Opinion 2023 Player X vs Y vs Z

[TDS7]

Serong- he'll get Hodor back soon

Perfect, now I have someone to blame if it all goes wrong. Thanks!

 

[toxic]

Perfect, now I have someone to blame if it all goes wrong. Thanks!

Are you my wife?

 

[Axly]

Harrison vs Fletcher

 

[SC fish]

Harrison vs Fletcher

Jeepers neither have decent JS. Fletcher looked good last week but I'd go Harrison as he's cheaper and on the bubble. Might also get a gig next week as JDG and Sidebottom will still be out

 

[Axly]

Jeepers neither have decent JS. Fletcher looked good last week but I'd go Harrison as he's cheaper and on the bubble. Might also get a gig next week as JDG and Sidebottom will still be out

Harrison was named on field this week, which seemed like a good sign

 

[VainGlorious]

Laird vs Petracca

Laird

 

[VainGlorious]

Ok peeps, real talk here.

I can either go Shitkins and Sturt to E.Hewett and Yeo… today.

OR

Wait a week and go Weddle and Seamus to HH & TarrynT.

Both pretty stinky options but am looking for bargain basement back-up to play the looping game with.

 

[VainGlorious]

Ignoring byes, who do we think averages more from here.

Keays vs Himmelberg?

I am getting Himmelberg next week, but if MJ isn't picked then could be swayed to go Keays early.

Flip a coin, mate.

 

[evo]

Ok peeps, real talk here.

I can either go Shitkins and Sturt to E.Hewett and Yeo… today.

OR

Wait a week and go Weddle and Seamus to HH & TarrynT.

Both pretty stinky options but am looking for bargain basement back-up to play the looping game with.

Second option is way better for mine.

 

[VainGlorious]

Second option is way better for mine.

Yep. It absolutely is.

I’ll take the points/rank hit this week.

It’s not like I’m ranked that high anyway, but I’d like to salvage the season somewhat if I can.

Sturt to Hewett is not really worth a trade, but gets me an extra warm body this week. Decisions decisions

 

[evo]

Yep. It absolutely is.

I’ll take the points/rank hit this week.

It’s not like I’m ranked that high anyway, but I’d like to salvage the season somewhat if I can.

Sturt to Hewett is not really worth a trade, but gets me an extra warm body this week. Decisions decisions

I ve traded in a donut with Dewar this week rather than get Marics 30 or 40 but have him clogging up my DPP swingingability for the rest of the season

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Laird

Petracca locked out VG ya kent I went Laird though.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Thoughts on Anderson vs DC please?

Anderson - He looks like a solid ton, with the potential big upside. Will Touk return affect his scoring?

DC - He's value and good for ruck coverage. But, do rucks really have a 1 week injury? I'm thinking if they are injured, you'll need to trade them out anyway, as the ruck injuries are often more severe than 1 week

 

[SC fish]

DC - He's value and good for ruck coverage. But, do rucks really have a 1 week injury? I'm thinking if they are injured, you'll need to trade them out anyway, as the ruck injuries are often more severe than 1 week

Can't do this if you have no trades, or are hanging on to your last one or two. In those circumstances a R1 or R2 injury can then be covered by a FWD bench player covering for DC while he's covering the injured/suspended ruck

 

[Kadog]

Ok peeps, real talk here.

I can either go Shitkins and Sturt to E.Hewett and Yeo… today.

OR

Wait a week and go Weddle and Seamus to HH & TarrynT.

Both pretty stinky options but am looking for bargain basement back-up to play the looping game with.

HH TT

 

[Kadog]

Thoughts on Anderson vs DC please?

Anderson - He looks like a solid ton, with the potential big upside. Will Touk return affect his scoring?

DC - He's value and good for ruck coverage. But, do rucks really have a 1 week injury? I'm thinking if they are injured, you'll need to trade them out anyway, as the ruck injuries are often more severe than 1 week

Agree with Fish. Low trades the smart play is ruck cover with DCam

 

[King Max]

Robertson or Windhager?
My last upgrade is M8, which is covered by one of the above plus Cincotta & Wardlaw. Playing for cashies, so in no rush for final upgrade until last rookies fatten up nicely for a last Uber premium.

 

[shockmaster]

Ryan vs Ridley?

 

[VainGlorious]

HH TT

Yep, cept I will be holding Seamus and turfing Shitkins.

 

[SC fish]

Yep, cept I will be holding Seamus and turfing Shitkins.

I'm planning to hold Seamus for the rest of the year (to cover DEF) along with Wilmot (to cover MID) and Windhager (to cover FWD)

 

[DaveyBoy123]

I'm planning to hold Seamus for the rest of the year (to cover DEF) along with Wilmot (to cover MID) and Windhager (to cover FWD)

Borrrrring.

My cover is some bloke named Gilbee, some bloke named Bennetts & some bloke named Madden

 

[King Max]

Ryan vs Ridley?

Ryan has 3/4 final games at home, if that helps.

 

[gh172]

Having trouble deciding between trading in D Moore or D Cameron? I know Cameron provides ruck cover but I have a git feeling that Moore will be seeing more midfield time and could really increase his scoring potential.

Sent from my SM-G986B using Tapatalk

 

[shockmaster]

Should I grab Harrison or wait for Hewett/Fletcher next week? Who's most likely to stick around a while?

 

[toxic]

Should I grab Harrison or wait for Hewett/Fletcher next week? Who's most likely to stick around a while?

Wait