Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[No eye deer]

Sinclair vs Sicily?
Or go cheap Charlie and get Dale, taking all the kick outs without JJ.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Sinclair vs Sicily?
Or go cheap Charlie and get Dale, taking all the kick outs without JJ.

I might take a punt on Dale but only because I need the cash.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I might take a punt on Dale but only because I need the cash.

Judd_Magic this man is going to need the keys to the No Trades Club, can you sort him out?

 

[SC fish]

Sinclair vs Sicily?
Or go cheap Charlie and get Dale, taking all the kick outs without JJ.

Am thinking the same as A Bit Dusty and going bargain basement Dale.

I'm also looking at Wines for the same reason

 

[Judd_Magic]

Judd_Magic this man is going to need the keys to the No Trades Club, can you sort him out?

I'll hand him the keys, a box of Cuban cigars and the finest bottle of scotch there is. That should make A Bit Dusty welcome into the no trades left club.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

I'll hand him the keys, a box of Cuban cigars and the finest bottle of scotch there is. That should make A Bit Dusty welcome into the no trades left club.

 

[VainGlorious]

Judd_Magic this man is going to need the keys to the No Trades Club, can you sort him out?

I am well and truly leading that race if I toast all three this week, m8.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I am well and truly leading that race if I toast all three this week, m8.

View attachment 1694036

 

[SC fish]

I'll hand him the keys, a box of Cuban cigars and the finest bottle of scotch there is. That should make A Bit Dusty welcome into the no trades left club.

 

[Kuuz]

Am thinking the same as A Bit Dusty and going bargain basement Dale.

I'm also looking at Wines for the same reason

Wines very tempted by - his scoring over the last several seasons is pretty much high 90s to low 100s. Good value, despite a small role change of being pushed more to the outside.

Dale I just cannot trust still, just because I do not trust Bevo at all. Still, insane value just less of a track record.

 

[JPod_31]

Libba v Serong v Walsh

 

[Scythe94]

Libba v Serong v Walsh

Depends on your bye situation. Libba (R15) and Serong (R12) are similar, so go with whichever works better.

Both are better options than Walsh IMO. His role fluctuates too much.

 

[Changa10]

Am thinking the same as A Bit Dusty and going bargain basement Dale.

I'm also looking at Wines for the same reason

I started Dale and traded him after Round 2 to Naicos after he started with scores of 56 and 83. Thought I had made a mistake when he tonned up the next two (mind you Daicos went 109 & 151 those two rounds), but then he has dished out the below since!



Absolute rubbish until last week.

I'm not going anywhere near him.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I started Dale and traded him after Round 2 to Naicos after he started with scores of 56 and 83. Thought I had made a mistake when he tonned up the next two (mind you Daicos went 109 & 151 those two rounds), but then he has dished out the below since!

View attachment 1695517

Absolute rubbish until last week.

I'm not going anywhere near him.

Fairly sure he's record at Mars was pretty good..

Can only get a kick in space

 

[rocker_oz33]

Libba v Serong v Walsh

Does fyfe back in the mids ...take chips away from Ser right ..or ser wrong

 

[SC fish]

I started Dale and traded him after Round 2 to Naicos after he started with scores of 56 and 83. Thought I had made a mistake when he tonned up the next two (mind you Daicos went 109 & 151 those two rounds), but then he has dished out the below since!

View attachment 1695517

Absolute rubbish until last week.

I'm not going anywhere near him.

The hope is that he does well with JJ OUT

 

[Hack_Watts]

The hope is that he does well with JJ OUT

But JJ will be back, right?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

But JJ will be back, right?

At least 8 weeks

 

[Sketi]

Stewart vs Sicily +30k?

 

[SC fish]

Stewart vs Sicily +30k?

Not much between them, Stewart probably has the better bye, Sicily cheaper and with lower BE so arguably better value. I have both

 

[Northernsoul74]

Stewart vs Sicily +30k?

Stewart. Bye.

 

[No eye deer]

Steele vs Sinclair.
Can’t afford Sicily.
Day would swing to miss for now if I get Sinclair, so structure would remain the same.

Either one of those or get Fyfe over Humphries and get Sinclair, but I don’t think I have the balls for that one!

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Steele vs Sinclair.
Can’t afford Sicily.
Day would swing to miss for now if I get Sinclair, so structure would remain the same.

Either one of those or get Fyfe over Humphries and get Sinclair, but I don’t think I have the balls for that one!

Sinclair a waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay lower injury risk.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Steele vs Sinclair.
Can’t afford Sicily.
Day would swing to miss for now if I get Sinclair, so structure would remain the same.

Either one of those or get Fyfe over Humphries and get Sinclair, but I don’t think I have the balls for that one!

Sinclair ..
One of the tv shows showed he's spilt.
1st Q.95% def
2Q 85 def
3rd 50/50.
Last Q 85% mid.

I just tired remember the spilt ..I prob spudded it up...but he starts in def...ends in the mids ..

 

[lids2richo]

Merrett vs Steele vs Neale vs Butters? (feel like Butters may be a bit over priced)