1:
Ginbey and Bont to Day and Mitchell

Team 2:
Goater and DCAM to Bowes and Nank

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Team 1:
Ginbey and Bont to Day and Mitchell

 

[kyri]

Thoughts on these for my 2 teams:

Team 1:
Ginbey and Bont to Day and Mitchell

Team 2:
Goater and DCAM to Bowes and Nank

You're joking right?

 

[Dundalis]

Simpkin to come back as well.

Can we extend it to Rowston vs Phillips vs Ryan?

Assuming Samson? With the 27 in the rolling avg for 2 weeks doesn't feel like an option. As someone who doesn't have Oscar Baker Im curious about Phillips v Rowston v Baker.

I know the latter two have the better JS, but don't know about scoring potential from here on out to make that 150k.

 

[Dundalis]

Thoughts on these for my 2 teams:

Team 1:
Ginbey and Bont to Day and Mitchell

Team 2:
Goater and DCAM to Bowes and Nank

If I had Day and Mitchell in my team, I would literally trade them to Ginbey and Bont if I didn't have them.

 

[weltschmerz]

Flanders gotta go. Van Rooyen, Amartey, or Chandler?

 

[pieman123]

Coniglio and Grundy or Gulden and Nankervis?

 

[kyri]

Coniglio and Grundy or Gulden and Nankervis?

I hate that I traded in Cogs after Round 1.

Save yourself the heartache, go Gulden and Nank.

 

[PoopingHindi]

Coniglio and Grundy or Gulden and Nankervis?

Grundy is basically booking in a trade later on and Cogs may be cheaper when upgrade season begins.
…so the other option.